Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Cute play but felt the story was a bit lacking/inconsistent
Good two-hander. Fun couple well acted. Entertaining maybe a bit slight. But doesn’t rise to level of Maybe Happy Ending.
A nice story. Well played. Good set. It won't change your life but it is a good show for a nice afternoon out with friends.
One or two songs stand out.
Strong first act. Weak 2nd. Very very funny. Amazing actors (Edited)
Enjoyable. Fun. A little dragged out. Not masterpiece but definitely enjoyable
Minimal cast and stage set. (Edited)
Great show and wonderful first experience using this app.
tony campaign starts now
MY TAKE ON: “Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York), Feb. 5, 2026 So few Broadway shows can cover the costs of their development and turn a profit these days that we need more shows like this to shock producers out of their collective ennui. “Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)” is both modest and delightful. Like last season’s “Maybe Happy Ending,” this production passes on showy bombast. It’s confident in building something from classic musical theater building blocks: a story about likable people who grow as individuals; a well-written script that moves the story along briskly; a simple but attractive set (which remains in place throughout the show); a crack orchestra (just five in this case, and onstage); and appealing actors with vocal chops and comic timing. In this case, the cast of two consists of Sam Tutty (as Dougal) and Christiani Pitts (as Robin), drawn together in New York when his father marries her sister. Dougal is an odd duck visiting from England, and Robin is a young city woman with a hard shell. You’ve seen this pairing and character arc before. Nothing will surprise you. The relatively bland pop anthems that make up most of the songs probably won’t bowl you over, but they are good enough to work with all the other elements to create an evening that is…charming.
y’all ever have a parasocial relationship with a lighting designer (Edited)
Cute but not my favorite. Glad I went to see it!
It was cutesy!
Amazing show! Seller was fast w sending, no issues!
Fifth Preview (Edited)
night show!!
Attended with: Chelsea and Laura
neeeEw yoRrrKkk!! (Edited)
601–620 of 659 comments
good show but not a crazy broadway production