Smash
I went into Smash without having seen the show and enjoyed myself. It’s fun to imagine the dramatic goings on behind the scenes at a Broadway show. There are a couple really fun numbers and powerhouse vocals. The book especially the ending could use some work but this is still in previews. The staging largely feels like a behind the scenes view without as many full out numbers/sets. It’s a shame that a lot of the numbers are abbreviated—it feels like they’re trying to put in as many of the songs as possible but don’t do all of them justice. I sat in the front side mezz for this which was a great vantage point to be able to take in the full stage. This is a fun fluffy show but I think if you go your expectations set accordingly you’ll have a good time. I can’t speak to how this compares to the show (which I know has been a point of disappointment for some which is totally fair) but I’ll say even going in with out having seen it it made sense and was easy to follow.
𝐒𝐌𝐀𝐒𝐇... 𝐎𝐑 𝐏𝐀𝐒𝐒? 𝐏𝐄𝐑𝐅𝐎𝐑𝐌𝐀𝐍𝐂𝐄 𝐈𝐒 𝐀 𝐒𝐌𝐀𝐒𝐇, 𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘 𝐈𝐒 𝐀 𝐏𝐀𝐒𝐒 I haven’t seen the TV show, but I had an idea of what this show was going to be, so I was expecting just a silly, fun night. For the positives, I honestly found the premise really funny because it is musical inception—a musical about making a musical—which was new for me, so I was invested. Plus, there were really fun comedic punchlines that had me laughing, especially because of Brooks Ashmanskas. Some of the songs were catchy and iconic. I love the upbeat score, and Robyn Hurder was phenomenal as Ivy. Bella Coppola and Caroline Bowman were also incredible. It was not a bad show at all, thanks to the performances. I do, however, believe that the biggest downfall of this play is its story development. The plot was thin. The characters were underdeveloped, making it difficult to connect with them. The ending was rushed and anticlimactic, and considering it was three hours long, it was disappointing not to see the characters get the endings I think they deserved. Because of that, my experience felt incomplete. Overall, while the performances, comedy, and music were enjoyable, the lack of depth in the storytelling holds the show back from being a truly Smashing experience. (Edited)
It’s a lot to take in. Especially as a big fan of the tv show and the music in the show. I really just don’t know how to feel. And I wanted to love it so so much. I definitely never knew what was going to happen in this show. I need a few days to gather my thoughts….
As a big fan of the TV show, this was a bit disappointing. It was still good fun but the book had a lot of issues. Music was great. Most (but not all) performances were great. Semi-spoilers ahead so stop reading if you don’t want to know…. My issues were: - dramatic tension reduced by adding the character of Chloe and having three women not two vying to play Marilyn - character of Ivy was completely unlikable here, too one note - role of Karen super diminished, reducing dramatic conflict as mentioned above, and also Caroline Bowman, who is wonderful, was underutilized - didn’t love the recasting of the director from an abusive and predatory straight man to an effeminate, lonely, middle-aged gay man… which seem like a lazy trope or caricature, and taking away the male power dynamic over these women who are competing serves to reduce dramatic tension as well - I HATED the role of Susan… was briefly funny, but got old quickly and was just annoying - I thought RH was miscast as Ivy and the role requires a much stronger singer - ending was off (as has been noted by many reviews) As someone who loved the show, I was a bit sad they didn’t do better with the adaptation. What worked: - a lot of the songs are great… the music is really good and has aged well - the show behind the show plot still works well and is good fun, also lots of inside jokes for theater junkies - standout performances from the actresses playing Karen and Chloe - kind of a fun old-fashioned musical comedy feel, it’s good escapism for these trying times
did a three show day and this was the end so i might have just been exhausted. they changed everything i loved from the show. tom and julia. derek. derek and ivy. made ivy a spoiled brat and made karen look like the good guy. who is chloe? just glad they kept the songs. and it was pretty funny. my 83rd show. 6/10.
