Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
amazing view even from above! you can still see everything Seating Tip: no bad seat in the house ;) cast was amazing and the music and lighting was just unreal 🫶🏻 i so recommend seeing this fun rom com before its run sadly ends in november!! (Edited)
The main was absolutely phenomenal Sam Tutty should get a Tony for his amazing Performance! I highly recommend this show its so cute and is h just amazing!
Yeah! It’s a great simple story. Well done. Great performances. The cast was very gracious and kind after. Very grateful I got to see this. Simple. Thoughtful. Funny.
super cute story and musical numbers. set was super interesting. they did so much with such a small space.
The music was fine but the book was amazing. I laughed so much!!!
Absolutely loved the show. Funny and heartwarming. Had a smile in my face almost the entire show.
This musical has all the warmth that a New York holiday needs. The songs are quirky in the best way, leaving you wanting to go back to learn the lyrics. The two leads carry the whole thing with ease thanks to their chemistry and expert comedic timing. I wouldn't be surprised to see Sam Tutty snag a Tony nom. Sure, it’s a predictable rom-com of a musical, but a nice escape with predictable joy is exactly what you need during an NYC winter.
Songs were very catchy and the story was cute - I giggled a lottttt. The story itself had a lot of parallels to Maybe Happy Ending which was unexpected and interesting
I was surprised by how much I liked this show! The characters were actually extremely likable, the score was pretty, and it had one of the coolest sets I’ve ever seen.
It was great!! I wish there was more story and more cast. But I loved it so funny and good songs. Any seat is great!
My favorite show of the Broadway season and one of my favorite musicals of the past decade. A truly charming and moving score coupled with heartfelt and charismatic performances from two emerging actors with dynamite chemistry. Don’t be fooled by people who call this a romcom on stage. It’s that and so much more and will bring you to tears with its sincerity and heart.
Actually hilarious. Went in cold and what a lovely surprise!! An ode to NYC I was not expecting. Heartwarming, comedic and well performed!
saw phoenix best's robin debut and she was amazing!! sam tutty is hilarious! this show was so funny and i loved all of it!
I expected this to be super cute (and it was) but I did not expect it to be so funny. I adored this show! (Edited)
Really enjoyed this show - Sam and Christiani are hilarious and have great chemistry on stage. Their character development was heartwarming
Saw this at at the American Repertory Theater (A.R.T.) in Cambridge, MA only in June 2025. Fun show, earnest acting & singing, loved the polly pocket set design.
I’ve seen this show when it premiered in Kiln Theatre and on the West End and it is one of the best musicals I have EVER seen
Was a phenomenal take on tourist and local taking on the city with real life thrown in the mix
Oh my God this is SO CHARMING. I don’t usually even like romcoms and I am obsessed. I hope it catches on so I can see it many more times. (Edited)
101–120 of 659 comments
Fun play. But it’s closing now. Enjoyed it. Seat was a little too far off to the side.