Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
pretty fun show! really enjoyed the jokes and the songs were great!
Very wholesome! Reminded my friend and I a bit of a more modern and realistic Elf, what with how excited he was to see NYC during Christmas and to meet his Dad.
How this didn’t win best musical is beyond me. Sam and Christiani are a joy. Great score, funny, and incredibly heartfelt.
Such a charming show. Sam and Christiani are such powerhouse performers from laugh out loud comedy to gut wrenching dramatic moments and everything in between. The set was very clever and the music was fun. This original work is not to be missed!
Charming. Beautiful performances. Sweet but not overly sentimental.
Super cute and very funny! Loved the set/stage; very creative use of the space.
Has a late 90s/ early 2000s rom com type vibe. Very dynamic even though it only had 2 actors.
So cute, knew nothing about it going in and fell in love! so glad I came back to NYC and had the opportunity to watch it
Sweet and enjoyable . A bit small for other stage but lovable. Sam Tutty is a ball of energy and talent.
LOVED LOVED LOVED. so funny and great chemistry between characters. def planning on going back!
Oh my gosh. Go see this. I love new work. I can’t even breathe it was so good. I had an absolute blast. 💥 These two are powerhouses. 10/10 run.
Sam and Christiani did an amazing job bringing this story to life on stage! I would watch it again and again!
Seen in Boston at the American Repertory Theatre, it was really special 💗
Saw in London and it was so much fun! So happy it’s getting a life on Broadway
I fear I’m obsessed with this show
Fantastic show. Plenty of laughs, life lessons and of course, the NYC storyline. Would see again.
What a wonderful surprise such a complex storyline shared with so much humor, love and affection. The performance by both individuals were out of this world. They are definitely superstar and have a bright future ahead of them. The singing is amazing. Chemistry is phenomenal between both performers. Must see show!
Very original relatable and heartwarming! Very simple but powerful at its core and both characters were absolutely loveable and ideal for this day and age! Go see it! :)
My second time watching the show! Highly recommend it to anyone and everyone!!
161–180 of 659 comments
It was amazing and the plot was surprising and the whole crowd would gasp. It was very funny and emotional at the same time.