Tammy Faye
This show has such great potential, but a very subpar book, where every scene is more about informing the audience about historical facts than dramatizing them, not very memorable songs, which is a shame because Elton John has written some amazing musicals, and an overall confusion about what the show is lead to a very unsatisfying night. It continues the problem Lempicka had which is that they have decided to tell her entire life story, despite the fact that her life doesn’t end in any satisfying way, leading to them having to scramble to figure out how to end it.
The set was kind of cool? Very interesting sunset blvd homage at the beginning of Act 2… I just gotta give it up to the cast because they really were giving it their all with such a subpar book and score. Some things just shouldn’t be adapted for the stage!
i hesitate to review a 1st preview but my issues aren’t things I think would be changed: The script is chaotic, the staging by use of the middle aisle seems junior and at a high school production, the songs memorable and also forgettable all at once the sets are really nice but also not utilized well
The idea is fascinating, the lead actress has an amazing voice and the ensemble is thrilling to watch. That being said the stakes are too low, the book is fairly surface and doesn't go deep, and we don't have sympathy for the titular character. I was bored. Also Tammy Faye's hair and makeup were WAY too small lol
It tried and tried, but sadly, couldn’t pull it off. It was trying to be campy in one way, bit it just ended up being campy in a totally different way. The portrayals were all caricatures, and the woman playing Tammy Faye was amazing, but couldn’t save this clunker
As much as I’m sad to see Tammy Faye close, I honestly feel like it deserved to be. I just couldn’t take it seriously. The songs were disappointing, with melodies that weren’t catchy, and the lyrics didn’t leave an impact. The choreography was messy, and I struggled to connect with the characters because of the lazy writing. I honestly believe the show had the potential to be incredibly moving if it had been directed and executed with more heart. Katie Brayben gave an emotional and heartfelt performance, and I could feel her passion. However, she was given weak material to work with, which held her back. I also wasn’t a fan of Christian Borle’s performance. Despite these flaws, I don’t think Tammy Faye is the worst thing in Broadway. The production value was actually impressive. The costumes and set design were visually pleasing, and I really appreciated the creative use of television blocks stacked together to represent people. Because of that I think the show is still watchable. It’s just the cringeworthy lines, songs, and choreography took away from the inspiration I wanted to feel from Tammy Faye’s story. Overall, it’s a missed opportunity, but with stronger direction and a better script, it could have been much more impactful.
First preview of the show, so there were some technical difficulties. Mics kept getting cut off and blocking could use some work. Performance wise, it was good but not too memorable. Story felt a bit rushed and not fleshed out enough. I didn’t enjoy it as much as I expected.
The show doesn’t know if it wants to honor Tammy Faye or play satire and there is very little substance. A few cute and funny moments but it’s a musical that’s makes you feel bored and even uncomfortable at times. Especially around election time, it’s an awkward reminder of serious things that still go on today, but the show just asks you to laugh at it all.
man this was,,, not it! didn’t really enjoy anything about this one… I kinda liked the TV set design situation and Katie was memorable in some parts but everything from the direction to the music to most of the lead performances were just so boring and weird and overall not fun! I went into it with low expectations but left with lower ones somehow 1/5
The show doesn’t know what it wants to be. The split personality of the story telling doesn’t help. Camp or documentary. Clever staging. Epically bad timing for this musical. Seeing even Michael Cerveris play Jerry Falwell doesn’t help given current political climate. The lifted Palace Theatre is quite nice.
You have to want it to get a “didn’t like it” from me… But yikes, this is in contention for the worst thing I’ve ever seen. Could not figure out what it wanted to be. I felt badly for the actors.
The ensemble kills is and so does Katie Brayben was fantastic, but other than that, it’s a meh show… There were good concepts, but everything became redundant, and unoriginal. Overall, it’s a fine show, but not really a show we need right now
Katie Brayben was fantastic! That’s about it. Very cheap looking and feeling production.
The music and book felt like a waste of the actors’ talent, and went on way longer than necessary
Story is boring and flat , a lot of people left after the first act I
Tammy Faye was godawful. Abysmal. The book sucked, the score all sounded the same, the set was ugly, the lights were headache-inducing. And it’s not even bad in a fun way, it’s just bad. Do not go for any price
There’s no denying the star power of the 3 leads. But even they couldn’t save an otherwise lackluster score and book.
too long - the writing was not very good book and song wise - the choreography was really messy - this show has a longgggg way to go
Left during intermission. Painful 😒
61–80 of 91 comments
this was so disappointing. the cast is stacked. the music is elton john. and yet the theater cleared out at intermission. i attached the pic of my full row. my whole row left. the best part was when the fire alarm backstage… TWICE.