The Great Gatsby
Finallyyy saw the show with Jeremy and was absolutely amazing!!!! My first time with the new cast, and i had a blast! Plus Dari was on for Myrtle and Traci was on for Jordan! So so great, as well as Michael and Austin❤️ Aisha. Freaking. Jackson. Oh my goodness🥹 I saw her in OUAOMT, and she was the clear standout there, and she was fantastic as Daisy!! So much emotion, and her vocals soared!!!!! I felt so lucky to see her and Jeremy together, their voices were like magic😭👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I’ll admit I wasn’t a fan of Aisha vocally as Daisy the first time I saw her, however tonight changed that! She sounded totally different, perhaps that first night she was ill or just an off day. She BLEW my mind with a lyric change in “Absolute Rose”, I love how she did it. Ryan has continually grown into this role, and he put 1000% of his emotion into his performance last night, I’m always blown away.
Wow this one was so fun!! My first ever lottery win and I knew about the story because of the book/movie but I knew nothing about the music and left with some of my favorite musical songs!! So happy I got to see Jeremy and Eva and especially Jeremy since it was his last week with the show! What great voices that my goodness! Michael Maliakel was such a standout as well like he played SUCH a great Nick. This was also my first ever lottery win and I thought the seats would be too angled to the right but I actually could still 100% see everything in the show so personally I think if you can try for the lottery for this show i definitely would!
3rd watch, with my gf this time! And their 1000th performance on Broadway! It’s now especially enjoyable now that I am very familiar with the music having listened to it way too much!! Seat today wasn’t as good as my previous shows, but watching it from afar and a different angle also gave me a new perspective (well, literally, but also, the perspective is that Orchestra is way better lol). I got to meet the cast today too, first time doing this after a Broadway show, very fun indeed!  (Edited)
THE GATSBY THAT IS GREAT 😭 Eva noblezada made me cry
I cried the whole time through, it was beautiful. Song dance acting spectacle, everything A1 (Edited)
We sat far over in the Right orchestra but still saw everything on stage. Sam Pauly who plays Jordan stole the whole show. She was the star. We had two understudies today. Both were amazing. Especially the understudy for Nick. Highly recommend. (Edited)
This one’s crazy. My wedding weekend is upon us… I win the lotto for a Thursday night show; my rehearsal is Friday. Do I go? Yes! I mean-Corbin Bleu is Nick Carroway!! Do I bring my bestie snd bridesmaid who flew in from Costa Rica the night before? Absolutely! Do we stay to stage door? YES Corbin wished me the best in my marriage so I’d say it was a win!
main cast- daisy: eva noblezada nick: corbin bleu jay gatsby: reeve carney tom: john behlmann jordyn: tracie elaine lee (u/s) myrtle: tess soltau (u/s) meyer wolfsheim: dave schoonover (u/s) wow okay. in awe from the opening number. corbin bleu is incredible live i’m so impressed. the most exciting part of this show for me was seeing eva noblezada, and she absolutely rose above all of my hopes. her attitude her voice her mannerisms, everything is perfect. her voice can be so calm and soothing, so sultry and raw, and so powerful. she is truly a legend. her ability to grab hold of the audiences attention is astonishing. there are quite literally no words i can effectively use to describe the way she delivers beautiful little fool live. otherworldly is the best i can come up with. there is an infinite amount of other things i want to say about her but it’s so hard to put into words. nothing compares to seeing this woman live. she is just magnificent. every human should get to see eva noblezada live because it is the closest a human can get to heaven on earth. reeve did pretty well, only tea was really good and it was really nice to see him and eva together. he poured one champagne glass instead of two i wonder if this was a mistake? idk. jordyn was an understudy i was surprised she walked out on stage and i was like uhhh so that’s not samantha pauly. i was a little disappointed because i love samantha but she did great, excellent atttude for jordyn. corbin bleu’s voice is so nice i love his head voice so much. the met was really good and his acting is just always on point he did great. he is so smooth in his dancing i love it, brings me back to i don’t dane from hsm lol. the dancing and the music was so beautiful i quite enjoyed. ahem the ending WHAT? i had no idea. very good tho actually and i’m glad i didn’t know the ending beforehand because i was shocked. meeting everyone was very nice and i am just so grateful to have seen eva i love her to death i will never forget this night. i absolutely recommend, this production is so visually stunning and heartfelt. especially with eva in the cast, you will be guaranteed a nice of emotion and awe.
Seen it twice already first time when it was Ryan’s opening night he was phenomenal. And just took my sister to see it yesterday. I cried when he sang The Past Is Catching Up To Me! The new cast members are amazing as well THE WHOLE SHOW masterpiece. SEE IT YOU WONT REGRET IT.
I’ve been wanting to see this show since I saw the rehearsal videos back in Oct 2023, and the show didn’t disappoint! Absolutely incredible, from the sets, costumes, acting, singing, and dancing, everything was so amazing. The only bad part about this seat was that it was the last row of the orchestra. Due to the mezzanine overhang, I couldn’t see the Dr Eckleburg billboard all that well. However, that didn’t take away from my experience and I had a fantastic time!
4th watch!! Absolutely love the show, and I love that after many shows with different cast, I can really see how different singer / actor have such different personal styles in singing, it’s lovely! I also love how this is my first time watching this dead center, I realized the (high tech) stage design is soooo well done!! Love it. (Edited)
On the surface, this musical is flashy and spectacular filled with classic Broadway tap numbers and glitzy costuming. They drive cars on stage!! Beneath that gleaming surface lies an American tragedy just as spectacular as the fireworks simulated on stage. The production beautifully fleshed out the tribulations of love by bringing the female characters to the forefront, while managing to keep the crushing nature of the idolization of the American dream in tact. The second act kept me on the edge of my seat. Michael Maliakel’s harrowing Act II performance cemented this piece as a classic American tragedy. Bravo!! 🎇🚙 (Edited)
Love the great gatsby so much and this view was AMAZING!! I thought it would be difficult to see considering I was on the far right but it was absolutely perfect! Eva noblezada never fails to amaze me!!
i just loveeee big broadway musicals! classic dance numbers (including tap!!) with incredible music definitely put this show up in my favorites. the costumes were enchanting. while i wasn’t a huge fan of the book, the musical brought it to life in a way that i really enjoyed. Michael Maliakel was such a stand out for me! i will definitely be back to catch Jeremy before he leaves :) (Edited)
1–20 of 856 comments
i know some people aren’t the biggest fan of this gatsby but personally i really enjoyed it. i’ve seen it two times, once back in february 2025 and in march 2025. in march i went to see it for sarah chase, john zdrojeski, and noah j. ricketts final performance. both times i was blown away by everything. the set was fun and lively, looking grand and elegant when it needed to. the party scenes looked awesome. as a dancer i thoroughly enjoyed when they started tap dancing during “la dee dah with you”. ryan mccartan’s chemistry with sarah hyland was beautiful, as was noah j. ricketts with sam pauly. and although myrtle isn’t that good of a person, the way she was written and her solo song “one-way road”, really made me root for her to get a happy ending even though i knew what would happen. and i truly enjoyed “beautiful little fool”. it’s my favorite song- i love how we get to see into daisy’s mind of why she chose to make the decisions she did while not absolving her of the wrongs she caused.