Floyd Collins
Jeremy and Lizzy were incredible vocally. That was rly the only thing I liked :/ the plot felt very underdeveloped. I got the broad strokes idea but the details were not resolved much at all. And the music wasn’t for me (Edited)
Jeremy Jordan and Lizzy Mcalpine were phenomenal but the show it self was lacking.
First off, the way they worked with the material was so great! This is truly a historical piece (both with the content and also the history of the musical itself) and I would recommend it just for that. The cast was magnificent although the acting of some was something I didn’t feel too engaged in (I don’t want to specify any negative opinions on specific people so I won’t be disclosing), but truly a great piece. Another qualm would just be the stage being too big for this show but it wasn’t really something they could help so all is well. Sad to see it had to be a limited run :(
3.5/5⭐️ Trapped by a viral story for entertainment. Interesting reflection of a tragedy turned entertainment by media/the US. Great acting and singing. Maybe not your thing: just ok songs, bare set, facing death, tragedy. Diversity: little. Media exploitation of low socioeconomic rural young White man/his family's tragedy. All main characters cis straight White. A few people of color in the ensemble. 2.5 hours; 1 intermission
love Jeremy Jordan and Lizzie McAlpine. And they did really well for the premise. But idk how anyone could make someone getting stuck in cave interesting for hours
it was okay! the space felt too big for such an intimate show. the sound quality of that theater is SO hard
It’s slow; the music is great, not much dialogue so the music serves. Jeremy serves. Absolutely no set.
A really beautifully sung show. All the performances were great. Not my favorite book or music, and it’s very dark/depressing but the production was very solid.
I liked it more the second time, but still not a favorite. Big big fan of Jeremy and Jason!
Better than expected. A little sleepy at times but overall good. Jeremy was excellent.
acting, staging, and singing were amazing. the songs themselves however….
Only went because of Lizzy! She was phenomenal, however I don’t need to go back.
really only went for jeremy jordan and lizzy mcalpine.
Cast vocals were fantastic but acting wasn't as strong. The story was predictable and not super exciting. Standout performance was from the actor who played the reporter. Set design was pretty cool!
Way too long but good acting ; fell asleep
Go for Jeremy Jordan’s incredible performance but the first act is very slow.
Talent was great, especially Jason Gotay, but it was dark and slow and I don’t love folksy / yodel music
While it wasn’t for me, I can appreciate the artistic merit of this one. It’s very abstract, and I think the target audience is for folks who are really into musicals and theatre, or are themselves a part of the industry.
Floyd Collins at Lincoln Center Theater is a thoughtful, well-executed production that leans into the emotional weight of its story without overplaying it. The set is sparse but effective, creating a sense of scale and isolation that fits the Kentucky setting, and the lighting—especially in the cave scenes—adds real texture. The cast sounds beautiful throughout, with Adam Guettel’s score getting the vocal clarity it deserves. Lizzy McAlpine makes a fine Broadway debut as Nellie, though her performance could benefit from more depth. While the show doesn’t quite hit every emotional note, its refusal to offer easy answers is refreshing, and the production as a whole leaves a quiet, lasting impression.
181–200 of 249 comments
Jeremy Jordan was amazing. Strong vocals. Sound and lighting were off and many sound failures during show. Set was very minimal and kind of blah!