Floyd Collins
I knew the story going in. And I knew people are fully mixed on this. When I won the lottery I figured I would go. I liked it. I’m glad I went. Two of the songs didn’t hit for me. Both overall I thought it was a good show. Obviously it’s hard to stage a man being trapped in a cave. But the lighting and what they did with the stage was cool.
Great acting and design elements but personally I didn’t like the story very much, not happy at all (which is to be expected with the story but still). I really loved the lighting/video wall and set but the sound was a little weird? Not sure what was happening there. Go to see Jeremy Jordan, Taylor Trensch and Wade McCollum because they’re great but it’s definitely not a “must see.”
I liked Floyd Collins but I like that hillbilly yodeling genre. It’s definitely niche. The theater was maybe half full and a good 10-15% didn’t come back from intermission.
I’m not the biggest fan of the book, it just isn’t the best musical material for me, but this was still a solid performance. I really loved what they did with the staging, and I’ll see Jeremy Jordan in anything. Not sure I’d see it again but definitely worth the watch.
I thought Jeremy and Lizzy were just fantastic is this. I went just for them. The rest of the cast was great too. I just wasn't so sure about some of the songs though. I didn't feel like "musical theater" enough for me. Still a good show.
Although I enjoyed the performances and thought they did interesting staging for this production I felt they the show was entirely too long. I felt my self wanting to check my watch which I rarely do when seeing live theatre.
Jeremy Jordan is wonderful, as are other members of the cast; however, I walked out of the theatre with no song stuck in my head. I wanted to like it more than I did.
Music is good, set design is fun. The Vivian Beaumont is one of my fav theatres and they did make good use of it. Jeremy Jordan is amazing. Jason Gotay is amazing. Happy to rediscover Taylor Trensch and am impressed! everyone is amazing. Except for Lizzy. She is TERRIBLE. 120% stunt cast. She couldn’t act, one face from the beginning to the end. High notes are terrible, looks like she’s gonna faint any moment of the songs. A recording artist and a musical actor is not the same. Go back to your comfort zone girl…all respect to her solo career!
The set design and some music treatment are undeniably artistic. Love the minimalist background and abstract shape. also really enjoyed Lizzy vocals. However, I found the story itself a bit dull. The plot felt repetitive, circling around the same emotional theme without introducing much that felt new or evolving. After a while, the momentum seemed to fade, and the narrative lost its freshness for me.
I thought it was good but nothing overwhelmingly memorable. There were some great performances but it was really slow. It should have been 30 mins shorter.
Jordan acted/sang the SHIT out of this (otherwise theatre school-esque) production!!
Jeremy Jordan and Lizzy McAlpine have great vocals but the show wasn’t for me. Was surprised at the amount of yodeling
Cool production, talented cast, but it looked too much like he was sitting in a recliner the whole time (Edited)
Overall, I just couldn’t get into the show. I saw it during the first week of previews, so that could have affected my experience. However, hearing Jeremy Jordan sing “How Glory Goes” was wonderful.
I wanted to love this so badly. Jermey is a pro. I adore Lizzy. Taylor stole the show. The story just wasn’t for me.
In previews, so it might change. But I felt the first act dragged a bit. The second, however, was excellent.
The cast is great but I got a little bored during the middle. Jason and Taylor were actually the stand out performances for me
161–180 of 249 comments
Lots of yodeling! Once heard someone say they could listen to Jeremy Jordan sing a phone book and they would still listen and I think about that a lot The musical is fine, nothing too life changing and unfortunately Lizzy McAlpine was out but I still had a good time! (Edited)