Redwood
Very emotional
Great music!!!
Show was great!
Absolutely loved it!
Idina is always wonderful
Whimper cryed, loved it!
Amazing acrobatics! Wonderful play.
Brilliant.
Awesome!
Amazing!
Amazing 🤩
i had mixed feelings about this show, despite having an overall cathartic, enjoyable experience–i even cried during "no repair" and "still." i don't know if i'm in love with the 100 percent projected set, there were moments i felt like it distracted from the weight of the show, rather than added to the "magic" of the redwood forest. that being said, if you want to get the most out of "redwood," you have to accept the novelty early on. now, on to the performances! i felt like idina got exponentially better as the night went along, and as jesse unfolded herself more and more to the audience. she was almost frustratingly charming at first, then BOOM, you get hit with jesse's mini freak out her first night on the tree, and you get it. the denuonment of the show is obvious early on, but that didn't take away from my emotional investment, and that's in large part bc idina keeps things engaging, AND because the supporting cast's performances, especially becca's, are so strong. did "redwood" change my life? no. but it moved me in specific moments, and i felt the belief the cast had in the importance of the musical, and that was enough to smooth over some of the more overt melodrama for me. also, shout out to mel's standby, veronica otim, who did a wonderful job! she and idina had great chemistry, and i loved how discordant (IN A GOOD WAY) their voices sounded on "back then." that all being said, the songs were a bit forgettable, and the show overall lagged. ugh. i really wanted to like this more than i did, but i just felt like the songs didn't dig deep enough--someone on here described them as "deflating" and i agree 100%. and yet, despite all this, i urge you all to go see this musical, at least to support the few truly original shows on the great white way right now. watching the effort put into this is worth it. (Edited)
It’s thrilling to see a brand new, original musical starring a Broadway legend, especially one co-conceived and directed by the brilliant Tina Landau. As someone who adored the musical If/Then, Idina Menzel’s last stint on Broadway, I was pumped to see her onstage again a decade later in something totally different. Sadly, Redwood, a show that sounds incredible on paper, in reality does not have the impact one would expect. The plot revolves around Jesse, played by Idina Menzel, who gives everything she has to the role. However, Jesse’s motivations are thrown at the audience too quickly and without clarity. As a result, Menzel’s character comes off as spoiled and thoughtless. The commentary about the environment could have been interesting and timely but it always comes second to Jesse’s seemingly random pursuits. The music written by newcomer Kate Diaz, wanders in a way that isn’t exploratory but instead sounds lost. The final product is a string of songs that all sound similar, and forgettable. The lyrics by Diaz and Landau are frequently cliché. Song titles like “Stars”, “Great Escape”, and “Drive”, all overused sentiments themselves, contain equally tired lyrics. Menzel sings on average every eight minutes in a show that is less than two hours long. By her tenth musical number, a wave of audience members rocked uncomfortably in their seats with heads dipping down to check the song list in their Playbills. Although the videos are beautifully designed by Hana S. Kim, it is off-putting to watch a musical grounded in nature where often the only thing filling the stage is a wall of screens. The screens swallow the actors and distract from the point of the show. In a world where audiences spend most of their days staring at screens, it is disappointing to see a live performance that is dominated by the same technology. The highlight of this production is Khalia Wilcoxon as Becca, whose epic stage presence and powerhouse vocals break the monotony of the show. However, Becca, seems to exist only as a sort of wise, voice of reason to two privileged, white, middle-aged characters, Jesse and Finn. It’s a shame the character Becca was not given the development this awe-inspiring actor deserves. For those who are super fans of Menzel, I encourage you to go and make up your own mind as her charming personality and one-of-kind vocals are on full display. However, the lack of a compelling story paired with a forgettable score and often cliché lyrics makes Redwood a show I cannot recommend. I feel conflicted sharing these criticisms as original musicals are vital to the Broadway landscape. As someone who is constantly seeking new work, I wanted to love this production. Based on the passion onstage, it is clear the creative team built this show with the best intensions. Redwood is proof that just because you have all the right ingredients for a hit Broadway musical, doesn’t guarantee it will resonate with audiences. (Edited)
Sometimes you have to face your inner turmoil alone with a tree. Be prepared for a show about grief and the interpersonal struggles regarding the different ways we deal with it. Might be hard for anyone recently experiencing grief. A bit heavy handed at the end, though I cried in the big struggles. Idina sings almost the whole show with some big belting numbers. Also, there’s no intermission with this two-hour long show, so use the restroom and get your concessions before.
It surprised me. Slow start, wasn’t understanding her diction, didn’t connect with her at first, a bit of “telling vs showing” in the unfolding of the script, but as it unfolded I got so engrossed in it. Interestingly, I felt for 2 of the other characters right away, and her later. Then it built to something SOOO moving and heartfelt.
I didn’t like it at all. Story is not well told. Didn’t like Idina’s singing at all. Music was mediocre. Liked the stage design and the project mapping. I think front mezzanine are the best seats to enjoy the show. But I will not go again. Show has no intermission. Being stuck in those crampy mezzanine eats for over 2hours is a torture. Please add an intermission.
So my main attraction to this show was to see Idina Menzel—and she is unquestionably incredibly talented. The visual effects are also really well done, although flagging that I was front row and that potentially too close. Where I struggled was with the emotional connection of the show—everyone is super talented and the effects are great, but I don’t think I got the heart of the show. I also felt like the beginning was a bit disjointed and difficult to understand.
If you’re a big fan of Idina Menzel and like more unconventional sparser Broadway shows this one might be worth catching but it didn’t work for me. There are some great voices but the story didn’t really hang together and none of the songs stood out to me. Instead of a set there are primarily huge background projections which are used in many different—at times abstract ways. The pacing felt off—there was no intermission but it felt like there were multiple moments that felt like a transition to one. If you do see this show I’d guess front of mezz would be the best spot. I saw this from back of the orchestra which wasn’t too bad but you feel the overhang more with this show than others. I’d try to avoid the extreme sides where you might miss some of the screens.
101–120 of 258 comments
This is amazing talented cast and production!!! It spoke to my soul