Smash
Smash is a smash! Even if you haven’t seen the TV series this show is still a ton of fun. I was so excited to hear my favorite Bombshell numbers and this cast did not disappoint. Robyn Hurder, Caroline Bowman, and Bella Coppola blew it out of the water! But the real surprise was Brooks Ashmanskas carrying the entire show, he’s hilarious and a joy to watch. Smash is a more lighthearted and comedic adaptation from the TV show and there were a couple changes and twists that made it stand on its own. I would love to watch a whole version of Bombshell with all three as leading ladies.
Fun to watch, great music! I never watched the TV series, but liked this one. (Edited)
When the Gen Z kid had to explain the word “streaming” to the lead producer, I was too scared to check how much time there was left in the performance
There were some powerhouse voices out of the women in this show, but overall I wasn’t connected to the plot. I didn’t watch the tv show, so I didn’t have expectations when it came to that storyline, but compared to everything else that’s out right now there are better options.
Unfortunately this was my least favorite show of the season. I didn’t go into this show having seen the TV show, but I found the music not very memorable, the book boring, and the story and themes clichè. I hated the romantic plotline between the director and the chorus boy. It just made me feel gross and the show painted it like a positive romance. The saving graces of the show are the actors and their immense vocal talent, specifically Caroline Bowman, Robyn Hurder, and Bella Coppola. (Edited)
I'll start with the great elements: Energetic choreography with full Broadway flair, the type you want to see at the Macys Day parade. The fact that the songs from the television show made it into the musical so you had some catchy tunes for the choreography. Now the rest. As a fan of the tv show, I really struggle with the mess of the plot here. Three possible Marilyns? Too many (failed) attempts at being funny (while talking about wanting to be funny)? Cliche portrayals of young people, theater people, etc? Overall it felt like a show that has been workshopped to death but held onto too many ideas, many of which were completely unnecessary and will leave most audiences confused, bored, and annoyed.
While I very much enjoyed the performances and the premise of a show about the rehearsal process of a musical, I didn’t really like the story
really disappointed with this one. i was so excited to see this and it just was very flat. robyn is lovely and a true definition of a triple threat. but the book is just… well. i don’t think EVERYONE needs a story line.
I was disappointed because the Smash TV show has so many beautiful songs, but I didn't hear the full songs. Moreover, Karen's character was untold.
Not like the show except for a few characters and their names. Songs from tv series but not the same heart. Actors were good but one of the main characters didn’t even have a song. It could have been better
Nope. Did nothing for me with the book, choreography was okay, talent was okay. I didn’t care about any of the characters and dear LORD what was that black hooded older method acting coach woman and WHAT was she doing in this show?!
hmm not sure how I feel about “meta” shows that have shows within a show lowkey would’ve been more interested in seeing the show within the show about the biopic of Marylin Monroe than whatever this show was lol (Edited)
The actors were very good but I did not like the play, and I found it boring
Huge fan of the TV show and this missed the mark by miles. The show also feels like a huge disrespect towards Marilyn herself
I mean like comically mid, a good time just not a spectacle, and that’s okay. (Edited)
I heard they tightened up the show since previews. When I saw it, it was a mess. Too many unnecessary plot lines.
Great performers. Unfortunately, the book was not up to their efforts. Extremely uneven, lackluster, and disappointing, in spite of several good performances by the actors.
201–220 of 238 comments
Sad to see the show closing - wish everyone well in whatever they go on to next!!