The show felt disjointed to me. I never saw the original show but apparently it’s not the same at all. I think I understand what it’s supposed to be conceptually but a lot of the jokes either weren’t landing or were entirely overplayed. I can’t say I didn’t laugh at all, I definitely did. But, there were many times where I felt like a bit just didn’t make any sense or went on for far too long. The music is good. At times I couldn’t hear what was being sung. The dances were impressive, lots of lifts and turns, but I can’t say anything extraordinary happened on stage. If I were to give a number rating, it’s a solid 6/10 for me.
Robyn and Brooks were phenomenal. Unfortunately didn’t get to see Caroline Bowman. Overall it was a cute show. A lot of jokes made for theatre people so reads a bit nerdy that way. Wish they had spent more time in the show developing Ivy’s resolution and showing us how she got there. Ending felt random, a conclusion to a problem we weren’t trying to solve or at minimum was a subplot.
It was better the second time but it wasn’t good my friend took me but the understudy that went on for Karen was amazing she was fabulous. Overall just a fine musical it doesn’t feel special and you can tell it was written by the same writers as boop because they use the same jokes over and over again but it works better in boop.
Such a campy, fun, and metatheatrical trip! Lots of great moments and bits here for the musical theatre girlies, both for those who watch them, and those who work on them. Lots of love for stage management, stagehands, and dressers depicted onstage! I’m especially obsessed with Jacqueline. B. Arnold as the producer, Anita, and with every single one of her outfits from costume designer Alejo Vietti. SMASH is the only show I’m aware of to take the actual Genie lift used during load-in and rig it up as part of the Beowulf Boritt’s set. In a cruel twist of fate, from my seat on the far right edge of the mezzanine, I was unable to see the genie at all. I’m certain that I’m the only patron who will ever care about this. For a show meant to be set in the here and now, I was a bit perplexed by the amount of 2011-style memes featured in S. Katy Tucker’s video and projections design. Most importantly though, SMASH also marks the broadway debut of THEE Bibiana Torres, who is serving as the SDCF Observer for the production. If you don’t already know her name and follow her work, you’d better start- a legendary artistic career is both here and ahead of her, I’m sure. Congrats, and happy opening! 🎉
The sets are lackluster and minimal. The story is a little all over and felt long. However, the relationships and characters are very good and believable! I LOVE the powerhouse of each woman in this cast; like WOW. So brilliant and all completely different, unique and gorgeous! I cannot say enough good things about standout and stellar showstoppers like leading lady Robyn Hurder, the understudy Caroline Bowman and BELLA COPPOLA!!! Made the Act 1 curtain fall; like BAM 💋 Go see if you Old Hollywood, Marilyn, Brilliant music by Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman, Strong performances and Dazzling costumes; go go go to the Imperial Theatre with your red lipstick on!!! #Preview #WednesdayMatinee #GetThemDeals
It was a lot of fun if you were a fan of the tv series! Probably less so if you weren’t. My seat (row A right mezz seat 108) was partial view so there were a handful of moments I couldn’t see, but it wasn’t too bad. I do I wish it would have said that on the listing.
