Redwood
Very mixed. It starts very slow, I was feeling very weary of the show after the first number. I would say the first half of the show was just a little all over the place. The second half definitely picked up as well as the musical numbers were just better in my opinion. Cool to see Idina in a show and in-person. The rest of the cast was good as well, fun. Overall just mixed. The wrap of the show just felt very on the nose, it spoke for itself and didn’t need the extra reiteration of the premise of the storyline.
Idina is really fantastic, but the writing of the show leaves a lot to be desired. Happy to support an original musical and still recommend. Worth seeing it for her and Zachary. My seat was really extremely partial view. Any time they were in the tree I could only see their legs and below. This was because of a speaker and the mezz overhang. Just don’t be last row of the orch and you’ll be fine.
When people say anything can be a musical, while they are right in theory, some things just don’t really need songs to push the narrative forward. Not that the songs in this show did that, they more so stated facts than actually played into the plot. The plot is very thin, predictable, and not inherently dramatic and it doesn’t do a good job at keeping your attention, even though it’s a one act. The songs all sound similar and every song ends with a Dear Evan Hansen guitar strum. I can’t remember a single song after the show. The performers are all doing their best, but the material just lets them down. Even Idina, who is giving her all, can’t overcome the level of the material no matter how much she belts or does her witch hands. The most powerful moment was the son’s song when she is in purgatory I guess? And I wish the build to that had been as powerful. I assume it will resonate with people who have lost kids and that it does explore how people will try to escape from dealing with their grief. But again, this is all surface level. Design wise I did like what they were trying to do, but many of the projections felt cheap? I don’t know if that’s the right word, but it had that same surface level feel as the material. The main, and really only, set piece, the redwood was cool, but it was also just a tree. I did love how the roots extended into the audience. (Edited)
This was okay. My biggest gripe is that I think the show could’ve been 30 minutes shorter. Some of Idina’s solo numbers were pretty boring (even though she sounded amazing). I found myself really enjoying the score at some points but a lot of it was boring and repetitive. I was there to see Idina but was blown away by Khaila Wilcoxon! What a star.
Unfortunately leaves a lot to be desired. Reminds me a lot of the genre of literary fiction where the main character is "going through it" and everyone is simply begging for them to go to therapy. The songs are mostly disjointed and found a lot of the show to be a bit of a snooze. Khaila Wilcoxon is the one shining light, and every part of their performance was beautiful and grounded.
Call me crazy but I did not love this. I thought about it after and I loved the creative use of the tree and the visuals and the story but I just didn’t feel what I think it was trying to get me to feel. The main character I found annoying. I’m sorry. I’m sure it’s just me.
ultimately ridiculous broadway show. but left it crying #lowkey
Starring Idina Mendzel, Redwood delivers on strong vocal performances across the board and stirring themes of grief and loss. The set is comprised of electronic panels (including some on the floor) and a massive redwood trunk in the center of the set that is well utilized throughout the show. While some of the projections aided the story telling, it felt gratuitous at times and the nature of the themes would have been better suited by a set that leaned into realism, rather than relying on projections alone. There were a few songs that really resonated (In the Leaves and No Repair) though the musical cohesion is a bit lacking. Overall, the show had a strong ending and stronger character development at the onset would have had it sticking the landing even more. See if you love themes related to nature, grief, are an Idina fan, and enjoy shows with a lot of heart (even if the execution needs a little work!)
Maybe I was there on an off night, but I wasn’t wowed. The set design was very cool. The story was ok. The acting was excellent, but Idina was singing off pitch a lot. I’m glad I went but I wouldn’t go again.
idina and i are 2/2 for random technical mishaps happening when i am watching her on stage lmao (HUUUUUGE shoutout to zachary for seamlessly continuing the scene through those fire alarms) i think the bones of this show are wonderful and beautiful and important. i think they missed the mark and either weren’t or didn’t dive as deep as they could’ve. the projections were fine. honestly with all of the projections we have nowadays, i wasn’t too impressed. i liked the huge ass tree a lot. the music was fine, book was eh. performances are obviously incredible, you’ve got four of my favorite actors on stage singing their hearts out.
