Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
It’s a heart warming show with both funny and emotional moments.
Love this show! Both actors are incredible and the show is exactly the type of light hearted (but message carrying) thing we need right now.
This is what new musical theater SHOULD BE. Book is well written, music is well crafted, and the SET - oh my lanta. Loved this.
Amazing performance, was surprised how much we laughed, it was very funny and witty.
I liked this show a lot. It is a 2 person show. Both performers were terrific
Love it! Fantastic show! They both were amazing! As someone said to me after I saw it and agree that it is a very fitting tribute to New York City. Very touching ending ❤️
could’ve been a play, happy it was a musical :) stellar writing & performances.
Great, great vocal talent and chemistry between the two actors!! Very clever staging as well.
Wonderful! Enjoyed it immensely and left the theatre in such a joyful state. Such a beautiful story.
It was good but I still have questions that need answers, overall liked it though
super funny, loved the set design. great music!!!
Loved it! Fun staging, great actors, a story that is sweet but not obnoxiously optimistic or trite. And wow can the lead woman sing!
Great show! Funny & poignant without getting sappy .actors are great as is the music !
An adorable, slightly predictable two-hander with charismatic leads — a love letter to NYC.
A delightful musical with two compelling lead performances. While I’m unsure if this belongs on Broadway (it would be better suited to a smaller, off-Broadway house), it’s still very much worth checking out. The music is solid, the story is well told, and it moves briskly. It’s funny, cute, and touching.
Absolutely loved this show. Even though the set seems basic, there were so many hidden things within it that made it amazing! The songs and acting were also incredible!
Absolutely LOVED this show! So FUNNY and incredible comedic timing and incredible singing! (Edited)
Such a cute and really fun show. Loved the simplicity of the set and how they made it work throughout. The two actors were brilliant!! And the chemistry was A+. Would definitely see it again. A must watch!!
Loved this show! Almost like a rom-com. If you get a chance, go see it.
181–200 of 659 comments
This show was joyful and touching all in one. It captured New York’s essence and created meaningful connections between the audience and the stage. Couldn’t recommend it enough!