Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Saw with Vincent playing Dougal and he was incredible!! Christiani was also amazing but I think we all knew that already. Highly reccomend
Funny show with incredible music. Both actors were great at the stage door as well. It’s really a shame they are closing on Broadway later this month.
One of the funniest musicals I’ve seen, Sam tutty and Christiani pitts are so incredibly talented. Sam really stood out to me for his charisma and commitment to the role that felt so natural. I would highly reccomend seeing this before it leaves in November. This is easily a new favorite for me.
Such an underrated show. I’m so impressed by the way this show managed to stay engaging with just 2 cast members and minimal set. The writing was impeccable and the songs were great. Both characters were understudied for my show but they were great! Highly recommend seeing this show before it closes!
Go watch if! Seats are tight, be ready to get cozy with your seat mates
Really cute and feel good show. Felt like it flew by and I loved the inventive set design. I wouldn’t say the music is super memorable but it definitely is fun and serves the story while you’re watching it.
If you’re an easy crier… bring tissues.
Cute show with lots of fun NY references. Saw it with understudy Vincent Michael, who was phenomenal.
So funny and a great time! The book is strong, the songs were more so a vehicle to move the plot along which I didn’t mind.
Really creative use of minimal set. Good songs and cute / light rom com
Great show with fantastic singing and good laughs. The set was so interesting and creative. Even though it was a two man show, it felt much more dynamic and there was never a dull moment.
Powerful vocals, inventive set design that calls on the imagination of the audience to conjure up parts of NYC, and good songs.
honestly just couldn’t stop smiling most of the time
Won the telecharge lottery! My seat was great and I loved being so close
Saw this in Boston and loved it! Very smart, cute set and amazing chemistry between the two actors. So many fun songs that have been on repeat in my car! If you enjoy a fun, rom-comeqsue vibe, you’ll love this show!
A funny and relatable musical! Sam Tutty stole my heart! He was absolutely phenomenal, charming, witty, and gave superb vocals! Christiani was perfectly cast and really showed off her vocals during multiple songs in the show. Would definitely recommend as a fun comedy!
it’s only first preview but I’m predicting best musical now anyway
Such a cute and fun show. I don’t watch a ton of romcoms but this felt pretty fresh and relatively unpredictable (Oops previously wrote a review for Art here) (Edited)
Loved watching as a New Yorker!! They both really carried the show :)
81–100 of 659 comments
Love Love Love!!! After seeing this it immediately became one of my favorite shows! I love the whole cast album and all the songs and listen to the soundtrack non-stop! I didn’t get to see Sam Tutty but Vincent was amazing! This was definitely my favorite show of last year! I love the two person play and how the incorporated the set for every scene!