Tammy Faye
sorry but this show was my guilty pleasure. so sad it closed.
I liked it! Fun music great cast, loved the costuming
Very enjoyable. The actress who played Tammy Faye was incredible. Tony nominee for sure.
The three leads are great and show is mostly fun! (Edited)
Loved Katie Brayben
It was good and cute story but satire!
Christian Borel!
Had so much fun!
We really enjoyed it!
good very well done show
To be fair-review based on a FIRST night “preview” (so there’s room for improvement): Pros: Katie and Christian, and whole Ensemble really are so talented! Katie is amazing and carried the show. Christian was a great Jim, and very funny. In fact, the show has some laugh out loud moments, and adult humor. The ensemble at stage door were elated to be in this production, and their energy on stage showed it. Balcony seats were affordable and the view was pretty good. The preview tote bags and buttons placed on each seat were a nice touch! Cons: Regardless of a technical pause in the show, it is too long (hope they trim it). Tho the balcony seats had decent view, the lack of leg room up there started to get uncomfortable (esp. bc of the shows length). As for the story itself, Tammy’s life as an evangelist was complicated: religion, power, money, love, sex, fame. Unfortunately, the characters didn’t come off as complicated or deep as they could have. The songs were good, but not catchy enough that I remember them this morning. The set design was cool at first, but the “Hollywood Squares” type cubes got old after 3 hours. Overall, it’s an entertaining show. See it as an add-on to your already planned day in NYC, or if you score some cheap seats. If you’re a Christian Borle fan, you’ll enjoy it and it’s worth spending more to be closer to stage. (Edited)
maybe they want you to feel middle of the road and confused about how to feel for tammy, sometimes you feel sympathy for her, sometimes you’re against her actions, and perhaps the point is people exist in a grey area. something in it was too earnest, and it didn’t feel like a ‘good people sometimes do bad things’ moral. it left you feeling wow she can sing, but not particularly on any side. the piece has potential and in 4 years it could be hilarious and well received. i wanted more camp, maybe make the lead men much more obviously gay, and cut the end to be a legally blonde ‘wrap it up bad guys left for bad, good guys left for good’. overall enjoyed and happy I saw, sad about the closing but I think a bad time for the production
The lead (Tammy Faye) was a power house with her vocals. The stage was simple; however, it had 3D blocks which distorted the pictures used and made it hard to focus. #ClosingNight
Katie Brayden and Christian Borle were great! I just didn't like the treatment and the story. First preview started late, paused for technical difficulty and ended about 1130 PM
Was the talent amazing? Yeah. Was seeing Elton John there on opening night sooo cool? OHHH YEAH! Was the book truly directionless? Mmmhmm yeah. Was there talent from all principal and ensemble cast members? OH YEAH! Honestly, how they interpreted the book made me slightly more intrigued in the story but overall it fell flat. Glad to have gone to opening night, wouldn’t pay to see it again. (Edited)
“I didn’t hate it,” said our group. The music is decent, but not memorable. The cast is solid, especially Brayben. Borle is underutilized, and Cerveris has a relatively thankless role that he executes with aplomb. The first act is a lot of exposition, and doesn’t really feel like it’s about Tammy. The second act redeems itself somewhat, but you still feel at arm’s length from the proceedings. You get the feeling like you’re watching a big flop in the making, even though the show isn’t half bad.
The show was fun, but that was all. The theme of this show and the message it sends is very confusing. It’s a show that doesn’t know what it is or what it is meant to say. If the show was completely satire, that’s one thing. If it was completely serious, that’s another thing. It felt like they didn’t know which path to choose, leaving a mix of comedy and seriousness that did not complement each other. I wasn’t sure what I was supposed to take away from this experience. The cast was giving their all though, and they were spectacular. (Edited)
Left during intermission.... painfull to watch.... save your money and see something else.
21–40 of 91 comments
Such a fun show!!! Highly recommend! Great cast !