Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
First act is much stronger than second act. Sam Tutty is brilliant.
I liked the story. It was sweet and funny. But I do wonder if this needed to be a musical. The songs didn’t add anything for me and I didn’t take away much from most of these songs.
Loved the first act. Second Act didn't hit the same note with me but I still walked out happy with the show. Calling it a rom-com is a disservice to the show and can set you up for disappointment
The 2 actors (characters) were very likable. Cute show - funny. I liked it but it’s more of an off Broadway feel due to the minimal scenery and the overall feel of the show. Very enjoyable but I wouldn’t pay for a full price Broadway show performance for it.
It’s decent but it made me confused about what we’re putting in off Broadway versus Broadway houses. Some talent was there but it’s very much a small safe bet show. The Longacre actually had people in it for once, though, so I’m glad for its success in spite of my views.
Felt story was repetitive, cute but it felt more like a play trying to be a musical
The book was great, and the characters were really well written and interesting. I think they were both acted very well and really cool to see. I enjoyed the music a lot but the plot was difficult to follow through the second act.
An entertaining show with great music. Would have appreciate a bit more set changes though.
Thoroughly enjoyed the set and design. At the start I knew I would enjoy it and some of the music was quite wonderful. There were a few songs I didn’t like, but both actors were very good and did a great job with the material.
I liked it but couldn't fully get invested in caring about the characters at all. A few nice songs, but nothing crazy memorable. It was enjoyable though and no regrets having seen it.
Sweet but light. I was a little confused by the ending. Are we meant to believe they’ll be together in the future or that their experience together have changed the “for good”?
It’s a cute show with a fun set, but predictable!
The first act is definitely better than the second act but I enjoyed it very much.
Cute! Fun! Original! I wish they gave Robin more to do than just be angry or sad
It’s great seeing original musicals and two great talents on stage but overall felt rushed and messy. The story was weird
It was cute and enjoyable but I left wanting more, incredible comedy and vocals tho (Edited)
It’s good, nothing crazy special. Good vocals, fine songs. They in fact barely carried that cake…don’t be fooled
Loved it!!!!! It was funny, along with great voices, and moving. Run to see this one❤️❤️❤️🎼🎹🎤
I thought the story was bland, but it is one of the funnier shows I’ve seen in a long time.
561–580 of 659 comments
The actors and music were so good, but I felt like the second act felt rushed in comparison to the first.