The Great Gatsby
the music wasn't really memorable, with the exception of beautiful little fool, and one-way-road, which completely shifted my feelings about myrtle, the actress did an incredible job. eva and jeremy sounded absolutely gorgeous, their performances sold me on daisy and gatsby's love story. i will say, though, that subtlety was lost on this musical–it didn't seem to trust the audience to form their own conclusions on the larger themes in the great gatsby: the new rich, class, WOMEN, women in MARRIAGE. this was never more present than in the transition to song. i never felt like anything the characters were saying in song, they couldn't have also expressed it in dialogue. it was technically integrated fine, but a little anachronistic in the fact that i don't think the women would've been able to express their ideas about the constraints of marriage, wifehood, and motherhood so clearly. i wanted the songs to arise from that place of confusion. i think the song that best did that was one-way-road. eva was a conatant show stopper, though. her voice and attitude and emotiveness softened the obvious lyrics for me. she added a necessary depth that would've been absent without her almost manically moving through the stage, twitching her body, like daisy was fighting against restraints and the bars of a cage. costumes were beautiful, ensemble was incredible, especially the tap break in act 2. i had mixed feelings about the heavy use of projection in the set, it felt like it flattened the show rather than adding authenticity, which is what I felt the goal was. i'll also say act 1 dragged in comparison to act 2, which really exploded during go and made to last. (Edited)
When intermission started, the person next to me said something along the lines of “it’s pretty much identical to the book so far.” For a second I thought I was going crazy because it wasn’t what I remembered the book to be like, but upon looking it up, my memory was right: this show was completely out of order. I’m not sure how well this worked for me, I think I liked some elements of it, but other times it felt like it rushed the plot together. The choreography, costumes, and set design was spectacular though!
The first half of the show was kinda boring, the second half was actually enjoyable. That could be because all of the action happened after the intermission. I also think that the seats being so close together that I was more focused on my discomfort than the actual goings on, on stage. The sets and the costumes were phenomenal. The acting wasn’t too bad and the singing for all except one person was good. There was one person every time they sang I dozed off. My seat also had certain moments where it was blocked because of the ladder on the stage that served almost no purpose but for one song. I would recommend this show to someone who likes glitz and glamour and loves the slow burn. I personally would not watch this again unless a celebrity I liked was in it.
I was hesitant to see it -knowing that it would be a stretch from Fitzgerald’s original work, but it was worth it for the sets and costumes alone. However, they are known for using understudies at the last minute, and sure enough-3 out of the 4 leads were understudies at the performance we went to. The understudies were fine, but I really wanted to see Eva Noblezada and Samantha Pauly. I’m not sure how they get away with using understudies in the leads ALL of the time, but you should definitely be aware of that if you’re going to see Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada. Chances are one of them won’t be performing. The show is a lot of fun/fabulously entertaining ensemble, so kudos to the non leads. It’s all eye candy-not deep or thought provoking but a lot of fun!
The spectacle! So glitzy, and some strong ballads to back it up. I think the costumes might have been my favourite part of this show. Being close to the stage was a plus in my opinion, you might not get a center view of the ensemble choreo, but I’d much rather be witness to the small details and reactions of the cast. Eva Noblezada was quite literally radiant, and I cannot stress enough how strong her vocals are. Absolutely incredible performance by Corbin Bleu and I appreciated him leaning into the comedy. To be completely honest I don’t think Reeve Carney was cast correctly as Gatsby vocally, but obviously his and Eva’s chemistry was on point. Loved the blocking of the pool scene, and Eva’s rendition of Beautiful Little Fool had me sobbing. Would absolutely recommend, especially to fans of the book and/or movie!
first time seeing gastby and it was extra special. first row seats, nina by my side and eva noblezada on stage. life was good even tho the show was a tad boring (but it was beautiful).
I’m not sure about this show…the acting was good but the musical numbers fell flat for me. Some were great but others were just meh. I also saw the US for Daisy, who was good but I could immediately tell how the songs would’ve perfectly fit Eva’s voice so I may go back simply to see Eva perform Daisy. Obviously, Jeremy was fantastic. Set and costume design were also insane but wasn’t expecting anything less for a musical based in the 20s. I’d recommend for the talent but the show itself was a little bit of a letdown. Doesn’t really tackle any of the main themes of the book so if you’re looking for something to stick to the subject matter, this ain’t it. But if you’re looking for glitz, glam, and some fancy footwork you may like this. (Edited)
I went to see jeremy jordan but i wasn’t amazed with the show tbh. None of the songs stuck with me. The dude who played Tom was fine tho. He and Jeremy both came out for stage door and I love jeremy so ultimately, I won.
