Floyd Collins
Jeremy Jordan has done it again!
Came for Lizzy McAlpine and she did NOT disappoint. Not my favorite story but the performances were phenomenal.
I want to be able to say I enjoyed this show but I'm not quite convinced I can. Absolutely nothing against the performers or the people behind the scenes - Jeremy and the others were great. I just didn't feel like the show really resonated with me all that much
Ugh it’s very rare that I don’t like a show, and I have seen about 35 ( some twice) in the last year. I hated this show. I looked at my watch so many times. I was ASTOUNDED that Jeremy Jordan is laying down the whole freaking show. Singing while laying on a chaise lounge! I don’t think that’s the way to go. I also just flat out didn’t like all the yodeling, so it’s also a matter of taste. But I did notice many people left at intermission and i definitely considered doing that. Good performances from the actors who play Floyd’s siblings.
There were some moments to like in this. Jeremy Jordan is great as well as the rest of the cast. The final song was strong. I didn’t mind the yodeling as much as some others have. However, the story was a bit boring. Music overall was so-so. Set design I felt was also a bit lacking. Jordan spends the majority of the performance laying down and if you are seated at left side orchestra you will have a great view of his entire performance. That is where he is for 90% of the show. I certainly didn’t hate this but there are significantly stronger and more engaging shows on Broadway.
The first act felt very slow, almost dragging at times. However, the use of the stage developed beautifully, and the lighting design was truly masterful. The background work created by the actors was incredible—visually stunning. I didn’t enjoy the story itself. I understand it’s based on true events, but I found the narrative to be too simple and, frankly, boring. Maybe that’s on me—I was expecting something more exciting. The cast, though, was excellent. A huge shoutout to Taylor Trensch—his voice and performance were outstanding, and I’m glad he got a nomination. As for Jeremy Jordan, his voice is undeniably powerful, but for some reason, it didn’t fully resonate with me. That said, compared to his performance in The Great Gatsby, which felt cold and distant to me, this time the “ice” melted a bit. I especially enjoyed him in “How Glory Goes.” I also want to mention Cole Vaughan—he was great and really stood out. Musically, I was drawn to the show after hearing the promo tracks from the album, which sounded amazing. Unfortunately, I was a bit disappointed. While the sound itself is impressive, I felt like the lyrics didn’t always mesh well with the music, at least in many of the songs. Lizzy’s voice adds something really special to the production. However, I wasn’t a big fan of her stage performance—but it was her debut, and she definitely has all the potential to become great. Overall, the first act left me bored and surprisingly unexcited for the second—something that almost never happens to me. But I have to admit, the second act redeemed the play and brought much-needed energy. It’s not a show I’d choose to see again, but some of its visual moments will definitely stay with me—they were simply beautiful.
I decided to play the lottery for this because it’s one of the shows I hadn’t seen- wasn’t on my list, but figured why not. I felt like the songs didn’t really flow, it was dull and had bad southern accents. I actually left during intermission so maybe I would have loved it if I had stayed 🤷♀️ (Edited)
I forgot to post about it… that’s how you know I wasn’t raving to post a review. As someone who loves Adam Guettel’s music, I can now see how it is repeated into his next major work.. Jeremy’s vocals really make the performance. Lizzy captures with her singing but the production, I don’t know… it didn’t have heart? Like I wanted more if that makes sense. Taylor was the best one of the cast and his nomination is well deserved. But I would not recommend it as the first show you go and see.
jeremy jordan and taylor trensch my beloveds this certainly was a show. the stage was creative on how they represented the hole vs outside, but it would’ve been 10000000 times better with actual sets. music was bleh, all i can really think of is the yodeling. it fit jeremy’s voice very well, but that’s about all it did. i feel bad commenting on the bad story as it’s a true story, but what the fuck. there was no point? he looked like he became jesus at the end? (i don’t think that’s a spoiler bc it’s literally just how he stands and it makes zero sense in or out of context) this show could’ve been one act and i still would’ve been dissatisfied but at least my butt wouldn’t have fallen asleep. lincoln center for being so new why are your chairs so uncomfortable
I was unmoved and endured rather than enjoyed this. I just couldn’t wait for it to be over. I was bored by the lack of scenic design although there were some interesting momentary stage pictures especially silhouetted with some warm light. But that’s about it. The music was harsh and not something pleasing to my ear not to mention that I could only understand about 40% of the lyrics. I was in row B so either the actors were not enunciating enough or the orchestra was overpowering them. Skip it.
Normally, Jeremy Jordan cannot be contained. He is an explosive leading man, skilled at scenes and seismic when he lets loose his powerful belt. But “Floyd Collins” makes him small – appropriately for the purposes of the story itself but also to the show’s detriment. “Floyd Collins” tells the tale of an American cave explorer who in 1925 became trapped and died in a narrow space in what is now Mammoth Cave National Park. With his leg pinned under stone, rescuers were unable to pull him out or enlarge the space enough to safely bring him up. His tale became that century’s first big media sensation, winning a Pulitzer Prize for a reporter who assisted in the rescue and got close enough to interview Collins. Presenting this on a stage is enormously challenging. The design collective DOTS responded with an abstract set that makes use of trapdoors and scaffolds obscured by tight pinspot lighting on Jordan. But the whole enterprise goes awry at the solution for leaving Jordan in sight while the rescue drama goes on. Jordan sits on a corner of the stage on the same exact level as those above ground in what can only be described as a black chaise lounge chair. (See attached photo.) When characters like the reporter get close to his tiny prison, they stand in back of this contraption and reach over Jordan’s shoulders and head. It becomes exceptionally difficult to suspend disbelief – and this overshadows all the talent Jordan brings to the folk-and-bluegrass avant garde theater songs by Adam Guettel. The story itself and Guettel’s music are tough sells; you’d hope that if anybody could overcome them, it would be Jordan. Sadly, that doesn’t happen. (Edited)
This show was not for me. I am energized by choreography, catchy music, and ensemble casts. This was none of that. Instead it really was just Jeremy Jordan stuck in a cave. The music was slow and draining, and despite lots of talent in an underutilized cast, I felt stuck, too.
Terrible songs, bad plot, way too long. Theater is comfortable and main three had good voices but not redeeming.
Cool seeing a show I’ve listened to since I was young but disappointing to find out that the musical kinda sucks as a whole. Boring, bland and why did this ever come back to such a huge space?
The cast was great. Jeremy Jordan is an exceptional talent, but his talent was wasted on this unfortunate show. The sparse set had none of the magic that Sunset Boulevard was able to deliver with the same kind of set. If Jeremy Jordan goes back to Gatsby, that's where I'll be.
Bad sound design. stage too big for this show
Likes the story…but not much else. Jeremy was Jeremy. Yodeling is just not for me! 🤷🏻♂️
Boring to me, I wouldn’t see it again but I did like the opening scene with Floyd going around the cave
221–240 of 249 comments
yodel yodel yodel yo