Smash
It’s not quite camp and borders on cringe at times, but the beloved music from the TV show still bops.
Loved it right up until the hacked ending. Talent is amazing.
Just remember it’s not the TV show. Performances are very strong. Ending is weak.
Second act kinda spirals but this one is for the theatre nerds.
The music and cast are great, the book isn’t up to par for a musical comedy.
I thought it was a lot of fun! Great dancing and singing. Second act can definitely use some editing in the book
How to feel about a show that knows and acknowledges it’s a mess…
It’s campy in a good way. The show feels like it was made for those who used to watch Smash on NBC, but honestly I wish they would have just made the bombshell musical
It was a really funny show but also so confusing
Loved it for what it was, but the script left a lot to be desired
Fierce talent working with a weird plot - not at all the tv show so know that going in!
3.5/5⭐️ Comedy version of TV show. Uses threads of plot from TV show but a separate, streamlined simpler plot. Sprinkling of musical numbers as they practice the show. Fun time and fun choreo. Maybe not your thing: simple predictable plot, different from TV. Diversity: no. Almost all cis straight White cast of main characters. Some ensemble are people of color. 2.5 hours; no intermission.
Fun, but nothing more. I love media about creating theater so this worked for me, but it was also kinda stupid. Glad I saw it for free tho!
Great if you’re at the person, lots of inside jokes
Good show—not the most groundbreaking or moving show I’ve ever seen but it had great choreography and it is so wonderful to see Krysta Rodriguez back on broadway!
It was fun and glad I saw, but as a big fan of the series it all just didn’t work. (Edited)
Given that New York Magazine once referred to the television show “Smash” as “the best hate-watch of all time,” the need for going another direction in bringing it to Broadway seems obvious. It also seems obvious that the creative team needed to keep all the catchy Marc Shaiman-Scott Wittman songs that gave the troubled TV show its appeal. And somehow, the book writers also needed to satisfy partisans of both Ivy and Karen, the two actresses competing to play the Marilyn Monroe character in the show-within-the-show. Their solution onstage at the Imperial Theater makes sense (even if the TV show never did): Go for farce. If the TV show was unintentionally funny, then why not go over-the-top and pack the show with theater in-jokes and laughs? This choice has the unintended effect of sidelining the diva characters (Robyn Hurder as Ivy and Caroline Bowman as Karen). Dominating the show instead is Brooks Ashmanskas as beleaguered director Nigel. His British accent and womanizing from TV are gone, replaced by Ashmanskas’s gay characterization whose every intonation, line reading and gesture throws the audience into fits of laughter. This kitchen sink of a book is most alive when he’s onstage. The women don’t have much interesting to say, but they, of course, get the show’s big numbers – “Let Me Be Your Star” and “Don’t Forget Me” – and they belt them to the rafters. And that, after all, is the personification of “star” that Smash fans most demand. (Edited)
The show gets better as it goes on but the beginning of the first act starts really flat.
Not my favorite but not bad at all
161–180 of 238 comments
Basically got a 2 for 1 deal with the lottery. Great music, very funny, and overall a good show. The plot was a bit lacking, but everything else made up for it.