Redwood
I liked it, but was pretty much an Idina vanity project - lots of in jokes and the show wouldn’t work with anyone else in the lead role. Was still fun to see her “fly”
no Intermission. The songs are pretty and the tech is amazing. the lady next to me and I zoned out a bit.
She was great despite being clearly sick, clearly no one is safe from the flu! The story and ending were great but the songs don’t stick with you like other productions do, however glad I saw it!
Beautiful and moving. Sit in mezzanine if possible. I loved the set and the sentiments and the talent is off the charts. Unfortunately the story is so full of holes and underdeveloped. The characters are cliche and the relationships are unbelievable. Feels like it was written from a straight, white POV and then characters identities were changed to make it diverse but without getting into the specificity of how (for example) a lesbian relationship differs from a straight one. Still so worth seeing!
I thoroughly enjoyed the show. I give it an A -for sure. Not a perfect new musical, but a damn good one. A grief show filled with heart
The cast is stellar, particularly Jessica Phillips, who did a wonderful job filling in for Idina Menzel (for what I am almost certain is her first fill in performance? You would not be able to tell) That said, almost everything else is a mess, the biggest issue being the book and pacing. Hopefully Menzel will be back in another show soon because this is not it
It was a horrible show. This subject about saving trees should have been a documentary at most but they threw in a couple of personal issues to spruce up the boring storyline. This was torture sitting there with my friend. The songs were either horrible or just boring. Sorry but Idina is bringing in the early crowds but this show will not last.
Saw a preview. Performances were strong. Songs weren’t bad but weren’t great. The special effects at times, especially those during the flashback scenes involving her son, were a little cringe/awkward. But would give it another try in 6-12 months.
some of the lyrics/projections i had mixed emotions about but on the whole it was so sweet and moving idina is soooo talented and also ADORABLE(?) in this role like she just had such a sweet energy also everyone in this show had PIPES 3.5/5
Loved the forest immersion feeling. Lots of talent but didn’t love the music. Subject matter is difficult. Idina is incredible!
It’s a weird story but made me cry so there’s that. The stage is nice and so is the lighting. Not the best show for Idina when I saw it.
Beautiful images of nature and trees. I give this show extra points for exploring the complex issue of grief. I was often moved and ultimately glad I saw it but cannot imagine listening to the music again.
Yikes. I’m not sure what Idina saw in this show. To me, it was like 5 artsy people met a National Geographic travel show about redwood trees. Extremely boring plot, bad quality projections/videography, cheap looking set and underwhelming score.
I did not dislike it, but so much of it did not hit how I wanted it to. The music was fine but mixed too soft and I couldn’t make out most of it. Idina was great but the supports were AWESOME.
Great singing performances and some cool screen/stage work. It sometimes felt long for a no intermission show that was basically a story about grief.
this is one of those shows where you wonder how it got this far. the most predictable plot of any broadway show i’ve ever seen, and far too little character development. the songs seem tailor-made for idina’s voice, which makes them feel tired. the electronic screens are cool, but they feel out of place in a show about connecting w nature.
Idina is glorious...the supporting cast is amazing...but the subject matter is odd, and the sets (mostly video screens) are off-putting.
I rarely hate a show this much - not a single memorable song, really trite , a mix of dated tree hugging and ‘tries too hard to be woke’ and last but not least, not the right time for a California fire scene!
Hearing Idina live (even tho she was recovering from an illness) was great. Performance wise this was solid, but the story didn’t do much for me and some of the characters felt underdeveloped.
141–160 of 258 comments
The set is gorgeous. I loved the use of video. If you are an Idina fan, you will love this show. It is such a showcase for her, that the other characters can feel like an afterthought. I did enjoy this show! But there were a couple of moments where it seemed the songs were just filling time, as opposed to forwarding the story. The songs are good! But towards the middle of the show, they all start to sound the same. Idina carries this show well, and her voice is powerful - but it would help if she’d incorporate some different moods and colors (vocally) in the songs. It can be a breath of fresh air when the other characters are singing. FYI - the story deals with grief. So if you are feeling raw from grief, this show might be triggering. Even with my criticisms, I did enjoy the show, and I’m glad I saw it. But I certainly understand why this show is getting wildly mixed reviews.