Smash
In 2012 there was a morning I leapt out of bed with a song in my heart: Let Me Be Your Star ⭐️. I had gotten the call to be an extra on Smash (Season 2) and I was HYPED. I had loved the 1st Season (come to think of it I never did see the 2nd Season oops) and actually I did extra work twice on S2. Anyway, that first time on set in Greenpoint BK I kept humming Marc Shaiman’s genious and exciting tuner (I loved the pushed quarter note Broadway sound, the belty interval jumps and those bongos in the background lol). My big “scene” was coming up and I couldn’t contain my excitement to be on the show (yes even as just an extra!) and I said to the other extras “aren’t you so excited?!” And I’ll never forget they all just looked at me deadpan and were like “chill dude” lol. In fact they all said they had no idea what this show was. 🤷♂️ Anyway I’ll never forget being somehow positioned face to face w Bernadette Peters and the other big stars were all like arms length away and we were on a huge HOLD and Bernadette and I were just like looking at each other like “hiiiiiiiiiii”. Lol ANYWAY - I went to see Smash Bway tonight because I DID love that 1st Season and somehow that song Let Me Be Your Star is so well written and sung I once again leaped out of bed and was excited to go Smash again. It was fun, it was fluffy and to my delight you hear the song over and over lol (I also like the song Don’t Forget Me which is like Let Me Be Your Star adjacent, like it’s Let Me Be Your Star-lite.) I was bummed however that Bollywood number didnt make it into the musical. NY you never let us down 🎶🎭🗽
i thoroughly, THOROUGHLY enjoyed this show. it was just what i needed after an awful week at work. in fact, i loved it so much, that at intermission, i went back to buy more merch. this is going to be a brutal tony's season. usually i don't start with writing about performances, but in this case i just have to--the cast was firing on all cylinders, and often, i forgot i was watching a preview. robyn hurder as ivy lynn was a revelation from the opening number. her dancing alone continually stunned the audience, and there were moments (WALKING IN THE AIR, HELD UP BY A CHORUS DURING "I NEVER MET A WOLF WHO DIDN'T LOVE TO HOWL"????) i literally had to say "holy shit" out loud. in terms of acting and emoting, ivy has the toughest role, and robyn sold me hook line and sinker both on her take on ivy lynn, AND on marylin monroe. even when ivy was acting like a diva, i never stopped rooting for her to maintain her spot as marylin. i'll note that the comedic timing was spot on–GIVE ME VERBS!! also, robyn looked gorgeous in the role. caroline bowman as karen was such a delightful surprise–i didn't care for hee character in the tv show at all, but she moved me deeply in this musical. i felt her frustration so acutely in act 2, and her rendition of "they just keep moving the line" brought me to tears. i wish they had given her more to work with, frankly, but alas! those in the director, writers, and producer role also did incredibly, though i won't go into specifics to mind the length. i will say the comedic timing, physicality, and chemistry shared by all of them constantly had the audience laughing. special shout out to chelle denton, who stepped into the rule of susan as an understudy, and fully committed. she had me laughing at every line (the pills, the moment where she ran up to the balcony to clap for the end of the show???) okay, NOW i'll get into the musical itself. in terms of adaptation, i was initially wary at all the changes, but not only were they done tastefully and convincingly, the show convinced me that they were NECESSARY for the musical to work, though I really did want a bit more interactions between ivy and karen to really sell their relationship. that being said, i did think that removing ivy lynn's underdog status muted the emotional depth out of smash, but to be fair, smash IS marketed as a comedy. i'll say too, the integration of the diegetic bombshell numbers and staging was incredibly deft. the music and score were obviously insanity, but that was expected, they had nearly perfect original material to work with. the choregraphy was a highlight for me, and this is coming from someone who doesn't care as much for showstopping dazzlers as a standard broadway goer. the comedy landed 90 percent of the time for the audience, and the call backs to the running gags (like all of the director's names for susan) made the audience truly feel like a part of the musical's world. book and pacing wise, this was not a perfect show--act 1 lingered, where as act 2 was a bit quickly paced, and didn't fully deliver on the emotional promises of act 1. the book was weaker than the musical numbers, and there were moments it felt like the writers were trying to be too~ relevant, but overall, it worked more than it didn't, and delivered on it'd marketing. *spoilers below** it seemed like smash was very committed to completely cutting away the sentiment, of the tv show, sometimes to it's own detriment. the finale springs to mind for this. bombshell bombed, and the musical moves away from the reality of that too quickly for there to be any catharsis or reckoning with deeper emotion. **spoilers over** this was probably the most close to a finished product preview i've gone to, and i'm excited to see the show when it officially opens, and they clean up and cut some of the meandering moments. overall, though, despite these criticisms and small gripes (wasn't convinced by any of the romance, wasn't fully convinced by chloe [through no fault of the actress]) i never stopled enjoying this show for even a minute. it felt like a real love letter to true fans of the theater. what it lacked in emotional depth (that robyn did a phenomenal job of accessing and trying to higlight) smash made up for in heart. SPRINT, don't run, don't walk, to this musical. (Edited)
An ode to Broadway. If you’re a fan of the TV show (like me) you’ll enjoy the incredible music. The rewrite for Nigel’s character and addition of Cloe was brilliant. The cast is pure talent. A lot more dialogue than I expected but overall wrapped up beautifully in the 2nd act. Sad to see most of the mezzanine empty :/ (Edited)
Pros: the authenticity and emotional heart. So many laughs. Great music and dancing. Performances you gotta love. Characters and fleshed out dynamics. Cons: It is a bit crowded. Act 1 ends in such a way that I cried my eyes out for a good reason. The show is a bit lacking in some forms of rep and stellar in others (not every show can check every box) but my goodness this theater gay was gagged. This show knows its vision and its audience which I really appreciate!