I want to say that if you like the tv series you’ll like this, but I don’t even think I can say that anymore. Above all, I was so excited to see the songs live but don’t hold your breath because for quite of few of them, like “National Pastime,” “Public Relations,” and “Mr. & Mrs. Smith,” it’s generous to say that we even get a 16-bar audition cut. These short snippets of song also happen while they’re in rehearsal, so don’t go in thinking you’ll see the numbers fully staged. On the whole I don’t dislike the changes to the characters, especially those made to the director, the writers, and Karen, as she’s now Ivy’s understudy. But overall the new story feels a bit bland. There are too many characters to give their own arcs to (for example, Nigel’s arc about falling in love and Jerry’s about becoming an alcoholic feel shoehorned). On top of that, they even add more characters, like Chloe and the acting coach, which makes it feel even more oversaturated. The show engine of the tv series was the competition between Ivy and Karen and when you not only take that away but also add in another Marilyn contender the entire story loses its path. The book also has some of the cringiest, most expositional dialogue I’ve seen on Broadway. To top it all off they have social media montages and a self-aware closing number about how they’re now going to make a musical about making a musical. It feels like they don’t know whether they’re going for campy, self-aware, meta, actually funny, cheesy, or poking fun at the industry and musical theatre in general. The result is a hodgepodge of some funny but mostly super cringey moments and they don’t lean into the camp enough to justify it. But my biggest gripe with this show is that the large majority of the musical numbers (except for maybe two) only exist because the characters are rehearsing or performing the number, meaning they do nothing to move the story forward. It truly feels like a jukebox musical in that sense, or even further, a play with way too much music, because the songs do nothing to speak to what the characters are going through at the moment—they only speak to Marilyn’s character. The story is largely about Ivy becoming more and more like Marilyn and how that affects the people around her, so the very easy fix to this is to have the songs that Ivy sings about Marilyn also speak to her current situation. The closest they get to this is when Karen sings “Moving the Line” but this could have easily applied to “Let’s Be Bad,” “Don’t Say Yes,” “Secondhand White Baby Grand,” “(I Wanna Be a) Smash,” “Don’t Forget Me,” obviously “Let Me Be Your Star,” and so many others. There are barely moments when, as Jerry says, “talking is no longer enough and the characters need to sing,” as defines a musical, because all of the singing in the show comes from the fictional show. It would have been so easy to have a drugged-up Ivy sing “Let’s Be Bad” as a drugged-up Marilyn and then show how this affects the supporting characters in both Ivy’s and Marilyn’s lives. The fact that they didn’t go this route is, frankly, disappointing and leaves me wondering if this even is a musical. There are some spectacular performances, particularly Robyn Hurder as Ivy, Brooks Ashmanskas as Nigel, and John Behlmann as Jerry, though I really wanted more of Caroline Bowman as Karen. The performers do their best to make the mediocre material work and the effort that takes is apparent. This show had so much potential, especially in the score, and it’s astounding to me how they were able to mess that up (how dare they cut the second verse of “Secondhand White Baby Grand”!). If anything, this show made we want to rewatch the tv series again. And, honestly, just stay home and do that and then go to the other Megan Hilty show one block over. At least that truly knows what it’s trying to be. (Edited)
Absolutely terrible book, completely gutted out the heart and drama of the storyline to make a nonsensical “comedy” story that constantly failed. Feel bad for the cast that deserves so much better than this. Also not the fault of the show but the lottery seat was not great.
I was hoping for a flashy, over the top, visually stunning production of Bombshell. The book is the biggest problem (way too many characters and added storylines), followed by a huge lack of big musical numbers and costumes. Robyn Hurder is a STAR!
Great cast, loved the choreography, lovely costumes. Fantastic to see a leading lady (Robyn Hurder) really get to dance and shine while doing it. Some funny moments and wonderful songs, but the ending felt slapped-together like a sketch no one knows how to end. Overall, I felt the comedy didn’t get quite there. Some fun NYC/theater references that I loved, but out-of-towners won’t likely get. I’d heard it billed as a backstage farce, and it just didn’t go far enough, get crazy enough, and Ivy Lynn just didn’t get to go insane enough to feel satisfying. I was hoping for something along the lines of “Noises Off,” but by comparison this felt lukewarm. I wanted to love it. It could have been so much more.
I overall liked the show, honestly one of the funniest shows on Broadway currently. For those that just want a fun night at the theater, this show will give you that. Smash had great source material whether they took more inspiration from the tv show directly or they actually made Bombshell the musical, but I feel like they didn’t use it in the right way. There were too many characters and the great songs we all know were chopped up. Overall it felt like a humorous version of Smash featuring the greatest hits from the TV show.
I think it was not o great musical but I love the costumes and choreography I think they were amazing. I think the characters were not real enough for me I never felt that there were stakes during the musical it never drew me in. It was fine which is arguably one the worst things a musical can be it’s not good but not bad just in the middle. The person playing director is very funny his comedy felt very different from the others and I felt it complemented the book.
Great dancing, funny moments, good set up. Act 2 was not great - no memorable songs and the resolution of the story wasn’t great
121–140 of 238 comments
Absolutely loved it!