Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Cute show! Some plot holes had me scratching my head though…was hoping I’d like it more!
The first half was pretty fun, but what was that second act?
Loved the show, and recommend this seller! This was a whim purchase, but much-needed after a long week.
Such a fun first act! The second was not nearly as strong but overall, an enjoyable show.
Felt like watching a Netflix romcom unfold beat by beat
Cute and fun. The limited sets def limited the story
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is a sweet, charming musical with a lot of heart! The chemistry between the two leads is lovely, and there are plenty of funny moments that make you smile. The songs are catchy, and the show has that cozy romantic-comedy feel that’s easy to enjoy. While the story can feel a little predictable at times and the show could be shorter, its humor and lovable characters make up for a lot. It may not be the most groundbreaking musical, but it’s a cute, feel-good theater experience that leaves you smiling!
This is a sweet rom-com with great singers who belt their hearts out. It will put you in a good mood. The format and story is very formulaic and predictable, but it entertains from start to finish.
1 year on Broadway !! Fansgiving ♡
It was very cute and I’m glad I watched it☺️ I can see why it was nominated, but also why it didn’t get to win unfortunately 🥲 Still a fun show💓
It was really cute but there were definitely points where I wanted more character exposition.
It’s cute and has funny moments, not life changing
Sam Tutty is easily the best thing about this play. Props for an original story, but kind of lacking overall
Very funny. A couple fantastic songs. Amazing performances. Maybe a bit contrived.
sometimes i wished it took itself a lil bit more seriously but it was good! i liked the twist and ending
It’s a cute musical. You will have a fun time, but it’s not the best that is out there right now.
Great set design. Unoriginal story. Ok music.
581–600 of 659 comments
So fun! A great show for tourists and New Yorkers. Both leads were great and the set was awesome. The band was also great! The music was just fine - almost entirely forgettable - but it was a fun Hallmark time. Great for first-time Broadway watchers because the format is easy to digest. I saw Vincent Michael as Dougal, and he was an absolutely great singer!