Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
I didn’t hate it, but I didn’t love it either!! I think that both actors did absolutely amazing jobs, but the storyline started and then parts never ended! Left me wondering what happened? The male lead delivered his lines hilariously and the female lead was NYC in human form. The songs were pretty good as well! In my opinion this show didn’t need to be two plus hours!
christiani pitts and sam tutty were great! and they are really nice too during stage door. he was very british and she was very new york. quite a fun watch but nothing out of the ordinary in my opinion
So cute! Loved the set + lighting and the vocals from both leads was amazing. The first act lost me at some parts but the second act was so great.
the ending was a little underwhelming…. but it was still an amazing show and the fact that 2 people can make it still feel like such an amazing production is so impressive!
This show was pretty good. Cute story, cute execution, two great and charismatic leads. Some good songs. It was not transcendent in any way and the set is pretty minimal. While the story was sweet, there was no effort made to really engage with most of the plot points. Kinda like any of your run of the mill romantic comedy movies (except there wasn’t really any romance). I liked it and had a nice time but IMO the prices are excessive for what it is. I hope to see more of the actor who played Douglas!
It was a really cute show! I think I would’ve liked it a little more if not for the implied romance at the end. Not everything has to end with romance!
Very engaging and funny performance even though it’s only a 2-person show, but the actual melody of the music is bland, like I won’t be listening to the album after.
Two Strangers is the feel-good show of the season. Sam Tutty plays Dougal, the impossibly naive Brit who has landed in New York for his estranged father’s wedding. Christiani Pitts plays Robin, the cynical sister of the bride tasked with picking him up from the airport. Together they create a sweet dynamic, not only in their voices but in the interplay between naïveté and realism. Tutty’s voice is impossibly tender; Pitts is a powerhouse in her own right with a voice to match and a performance as sharp as her character’s Brooklyn roots. There’s no denying their chemistry onstage is real, but I didn’t fully buy the romantic arc the show gestures toward; friendship, connection, two people colliding in a pivotal moment, yes. Something more, not quite. The set is cleverly designed with a collection of grey suitcases that morph, Avengers-style, into every piece of scenery the show needs, from subway seats to hotel beds to the Plaza Hotel. Tim Jackson directs and choreographs with a light touch, and Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s score is the kind you hum on the walk home. A small note on the title: carrying a cake across New York is not actually the fundamental premise of the plot—they take an Uber. Where the show really delivers is somewhere quieter: the slow unraveling of Dougal’s fantasy about his father. Robin also softens. Dougal starts to see reality: his father didn’t know he was coming, didn’t invite him, and has spent a lifetime actively choosing not to be in his life. “If I Believed” was the standout song for me—one of the slower numbers, leaning into a vulnerability the whole show has quietly been building toward. It’s the moment the feel-good show earns its feelings, and one reason it’s worth your time.
I’m going to say I wasn’t in the best mood when I saw this, but I’m left with the feeling this show is overhyped. The performers were great though . The songs were okay, nothing really stuck with me. I found the story too cute with too many expected twists. Not my favorite, but I can see why people like it. It is a comedy and I did laugh, but maybe my taste is more Death Becomes Her than this sweetness.
541–560 of 659 comments
Undeniably cute. The characters are instantly likable, and the script is genuinely funny—I found myself laughing constantly. However, the musical side didn't quite land, and for a show about New York, the city felt surprisingly washed over. I wish the set design had made the location a character itself rather than just a backdrop. Ultimately, this would have been a much stronger 90-minute one-act. Worth it for the laughs, even if the tunes (and the setting) don't stick. (Edited)