Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Loved this musical. I watched the first bows in Broadway. It never disappoints.
Chemistry between the two of them was awesome. It was so funny. I loved the music.
Such a great show! Awesome jokes especially if you’re familiar with NYC!! A very light hearted, fun, funny show but also emotional! Cast is amazing, set is so cool, some great songs!! Go into it expecting to laugh and have a good time!!
A really fun musical especially if you have context about or live in nyc. Creative stage design :) (Edited)
Just as fun the 2nd time round!
might be my favorite show right now
Two person show. Really enjoyed it. Great singing with a cool set. Will see how it evolves on Broadway.
2nd time. I think I liked it even more this time.
Lots of laughs, lots of fun, lots of emotion. Wonderful and enjoyable production.
Hilarious and brilliantly acted. The music is silly, but it works and it embellishes the plot. Bravo!
This show is brilliant!! Amazing score, the chemistry between the actors was convincing, and it reminded me what a privilege it is to live in NYC
Great performance from the two main performers. Very funny and sweet. I just wish the storyline was a little more elaborate. Overall, this was a very pleasant evening.
Lovely show! A little bare bones but the music has something very sentimental and charming to it!
Very sweet, silly and funny. The actors were great, but the music was just so-so, in my opinion. Still, I appreciated the joy and charm this show brought to the theatre.
I enjoyed it. I thought it was super funny. Love the opening song. Really great show. 🗽🌆🎂🎭
For a two person show, it was AMAZING!!! Extremely funny, and talented! So sad it’s leaving :(
Not super memorable, but a fun and very funny show to see. Definitely enjoyed it.
Definitely worth a watch. It was a cute musical and had a ton of nods to NYC. I feel like it would do really well in a black box setting compared to a full a theatre.
This was such a fun musical. I wish strangers carried a cake in all major cities, as this feels like its best suited for tourists and first time city guestS. Either way, it was so much fun! (Edited)
141–160 of 659 comments
Went in knowing nothing about this show and absolutely LOVED it!!! The performances and the storyline were perfection! Can’t wait to go back and see it again!