Redwood
The projections were were very well done, but you could probably appreciate more from mezzanine. The actors were excellent, but the book needs work. (Edited)
Honestly such a shame this show is closing! I really did enjoy it but I may be biased as an Idina fan. It was a good length of show although some songs could’ve been cutz
people who would like this show: idina menzel super fans, people who like hyperrealistic nature set and special effects, and people who like redwood facts. The one liners in this play between the forest researchers were good but the grief line in this play felt lost among the sauce
she’s so so talented and so is the whole cast. gorgeous set. just not my fav show in the world!
Really could've been better. The set is stunning and takes you on a journey. The music is good enough but the lead actress could've been much better vocally. Khaila Wilcoxon stole the show for me.
Great singing but the story kinda messy. I think that the reason for her journey should’ve been stated earlier and not waited so long to reveal or hint at it. It first seemed like she was just running from her problems as a workaholic. The ending was nice but I didn’t feel a big impact. They all have beautiful voices though.
Idina was great but the score was quite underwhelming, could have been a play… also maybe less screens in the set design? Just a thought.
Redwood delivers visually with a stunning 10/10 set design, using dynamic projections and screens to fully immerse the audience. The supporting cast shines—especially Khaila Wilcoxon—while Idina Menzel impresses vocally but falls a bit short in acting. Unfortunately, the story lacks depth and the music is mostly forgettable aside from a few strong tracks. Though the sound design is well done and direction has its moments, the overall pacing and emotional impact feel uneven. A visually striking show, but narratively underwhelming—I'd give it a 6.5/10. (Edited)
Despite having really strong scenic design and some cool moments involving climbing the tree, this show really has one of the weakest books and scores I’ve seen in a while. The book is just really shallow and all over the place and the score really just sounds the same most of the time and is mostly forgettable besides one or two songs, would only recommend if you really like Idina Menzel (though honestly did not love her performance here)
This show is conceived by Idina Menzel, and she just doesn’t shine in it. She is the weakest singer on stage and there are maybe a handful of memorable songs. I expected a lot more from a show on Broadway. Save your money.
Some portions dragged a bit and lacked that spark, but some were extremely poignant and tear evoking. Overall 7/10.
Loved the multi themes for this show. Liked some of the cast. Liked the set. Idina as well as other songs were rough Book was lacking Rough @ Start (Edited)
Great great innovative show! Idina Menzel was struggling to control her voice- everyone else was such a better singer. Still worth it though
Sure to satisfy anyone looking to hear Idina belt live! She and the rest of the cast sound great, but the story and characters feel uneven, and the songs forgettable. Not quite the towering show they were aiming at.
Good intentions, songs, and scenic design. However it missed the mark a bit by tryin to hit the emotional gut punch it is tryin to convery. Enjoyed it but didn't love it
What a great band led by Queen Julie Mcbride, and such a stellar cast. Idina’s acting is phenomenal. And no spoilers but Zach Piser nails his song so hard. Flagging this one for sensory accessibility issues with the tech, and the show is not totally my vibe but still strong moments and could be worth a watch for many.
161–180 of 258 comments
Pretty sure Idina Menzel wasn't feeling well at the performance I saw - the show has so much potential but I just wasn't wowed. Hoping it was just the bug that's going around.