Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Wasn’t expecting to like it so much. When o went the 2 understudies were in it. What a great pair and the story is truly heartfelt and them leading to friendship love it recommend highly
my friend and i were having the time of our lives; the music is just ok in my opinion, but christiani and sam (their vocals, line deliveries, and comedic timing) really sold the show. funny and worth a watch!!
I was giggling and kicking my feet the entire time.
We saw the show with the standby go on for Dougal! Both he and she were fantastic and the show was delightful :) It’s funny and lighthearted with touching moments.
I’m sorry. Overhyped? Not a bit. Non-memorable tunes? Incorrect. Predictable? Bullshit. This show is the salve on the wounds of the world right now. Fresh, hilarious, adorable, TOTAL ear worm turnes from start to finish, an ending to die for with Christmas magic, and performances that best be getting ALL the award nominations. I’ve seen it 4 times in London, 3 in Boston, and the first New York preview, and have e more dates booked for post opening. Just go. You can thank me later. You’re welcome.
This show was adorable, I’m sad it’s closing. The story took a different turn than I was expecting, but I still absolutely loved it. The soundtrack was beautiful and those two are stars. Good view despite being in the mezzanine!
I didn’t want to go to this because the title didn’t grab me and I assumed that a 2 hander musical would not be able to keep my attention especially since I was on 4 hours of sleep. Boy was I wrong!!! This musical was phenomenal, and the acting/singing was as good as you can get. Not only was I pleasantly surprised, I can see myself going again with other people that I want to see it. Just goes to show that you should NEVER judge a musical by the title.
I’m surprised that I like this show so much. The premise seemed silly, but it was actually very heartfelt (and funny!). Even more surprising, I think this is one of the few shows with a stronger Act 2 than Act 1. I wouldn’t pay a ton of money to see it, but I do think it was great! (Edited)
I'd been waiting to see this for so long and after two missed opportunities finally did and was not disappointed. It was hilarious, heartwarming and so so beautiful. Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts both have incredible comic timing and their singing was top notch. I really enjoyed the set design of this one because it was so compact yet so clever (no spoilers) and the Orchestra in the background is just a fun touch.
if this show has zero fans i’m dead and i will be first to riot if this doesn’t win best musical i felt ALLLL the feelings in 2 hours and Sam Tutty’s energy truly is contagious i love him so much although there weren’t any like showstoppers in my opinion the music slapped (Edited)
I cringed for a lot of the first act, which I believe is a testament to how good the acting was. The second is a lot stronger, as well. Very inventive staging, music and lyrics with a lot of effort put into them, and two very solid performances from the leads. We’ll see if it breaks the Longacre Curse.
This was a such a charming show! The story is heartfelt and the music is excellent! There’s great chemistry between the leads. I was unsure about the more abstract set when we first sat down but they do some fun stuff with it. I saw one of the first previews and I’m sure the show will only get better as time goes on. This is a two person show so if you’re looking for a big Broadway spectacle this probably isn’t the right pick but it’s a lot of fun. I heard they did some work updating the jokes for a New York audience and they totally land. I was sitting off to the side of the orchestra and still had a great view. Most of the action is pretty central which is super central and I’d imagine most seats here would be pretty good.
probably the best thing i’ve ever seen. laughed and cried. developed a crush. the whole thing
A hilarious rom com that had me laughing almost as hard at Oh Mary! It’s a journey through the five boroughs making it extra enjoyable for native New Yorkers. I will say first act was excellent. Second act was good. Still highly recommend!
GREAT SHOW! 8/10 Actors have great chemistry and experience delivering a funny, charming story about two strangers in NYC. It was cute, the set design was really cool and truly came to life with good lighting and great acting. I would recommend it to any brokeish New Yorker looking for a laugh at power dynamics, similarities through differences, and hilarious yet cringeworthy moments. Had really good seats -- the sightline was great and we missed nothing despite being high and somewhat far up.
Cheesy? Yes. Funny? Absolutely ! Acting? Superb. I laughed and cried.
hilarious! i went in with lowered expectations given the two person cast but man was i blown away! it’s so beautiful and heartfelt and sam and christiani were just incredible! i was laughing the whole time!
cute show!! love love love the stage and effects. love de direction and the characters dynamic. gave myself and tay a seat upgrade on second act because why not?
21–40 of 659 comments
The show was hilarious! It’s only two characters, but they absolutely smashed it! I’d recommend closer orchestra seats or front row mezz since it’s a small set. (Edited)