Floyd Collins
Great music
The entire cast is amazing.
Wonderful!
𝐅𝐥𝐨𝐲𝐝 𝐂𝐨𝐥𝐥𝐢𝐧𝐬 𝐡𝐢𝐭𝐬 𝐞𝐦𝐨𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐚𝐥 𝐝𝐞𝐩𝐭𝐡𝐬, 𝐛𝐮𝐭 𝐦𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐜𝐚𝐥𝐥𝐲, 𝐢𝐭 𝐠𝐞𝐭𝐬 𝐥𝐨𝐬𝐭 𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐚𝐯𝐞. The true story behind Floyd Collins is incredibly fascinating. I honestly couldn’t believe it actually happened in real life. I really want to recommend the show for its premise alone, but a good show is also about how well it executes the story, and this one didn’t quite reach its full potential. Jeremy Jordan delivers a powerful performance that anchors the entire production. Sitting in the second row during the second act, I felt his performance even more. Seeing the tears up close allowed me to really connect with his character’s agony. Most seats offer a full view since the action takes place at the front of the stage. If you’re seated on the extreme sides, you’ll only miss the backdrop, not the key moments. The performances help carry the weight, but the overall staging and production design fall short. It isn’t visually strong and could have been much better. Act 1 felt slow and uninteresting, while Act 2 was more emotional and engaging. Still, the show struggles to maintain consistent momentum from beginning to end. The music, unfortunately, was the weakest part for me. Honestly, this would have worked better as a straight play. The songs were forgettable, with the yodeling song being the only one that stuck with me. It’s not the best musical out there, and certainly not the most polished production. But for the emotional weight of the story and Jeremy Jordan’s standout performance, I’d still say it’s watchable. (Edited)
Went for Jermey, Lizzy & Jason…. I didn’t hate the show but I also didn’t love it…. I have never been to a show where I’ve seen people get up and leave before intermission. I felt the second act was better than the first, but I was just expecting more from this show. The sound was messed up at times I couldn’t even hear the actors!? (Edited)
Well performed by everyone, the music was nice. The show felt long, it could have been reduced to a one-act. Jeremy Jordan harmonizing with himself will stick with me for a long time. This show could have been so much better with a smaller stage, the Beaumont swallowed the production and didn’t showcase the vision to more of the audience. Very uncomfortable seats in the loge.
I’m happy I saw Floyd overall. I MAY have left at intermission if my friend wasn’t into it but happy I stayed in the end. It was a new, interesting story. The male cast was very talented; the women not so much. The first act storyline was too slow and the set was too sparse. The second act truly picked up and was great! I loved how they incorporated the entire space from set to lighting, though I think that was likely the point vs the small, dark cave but I think that was a huge miss there (the darkness and sparsity in the beginning)
This was actually more interesting than I expected. Lizzy was sick and could not perform and while the understudy had a beautiful, I do feel Lizzy would’ve brought the extra folk her character needed. Sucks I missed her but it is what it is
Cast was amazing, sad I didn’t get to see Lizzy Mcalpine perform but did get to see Jeremy Jordan :) Jason Gotay and Taylor Trensch were great in their roles. Stage design was weak but lighting definitely ate. They were not lying when they said Jeremy would be sitting in a chair for most of the show 🫣 (Edited)
The best - every bit of Jeremy Jordan’s performance. The worst - The wig on Taylor Trench All the other characters are doing the most with hints of storyline that fail to materialize. There’s a featured townie that gets increasingly drunk and Floyd’s dad is increasingly sick (?). It might help the viewing to know going in that there are 3 siblings and no dating pairs amongst any of them. When you hear that the young girl shouldn’t go in the cave because of “her condition” you think she’s pregnant. No, but she has been institutionalized for something in the past. Against all these loose ends, Jeremy Jordan’s performance makes it worth it.
A gorgeous production with elegant music sung with miraculous skill, which unfortunately isn’t necessarily matched by the slow narrative. I saw this show about 20 years ago and remember not loving it then — although I think the source material is ripe for musicalization, the book is kind of plodding and you’re never truly reeled in. But this production is easy on the eyes and ears and, if you’ve never seen the show, it’s worth a visit.
I don't think I like the musical Floyd Collins itself, but I think Lincon Center's production of Floyd Collins is very good. A lot of the dialogue and lyrics felt very forced and unnatural to me, and I'm not a target audience member for folk music, but I liked the general core conversation of the show. I interpreted it as "Chasing the American dream feels like distant hope in a dark cave until it buries you alive." and "It's easy to turn others suffering into spectacle." The minimalist set was utilized perfectly, proving limitations can't kill creativity. And I think Tina Landau was the perfect director for the intricacies of the moving platforms and imaginative set pieces. My bestie made a good observation of "Any song that happened on the surface had the southern twang/influence in genre, but every song Floyd had underground was more grandiose in orchestrations cuz it was just him thinking. The setting influenced the genre." I genuinely think Taylor Trensch deserves their Tony tomorrow. Fingies crossed! Jeremy Jordan sounds exactly like he did 13 years ago or on any recording he's ever done. Insane! Hot take, I wouldn't be interested in seeing this anywhere other than Broadway. (Edited)
No bad seat at Lincoln Center Theatre! Jeremy Jordan is very moving in all that he does! I didn’t love the story as much as I thought I would but it def is worth seeing! The sets are amazing! You feel like you’re in a cave!
Jeremy Jordan is a force to be reckoned with. Overall, the whole cast is fantastic (and I’m a huge Lizzy McAlpine fan so seeing her on stage was wonderful). Visually it’s also great, the stage production works beautifully with the story. But, story wise, I realized afterwards that I didn’t fully follow/understand it. It kinda felt that not a lot was happening and after the show I read the real story and had a lot of ‘ooohhh’ moments, that I would’ve liked for them to be clearer in the show. So I have mixed feelings. I enjoyed it but mostly because of the talent onstage then because of the story.
While Floyd Collins didn’t entirely win me over, the intricate spatial design and clever use of silhouettes in the staging kept me engaged. The real highlights were the musical numbers where the cast clearly had the most fun—so infectious, you might find yourself yodeling on the way out, despite yourself.
great voices and acting, but feel like most of the songs don’t add to the story. kind of boring bc nothing ever changes—he is still stuck and they’re still trying to get him out. great seat though, def recommend left side bc that’s where the cave is (where Jeremy is for 90% of the show)
I wouldn’t say it’s your usual musical, a little bit predictable but Lizzy, Jeremy and Jason were phenomenal. They didn’t come out for stage door but Marc (Lee Collins), Wade (Bee Doyle) and Cole (Jewell Estes) came out. Cole was so so sweet and he gave off very Gen Z energy but he’s literally engaged LOL but it was show itself was unique in itself.
It’s been a long time coming for this show. I was very excited to finally see it. I enjoyed the show but I think it would have been much better in a small venue. The Vivian Beaumont theater is way too big for this show. That being said. They did some really creative things. I hope you all enjoy it.
Whelp. JJ is really incredible. I would not be bummed if he earned a Tony for this. That said, I may just not be a Adam G fan. It's an unnecessarily cacophonous score and has bizarre storylines that just don't have a purpose. If it was just JJ as Floyd stuck in a cave for 2hrs, I would be down. I give major kudos to the lighting design and Taylor Trensch though.
141–160 of 249 comments
Fantastic direction A must see