Redwood has a great book and the electronic panels are stunning. Idina is a legend and the people on stage with her had outstanding voices. I don’t think Idina’s songs were written in her range - or maybe she wasn’t feeling well…but overall we really enjoyed the show. The stand-out was Khaila Wilcoxon who played the role of Becca. She has a beautifully powerful voice.
This show is getting mixed reviews so I will offer the positives. This show is so much more than Idina - the four other performances are absolutely wonderful. This show is cast perfectly. There's some cliche moments in the plot, but I believe that people who have dealt with grief will relate to and ultimately enjoy this show much more. This was certainly the case in our group. Basically, imagine Maureen from Rent grows up, owns an art studio, and is raising her son with her wife. Her son reaches 20, dies unexpectedly. Obviously Maureen would seek healing in a Redwood with some environmentalists. Obviously she'd be a little annoying to everyone around her, but if it's a take me or leave me sort of situation, I'm going to take her.
Paper thin plot and not much happening in this one. A nice idea that doesn’t sustain itself for 2 hours, nor does it ever deliver a much anticipated punch. The only reason to see this is for Idina Menzel’s performance, and I’m not sure that even she can carry the weak script and forgettable score. In fact. I wonder what the point of this production is exactly supposed to be? A woman named Jesse who recently has experienced a tragic loss climbs a Redwood tree with the help of a tree activist and his partner. She tests her limitations by staying in the tree, where she hangs out for a while, removed from her traditional comfort zone. Jesse also sings a few songs about her feelings, because she ostensibly can’t talk about her emotions with the spouse (Mel) that she left behind at home. I gather that Redwood is attempting to impart that some people grieve by moping around in their pjs, whereas other outdoor novices climb Redwood trees in order to face their demons! Except, we’re actually never even privy to Jesse’s demons, other than that she initially never cared much for hippies. We discover that she doesn’t normally climb big trees, and she’s pretty proud of herself for making the ascent. We also learn that Redwood trees can get scorched, but their dead centers still allow life to continue (or something like that). I don’t regret going, but I also wouldn’t recommend it unless you are one of Menzel’s hard core fans and simply won’t care that the story never takes off. We never even find out anything about the logistics of tree dwelling. For instance-how was she making her meals, or what did she use for a toilet? There might’ve been some humor derived from the overwhelming difficulties inherently involved with such an atypical living situation, but there is never any discussion about the mundane, day to day challenges that she faces. Jesse might as well be renting out an Air b’n’b, without much to laugh about or fret over, other than that her cellphone doesn’t always get a signal. Redwood has some interesting moments and cool special effects. An impressive looking redwood forest is digitally recreated. There’s also a big Redwood tree which Jesse learns to hug, after leaving behind her hardened, cynical self in the city in order to embrace her inner hippie spirit in woods. (Edited)
I was bummed :/ cool to see idina live but she was actually pretty shaky vocally and despite the compelling concept of the show there was a soulless disconnected feel.. also 2 hours with no intermission in those very cramped seats is tough!
They should warn those of us with motion sickness ahead of time. I found myself closing my eyes a lot to keep the nausea at bay. The photos move with speed and random directions. Otherwise I enjoyed the music!
IDINA MENZEL did not disappoint 🥰 I literally always got chills from her singing. I solely went for her though so I’m satisfied. The plot of the show was very predictable though and I feel like the set design/projections were too electronic for a show about nature/trees. It took me out of the feels and felt lackluster. Maybe I just had too high of expectations though 🙂↔️ (Edited)
It was boring, but it wasn’t as bad as people say. I didn’t care for the singing, the song book, or the storyline. The screen usage feels gaudy, I’ve seen many productions that used a digital set well, and this wasn’t one of them. The story feels forced and not believable. Khaila Wilcoxon was the star for me. Her singing was the best inmho. De’Adre Aziza was great as a vocalist but the acting was also unbelievable. The story felt very disjointed and just not believable. Adina’s character was just annoying from start to finish. Literally she just ticked me off by the end of the play. Very mediocre show, think toasted white bread with unsalted margarine. It’s not bad, it’s just bland, confusing and mildly annoying. (Edited)
121–140 of 258 comments
Story and music weren’t the best but it was a marvelous production. In the mezzanine, the video design made it feel like I was on the Disney ride Soarin’