Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Wonderful production! The set design is amazing, being able to transform “luggage” into a restaurant booth and the Plaza Hotel was ingenious! The two actors are able to hold a pause to increase the effect. Purchasing through this app was easy. Front row balcony has its challenges. The bar along the edge was at my eye level so I had to continue to move forward, back, up and down to follow the action. Just a warning for those of average height.
every single person needs to see this show right now. i laughed the ENTIRE TIME. i was iffy about it because there’s only two actors and the same stage setup the entire time, but oh my god did they PERFORM. such a fun and happy story i was smiling ear to ear from start to finish. the actors are phenomenal and the songs are so catchy. they both came out for stagedoor which was so appreciated on a two show day and they were so so nice and pleasant. as for our seats, we were in the very last row of center balc and it was the perfect view. high up, yes, but you didn’t miss a thing. the theater is tiny so any seat is a good seat. 10/10 would absolutely see again
Got to see my amazing friend lead this show I cried so hard at the end!
Simply delightful. Funny and genuinely endearing. I loved how creatively the set was used. To be completely honest, I was skeptical going into this show. Mentally, I had it billed as "the new MHE" and I was iffy about the music, story, and rom-com aspect. All that to say I ended up loving it. Vincent Michael was in for Sam Tutty, and before the show started I was initially disappointed not to see the original cast. That feeling disappeared almost immediately. He was charming as could be, and both leads delivered outstanding performances. I would highly recommend this show. For those who might be on the fence like I was, I say give it a chance.
The first night of previews, and aside from a few moments that felt like first-night kinks to work out, the show was FANTASTIC. I’ve seen and heard feedback suggesting it could be cut to a much shorter show - I see the argument here and do think there’s room to shave down, but I really appreciated how much space was allowed to build comedic anticipation and create what felt like a genuine flow of getting to know a new person. There were certain moments that could’ve benefitted from a different emotional intensity or a few script changes to make the emotional arcs feel more worth their weight, but in most moments the performances came across as authentic and grounded in the truth of their characters. The songs and vocal performances soared above my expectations - it’s hard to go back to the soundtrack when so many nuanced moments and lines were delivered differently in person, and absolutely for the better. Overall not the most refined show I’ve ever seen on Broadway (granted, it was the first night of previews so I look forward to hopefully return after a while to compare). But I laughed often, I shed a tear or two, I smiled, I ached, I couldn’t help but tap my foot and hum the tunes through midtown after the show - I was truly entertained. A fun and heartfelt show that’s well worth seeing. :)
Did rush! Got there at 6:40 (didn't have to do that because people didn't come until 9 😭) but was worth it regardless! Got second row for $42. Overall, it was hilarious!! So funny and the story takes such a turn! I loved it so much and I definitely will see it again with friends next time.
Won the lottery for this show and were in the first row by the stage. You so miss some staging sitting that close but i did not feel it hindered my overall experience of the show. The show it self is so fun, well staged and performed ! I had such a good time at this show! It’s a great original musical
I originally saw the show with 2 understudies, who were amazing, but had to go back to see Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts. This show is so special. The comedic timing is so tight snd thr chemistry between Sam and Christiani is undeniable. Sam’s Dougal is goofy, optimistic, and endlessly charming. Christiani’s Robin plays so perfectly off of him, her cold demeanor just melts away as the show progresses. Like Operation Mincemeat, this show is equal parts belly laugh funny and painfully sincere.
funny, romantic, touching. cried and laughed harder than i ever have in the theatre.
wait it was actually so good and genuinely really sad. I did not expect to cry watching this…
This was a surprising delight. Did not know what to expect, but this production is full of heart, and every joke lands flawlessly. Brilliant staging, songs are catchy and sung beautifully. We saw Austin Colburn (understudy) as Dougal and he blew us away, so charming, and outstanding chemistry with Christiani Pitts (Robin). Looking forward to seeing this again.
This show was so funny!! Both leads were so charming and had such great chemistry that I couldn’t look away. I think I needed to see this show at this stage of my life because the themes really resonated with me and by the end I couldn’t stop crying. The score wasn’t my favorite but some of the songs were very catchy and I find myself humming them here and there. Definitely recommend if you need a good laugh with a side of life contemplation lol, especially as an early 20 something college graduate who has no idea what they want to do with their life 🙃
Feeling under the weather and this was a great pick me up. Very strong catchy score, Christiani Pitts and Vincent Michael (u/s for Sam Tutty) were fantastic, you’ll be streaming this one in Spotify shortly after!
went to this show on an impulse with family and it was soo funny it was so cool to see that it was only two people sam and christiani are amazing 🥰🥰
one of the funniest shows i've seen so far. definitely surpassed my expectations (i was, admittedly, skeptical). Seating Tip: the mezz's incline (from row-to-row) is quite low, so if someone tall is sitting in front of you, it really does obstruct your signtline. ask for a booster seat! (Edited)
So nice had to see it twice and got to see Vincent as Dougal this time around. He was just as amazing as Sam and brought such a unique performance to the role. I was glad to see he got the crowd support that day too. Love, love, love this show!
Seats were a great view, theatre feels intimate and cozy. And the show was AMAZING! Very interesting stage design and absolutely knock out cast!
Such a fun and lovable show. The songs will be stuck in your head and the mezzanine has amazing leg room for a broadway theatre as someone who is 6’
1–20 of 659 comments
I didn’t know anything about the show when I went in, I will say I thought the plot was going to be a little different but it was really funny, gave us a lot of laughs, and overall I had a great time. The music was amazing, and the actors did phenomenally. The railing for the balcony did hinder a bit of the performance for me considering I am only 5’ tall, the bar kind of cut right through the middle of my view so I was leaning forward quite a lot which easily solved that problem, however was a little uncomfortable after a while. There is also no real leg space being that close to the railing, but that was expected. Really it was just an overall amazing time filled with a lot of laughs and great music.