I wanted to love it but prepared myself to not. Overall, enjoyed it visually. Nick Carraway was the break out star for me and offered lots of funny and tender moments with Jordan Baker. Agree with others noting songs were not memorable. The music and choreography on the other hand was stunning. The tap sequences!
The Great Gatsby is a dazzling show with really fun and GREAT production and costume design. However, as a musical, it wasn’t exceptional. The songs were average and relied heavily on belting, which didn’t actually elevate the performance. Yes, the actors can reach high notes, but the songs were just not well-written, and the melodies were neither catchy nor memorable for me. I haven’t read the book, but I’m still not a fan of the story itself or how accurately this show adapted the book or the movie. I’m just a fan of Eva Noblezada’s work, which is what still made me watch this show, and her performance did not disappoint. She is probably the highlight of the show. The only goosebump moment that raised the score for me was her performance of “Beautiful Little Fool.” Other than that, everything was just okay. I was so disappointed that I wasn’t able to see Jeremy Jordan in this performance because I was really looking forward to it. Austin Colby is charismatic, but in this performance, he made a few singing mistakes, and his performance wasn’t flawless, which somewhat affected the experience. Overall, The Great Gatsby is an impressive visual spectacle with a standout performance from Eva Noblezada, but as a musical, it falls short due to lackluster songs and inconsistent performances. (Edited)
went out on a whim to see this and it was good! i never really was a fan of the book or the movie, but i wanted to give the musical a chance. “Roaring On” and “New Money” are my favs for sure, and i loved being able to see Samantha Pauly (Jordan) & Ryan McCartan (Gatsby) because i absolutely love them. Act I was stronger than Act II, but i still enjoyed myself for a solid majority of the runtime. wouldn’t necessarily watch again unless a pro shot is released, but that’s okay!
First time up close. Had a rocky start, but really pulled itself together after a bit. Austin Colby shined during Made to Last. Still a McCartan fan
Honestly really enjoyed this show - thought Sarah Hyland was especially incredible in the second half. But overall, the show almost felt too straightforward in comparison to the book. I feel that the book really makes you THINK and has metaphors etc, that the lyrics don’t really display the same way. It felt a bittt commercialized. HOWEVER that being said there were a few great songs - like Beautiful Little Fool - that are stuck in my head! The performances were fabulous, and the ending scenes really had me on the edge of my seat. So overall, a 3/5 I’d say. Def worth a watch.
The lyrics and the script were breathtaking. Saw Ryan McCartan and Sarah Hyland as Gatsby and Daisy. Both had solid performances and amazing pipes. But I didn’t feel any chemistry between them. Terribly sad I missed Jeremy & Eva. Edited to add: John Zdrojeski’s Tom was AMAZING. (Edited)
(Spoiler alert) Just loved how everyone was so shocked and leaned forward to see where Jeremy Jordan fell into the pool
4/5 ⭐️. The Simplified Gatsby. Glitzy set, costumes, decor, dancing in full '20s swing. Fun and good time to a familiar story. 2.5 hours; 1 intermission. But watered down version of the novel losing some dimensions. 4 of original cast were out; would've liked to see them. Diversity: a little. Title character played by conventionally attractive cis straight White male. Some characters played by people of color.
Tremendous talent on stage. Worth it to see “My Green Light” live and Sara Chase as Myrtle was a revelation, but overall The Great Gatsby is not my favorite story in musical form.
I think The Great Gatsby was a missing piece on Broadway. Considering how important this story is to American culture, it’s almost surprising that there hadn’t already been a Broadway musical adaptation. The show is very well done and clearly a big production. When I saw it, it reminded me of Moulin Rouge! in terms of cast size, dance numbers, and overall production value. It’s an easy show to like—you really can’t go wrong with it. It’s an original musical, and the songs are genuinely enjoyable. I saw the original cast, and I was especially excited to finally see Eva Noblezada perform live. She was just as great as I expected her to be. Personally, I wasn’t a big fan of Jeremy Jordan’s performance; for me, it didn’t feel very communicative. That said, I do recognize that Gatsby himself is a rather cold and distant character, which may have been an intentional choice.
Gatsby has all of the elements you want in a broadway show- big voices, splashy dance numbers, complex sets, gorgeous costumes, pyrotechnics, etc. Technically, the show is prestige and the cast (particularly Jordan and Eva) sing their absolute hearts out and are immensely talented. As a fan of the book however, I couldn’t help but cringe at the deviations from the plot. It didn’t seem to me like the creators had love or full understanding of the novel- particularly it’s most complex characters. I ultimately did enjoy myself and am very happy to be able to see the show before Eva and Jordan finished up their runs. But the music nor the plot didn’t blow me off my feet enough to make me give this a full thumbs up.
561–580 of 856 comments
yessss