Had Katie Webber u/s for Ivy! Review by someone who hasn’t seen Smash btw. A fun show, lots of good laughs. Especially fun with this performance having the understudy on (more meta). I’d recommend, maybe 7.5/10? Talent was strong (less so by Katie (great) than by the Chloe and Karen actresses (phenomenal) but I think that’s kind of the point, too. Long show that felt like a movie!
Third day of previews. The lead understudy had to go on last minute and the whole thing blew me away. I knew nothing about smash going into it and you don’t need to
Fantastic! Super funny show, laughing the whole time. Brooks Ashmanskas is an icon and just blown away by Robyn Hurder. DISCLAIMER: aside from a select few of lead characters, this is not like the show at all. completely different plot line, new characters, etc. Script felt a little awkward at times, I think due to trying to keep it in the “recent” and post -covid meta relating to the audience vibes, but still a great show nonetheless ! totally recommend (Edited)
Initially was disappointed that it strayed far from the TV show but realized by intermission that it was a smart choice to do it this way! One of the most talented cast I've ever seen! I think this is Brooks's best work!
I enjoyed it! I never watched the show (controversially) so I had nothing to compare it to besides a few songs, but I laughed a lot and Robyn Hurder to me is just incredible.
The costume design is fantastic, and the stage set is wonderfully imaginative. Robyn Hurder is absolutely stunning—especially her singing; for a fleeting moment, I felt like I was watching Marilyn Monroe herself. I really enjoyed the references to Billy Wilder and all the classic Hollywood icons, but I was equally impressed by how the show balanced those nods to the past with a fresh exploration of influencers and the role of social media in shaping Broadway nowadays! The music is excellent, and Brooks Ashmanskas delivers a truly sophisticated, standout performance.
I was missing a funny lighthearted musical. I watched the tv show years ago but did not remember a thing — and it was nice to see it with kind of fresh eyes, especially after going to Broadway a few times, seeing how things are on the inside is just wonderful. (Edited)
I had a great time at Smash. The cast are all so talented and I very much enjoyed the music, songs, choreography, sets and costumes. I really laughed a lot. I definitely want to see this again for the sheer fun of it. The book is rather silly and the ending over the top but the pace keeps you very engaged. What a blast!
Good performances, clever lines in script that weren’t telegraphed. Obviously a cast that enjoyed working together
It’s super camp! It was fun. Don’t expect to have your life changed but come prepared to have the girls SING for you.
My inner child was screaming for this show. I was nervous since it is billed as a comedy while the TV show is clearly a drama, but this show CRUSHED in every way imaginable. The songs, actors and general plot was so good at taking key moments from the show and adding a light-hearted comical view. Would see many more times!
The show was really good! I liked the opening number and the act 1 closer the best! The whole cast was phenomenal! This was a lotto win the seats weren’t that great but the show was still amazing! So sad it closed!
Smash was a fantastic experience. Having never seen the TV show, I came in with no expectations and was thoroughly impressed. The production was sharp, the costumes stunning, and the humor kept me laughing throughout. A truly enjoyable performance
Fun show overall. Usually not a fan of sitting in the actual front row but because of the style of show, I don’t think it took away from the experience/view.
1–20 of 238 comments
Such a delightful, humorous, and heartwarming show. You can’t approach it expecting it to be like the TV show because it’s not. It’s loosely based on the TV show, but it tells a completely different story with many amusing and fresh ideas. Including but not limited to Chloe. When you see her you’ll know what I mean. She steals the show for me. I was very impressed with how funny it was as well. The timing was spot on with these actors. Very very good. I def recommend it but like I said before, go in with an open mind and do not think it’s going to be like the tv show. Standout moments throughout the show included the end of Act One, where “Let Me Be Your Star” was performed. There were a few renditions and versions of this number throughout the show, but this was undoubtedly the best. Karen’s (Caroline Bowman) rendition of “Just Keep Moving the Line” was also stellar. Bowman’s performance was exceptional throughout the show. The final standout moment was the assistant Scott’s (played by Nicholas Matos, who made his Broadway debut in this role) number at the end of the show. It was hilarious, sweet, and he’s incredibly cute. His performance brought me to tears of joy. What can I say? I’m a sucker for a happy ending. It was an amazing night for me because I saw my sister and her kids emerge from the same exact show that I was in. We had no idea that the other was there. Smash now holds a very special place in my heart because of me reconnecting with my beautiful little sister after almost three years of not seeing her. So thanks you Smash. Thank you Karen and Chloe and Scott. Thank you, theater, for constantly reminding me of our humanity and for your remarkable ability to evoke tears in me. Now go see SMASH!