Floyd Collins
One of my new favorite shows - the entire cast was stunning. It's a unique Broadway experience for sure. This seat was about six feet away from Jeremy Jordan for most of the show which was absolutely incredible! Very worth the $32 for some small moments where you couldn't see the singers' faces. The music itself blew me away - bluegrass and folk roots with some modern Broadway touches for an incredible sound. The orchestra was great as well! One of the best things for me was the production. The stage is so vast and used well. This was also one of the only times I felt that the giant LED backdrop was not distracting and helped tell the story and mark the passage of time. Jeremy Jordan rock climbing during the Ballad of Floyd Collins had me GAGGED This was maybe the best show Lizzy McAlpine could've made her debut in, with a lot of her music being in the folk area. She sounded absolutely beautiful and portrayed Nellie heartbreakingly well, almost like a siren you couldn't not listen to. I also saw Colin Trudell as Homer Collins (usually played by Jason Gotay) - absolutely amazing. He was the highlight for me, and he was so sweet at stage door as well. Overall absolutely worth your money! See it before it's gone! (Edited)
Amazing staging, and the performances by Jeremy Jordan and the guys who played Homer and Skeet were AMAZING. I got so lucky and had a seat that was literally 6 feet away from Jordan for most of the play so I saw every little facial expression he made. Amazing, amazing experience. I was sobbing on that last song about heaven
very interesting story with such great music behind it. jeremy jordan is just flawless in everything he is in and being in the room where lizzy mcalpine makes her broadway debut is crazy. shoutout taylor trensch for giving my mom and i’s favorite performance. will not be going into a cave anytime soon. my 95th show. 7/10.
So glad I got to catch this show before it closes this Sunday! Jeremy Jordan was spectacular as Floyd Collins, but the real standout to me was Taylor Trensch. His performance was incredible and I wish I hoped on this bandwagon sooner so I could have seen it twice. The story was moving and the music was gorgeous. The entire cast was phenomenal and the band sounded amazing! The view from my seat was a little obstructed since there’s something (or someone) on the stage right in front of those seats. I couldn’t see certain things that happened towards the back of the stage but nothing insanely important.
i went into this with zero knowledge about the show- i just love jeremy jordan and lizzy mcalpine 😭 i was pleasantly surprised! very different vibe to the other shows that are playing right now. i overheard someone say it feels like watching a movie and that honestly is a good way to describe it. it feels like an old timey music and the music fits right with it. everyone was amazing and insanely talented. i’d definitely reccommend everyone to go see! stagedoor gets VERY crowded though due to jeremy and lizzy so beware!!
Opening previews lottery win! Performances were AMAZING but given it was the first show they were having some music/mic volume issues. This production has a very minimalist set with a background screen so I’d recommend seating further towards the back to get full effect. We were very much on the side so some of it got lost. Be prepared for some drama and a hefty dose of southern twang!
Second time seeing this show this week (and ever); I’m in the city for a few days and I’ve been anticipating seeing it for a while. I saw it on Tuesday, but I just had to see Lizzy live, as she’s my favorite artist and this was my only chance to see her. Did not realize how close we’d be to the stage and just about ascended multiple times. The right side of the orchestra tends to have most of the actors’ backs facing towards it in many scenes, but it’s not as inconvenient as I feared it would be. We could see everything! Floyd Collins is definitely an acquired taste, but I’ve totally acquired it! I love folky/bluegrass-y music. Too perfect. Would absolutely recommend to try and see it before it closes on Sunday!
Loved it! I cried so much, Lizzy, Jason, and Jeremy were wonderful!
I had zero expectations of this show, I mainly wanted to see Jeremy Jordan perform, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. All the performances were top tier and the set design was so unique, I was not at all surprised this show was directed by the same woman who directed Redwood. Side note, I was incredibly impressed with how Jeremy could run around and climb down the cavern and sing at the same time. I would definitely recommend this show…put your name in the digital lottery via Telecharge! I won 3 times, was only able to go once and my seat was phenomenal!
I only had one night in NY and this was top of my list, as I’m a huge Guettel fan. Jordan is a wunderkind, the sound design is exceptional- every note sung and played was enrapturing, best music therapy ever.
Jeremy Jordan is perfect for this role. First time seeing him live and it was just amazing. Also saw the understudy for Lizzy McAlpine and she was fantastic. I also may or may not have sobbed at the end.
Finally saw Jeremy Jordan in person and had to restrain myself from yodeling too
On a second viewing I still do really love this complicated, thoughtful, hopeful, tragic, enigmatic show. And I love this staging that lets the beauty of the music take the forefront (though I could write a whole essay about how the minimalist set, especially at the beginning, allows us to experience the cave through Floyd’s imagination, how it becomes more and more complex as the story takes hold in the world on the surface — literally invented and embellished by the people outside the cave — and then there’s the use of color and lighting at the end, which is incredibly powerful). I understand why this is polarizing but for me it’s just such a beautiful piece.
Amazing show! Jeremy Jordan and Nellie Collins were phenomenal and I couldn’t ask for better seats! Their voices captured the historical time and location in a fascinating way. The stage was minimal but it was so interesting to see how they created this world underground with just a well done performance. I didn’t know the story or how it would end so it was very moving and they did a great job showing the struggle of Floyd in a way that made you feel it with him. Highly recommend!
No broadway show has made me sob more than this show did. Jeremy and Lizzie were absolutely amazing in this.
Saw the second preview it was so goood omg. It’s not everybody’s type of show but I thought it was really good!! I really don’t think you can go wrong with seating, I sat in the very back row and still had a very clear amazing view.
I really love this show and so I’m hoping through the preview period (which I saw the show close to the beginning of previews) this new Broadway version can tighten up and help the flow even more so you can really connect to what’s happening. It’s a beautiful story and I did still end up crying at the end so I’d still say see it if you get a chance!
There is something truly magical about the way this musical is written and the way it’s brought to life on stage. Jeremy and Lizzie singing on the same stage was transcendent.
Jeremy Johnson deserves the Tony for this. I liked the second act more than the first act. I also changed my seat at intermission because there were lots of empty seats.
1–20 of 249 comments
This was a beautiful show. I was blown away by the vocals of all cast members. There were comedic aspects, but by the end, our entire row was crying so hard. You could hear the entire audience sobbing. So beautifully done, we got to see it on the 100 year anniversary of Floyd Collin’s death, making it even more heartbreaking and special to see.