The Great Gatsby
Went with friends who were visiting out of town and they fell asleep at the first half lol. Thought it was missing something but Ryan McCartan’s voice was amazing. Second half was much better. (Edited)
the new cast is a huge downgrade imo (and I’m not just talking about reeve). the singalong was fun but nobody around me was singing which sucked
Saw Ryan at the start of his run and now nearing the end. I think he’s come into how he plays the character I just don’t enjoy his interpretation/choices. But he sings the shiz out of it. Sam Pauly is amazing, the verve she imbues Jordan with is contagious. Very excited to see Jeremy Jordan in Nov.
There are a lot of mixed reviews for this show and I never read the book or watched the movie but I thought it was decent. Wouldn’t see again but Jeremy Jordan exceeded my expectations he is incredible. I was also hooked the entire time the story was interesting and the set design is pretty cool. Just nothing super special about this one. (Edited)
Jeremy Jordan!!! Sam Pauly!!! Eva was unfortunately out the night we went! Music was not my fave but the choreo was great. (Edited)
The Great Gatsby, now playing at Paper Mill Playhouse, is an honest to god adaptation of the famous Fitzgerald novel. That is, in a lot of ways, it is utterly predictable. It relies a bit too heavily on the audience having an in depth knowledge of the source material. On the flip side, it is a literary nerds dream (or at least this former English teachers.) The most famous lines are plucked right from the page and come to life on the stage with a freshness I wasn’t anticipating. This production soars high largely because of its stellar cast. Jeremy Jordan’s stunningly clear tone is reason enough to see it. His Gatsby, while still incredibly charming, carries a school boy desperation that not only humanizes him but adds a much needed layer of humor. Eva Noblezada aches with resonance as Daisy and is a true force of nature you cannot stand to tear your eyes from. Samantha Pauly’s Jordan Baker brings a much needed feminist lens to the narrative (although this adaptation in no way passes the Bechtel test.) I longed for more from her and Noah J. Ricketts as Nick Caraway. Their ease of chemistry created a necessary counter balance to the tumultuous melodrama unfolding between the long lost lovers. Dominique Kelley’s choreography has the ensemble teaming with life by infusing the movement of the roaring twenties with flickers of modern moments. The set design feels purposefully reminiscent of the 2013 movie adaptation, making use of both physical set facades that are immeasurably enhanced by the projections. This is no doubt an attempt to draw on the nostalgia and success of the DiCaprio film. At the end of the day, the story’s message of “the lie of the American Dream” is lost. It felt shoehorned in at the end with Wolfsheim’s quick aside at Gatsby’s funeral. Because this essential point got muddled, the production struck me as tone deaf - especially since the director Marc Bruni states in his director’s note that he is actively attempting to draw parallels between then and now. But if you go in with the mindset that this is just a standard Gatsby adaptation, that has no real interest in pushing boundaries, you’ll have a lovely time.
The costumes and choreography were absolutely stunning, and Jeremy Jordan was phenomenal. He brought so much presence and talent to the role. My biggest complaint, though, is that the production seemed to almost go out of its way to make Nick Carraway appear straight, which felt like a deliberate and unnecessary choice. While there was a lot to admire visually and performance-wise, that decision was distracting and disappointing. (Edited)
I think this show is fine. I think there are some good songs and I like the sets and costumes. Happy to finally see Eva Nobelzada after she last minute called out on 3 prior shows I was supposed to see her in. She does have a great voice and I wish she was a more reliable performer.
At first I was disappointed to have Eva out for my performance, but her replacement was great! The sets were amazing if the pacing suffered slightly.
It’s a silly little show with mostly forgettable music and a lot of mid performers, but Gatsby, the sets and the costumes were excellent. Fun to see Sarah Hyland. Just come in with the right expectations and you’ll have a good time.
Dazzling, captivating extravaganza. The show is definitely fun to watch. Being a devoted fan of the book, I felt it completely missed the mark on the satyrical, detached tone that is a core element of the original social critique. Both the scenes and the lyrics are hollow, full of unfunny and forced remarks, and attempt relatibility where there should be none. If you want a fun spectacle- run, don't walk. If you want a complex tragedy of the American dream- this is not the show for that.
as a theater show, this show was beautifully technically and well done. as far as story goes, this personally wasn’t for me. but, that’s okay! i still had a good time. i particularly liked the roles of nick and jordan, they both definitely stole the show for me. everyone had really great voices, though.
I thought this musical was nice but I probably wouldn’t see it again. I felt like the casting was a little odd though - there was no chemistry between Gatsby and Daisy and I felt like the ending was a little too drawn out. It was nice to see Corbin Bleu on Broadway, however. (Edited)
581–600 of 856 comments
The seat wasn’t great, as it was partial view and it was on the side where people came in and out the door and where there was a balcony at times, so I couldn’t see that. Overall the play was ok. The actors were pretty good, but it wasn’t anything to write home about. I enjoyed the song and dance for the most part. Honestly, it is the only play/musical where I find it to exactly reflect the book it’s based on. There was nothing added nor taken away, and I liked that. It also helped me understand the book more deeply from seeing it be played out visually.