Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Adore this show. It’s so witty and charming and soooo New York. The two leads have great chemistry and beautiful voices. A few times in the 2nd act I got a little misty eyed. I have already seen it twice and will probably go back again. This is a perfect show for a date night. It’s a must see.
Loved, could have cried, felt like it was written for me, also laughed a lot.
I saw it twice and loved it! Funny and heartwarming ! Sat in the orchestra and also first row of the center mezzanine.
This was fabulous! I was laughing the whole time. While some of the plot was weird; like why are they kind of interested in each other when they are about to become family? This play was so worth the watch. I would definitely see it again just for the British actor! (Edited)
About ten minutes into Jimmy Barne & Kit Buchan’s TWO STRANGERS (CARRY A CAKE ACROSS NEW YORK), I realized my cheeks hurt from grinning so hard. That feeling never let up. At first glance, it seems like a light, breezy romantic comedy, but there’s a quietly profound emotional core that sneaks up on you. The premise is classic rom-com territory: Dougal flies in from England for his father’s wedding, while Robin, connected to the bride, ends up tasked with collecting him. What begins as a simple errand evolves into a 36-hour sprint across the city, filled with late-night conversations, subway mishaps, and the kind of unexpected moments that force two strangers to reflect on their own lives. New York itself is a character here. Every hurried cab ride, every crowded subway moment, and every accidental encounter propels these two characters forward. The city’s chaos mirrors their emotional journeys, and Tim Jackson’s direction lets the story breathe, pacing the highs and quiet, intimate moments beautifully. Sam Tutty’s Dougal is sunshine wrapped in charming awkwardness; you can see both his boundless optimism and the cost of his over-eager heart. Christiani Pitts as Robin exudes restless energy, the sense of someone running on autopilot who’s about to realize how tired she really is. Together, their chemistry is magnetic, and the humor naturally blossoms alongside genuine empathy. The set design is brilliant. Soutra Gilmour turns simple stacks of suitcases into midtown streets, subway cars, coffee shops, and more. Every inch of the stage is used creatively, transforming minimal elements into a dynamic, fully realized world. It’s clever, compact, and endlessly inventive. And the music…oh, the music. Each song captures a facet of modern adulthood: the excitement, loneliness, and longing for something real while still being catchy, playful, and heartfelt. I found myself humming the tunes long after leaving the theater. What stays with me most is the authenticity of this musical. There’s no pretense, no overblown melodrama, just two imperfect people navigating a day they never expected, and in the process, discovering honesty, connection, and maybe even a little magic. The final scene is breathtaking, and it leaves you wanting to be part of their world. Two Strangers (carry a cake across new york) is smart, funny, romantic, and deeply human. It’s the kind of musical you’ll want to see again and again.
Loved it even more the second time around. A fully original score. With a genuinely hilarious book. It’s hard not to walk out of this show in a great mood. The perfect show to see in New York.
this show is so near & dear to me. it made me fall in love with the city & made me fall in love with broadway. this is my second time seeing it and devastated that it’s the last. these actors are just phenomenal & their chemistry & stage presence is one of a kind. the vocals mixed with comedy is truly what makes it a perfect show. love love love love and love. 10 out of freaking 10 (Edited)
I cry it was so good (Edited)
such a heartwarming show! i laughed, cried, and could relate to a lot of what each character was feeling - abandonment, longing for love, but making the most out of life! i loved that it was a 2 person cast with a minimal set. music was engaging, the witty one liners had perfect, especially after an emotionally intense moment, and it being set in new york was just icing on the cake 😉 def see this show! 9/10 ⭐️
Quaint theater, fantastic performers! Aptly described as a love letter to New York. People who love the music in a musical will love it.
Thought is was going to be just silly but it had a deeper storyline I really enjoyed! And the comedy was brilliant! I’d love to see it again!
Great musical! The opening song was the best, and I found it to be emotional. Sam and Christiani both did a great job! It was funny and heartfelt - glad to have seen it! (Edited)
Second time was even better!! Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts are a joy to watch.
I really liked the story and the actors. They made me feel like I was really in the show experiencing the drama. The seat was great and easy to see.
Had SO much fun at this one. I was smiling and laughing the entire time and left the theater feeling giddy and happy.
Fun & quirky. I absolutely loved the usage of the stage and the limited space. The chemistry between the lead actors is undeniable.
My 10 year old daughter and I loved it, so amazingly comedic and clever and heartwarming. Great use of the set. Just a fun feel good show, you do not feel it is a 2 person cast due to the staging. Really is a wonderful play for New Yorkers and think tourists would appreciate it.
I texted my friend that I was having a blast at intermission and then texted her again after the show that I had a blast. I had so much of a blast I didn’t even know I used that word twice to describe the experience. SUCH A BLAST.
amazing!! don’t regret rushing this at all. christiani pitts and sam tutty are so great and nice! took my friend that isn’t into musicals to it and she laughed the entire time!
41–60 of 659 comments
Slightly obstructed but so sick to get up close like that!