Tammy Faye
The performances are great. My gripes with the book would lead me to suggest it not to everyone. Tammy Faye feels oddly like a posthumous PR piece, focusing on the message of spreading love to distract us from the very real manipulation and financial gain televangelists, including Tammy, conducted. It’s an interesting, albeit borderline unserious, revisiting of how religiosity spread across the USA through TVs. Colorful lighting and quirky caricatures attempt to point out the absurdities in televangelism and in Christian Nationalism, but it’s really preaching to the choir as American audiences have witnessed the role religion has taken as a cornerstone of political right-wing rhetoric during the last decade. Any attempt of holding up a mirror to America’s religiosity is also undermined by how indulgently redemptive the musical is towards Tammy Faye. Although she is the protagonist, she has very little agency, and as a result, has no crimes to be resolved from, as far as the book is concerned. Rather than an external examination of her church, it functions almost as PTL-sponsored content. Her acceptance of gay people feels highlighted as a tool to absolve her of all other criticism and harm created by the PTL. There’s a certain dissonance, and justification, where if you preach morality, or in Tammy Faye’s case, “love”, you can pull the wool over people’s eyes when you take from them in the name of the message. This, to me, is not dissimilar to other grifting donation campaigns - the message is just a means to part you with your money. The musical is too interested in distinguishing the “right” way to practice Christianity (Tammy) vs. the wrong (Falwell), which somewhat works within the book’s universe since it is primarily a Tammy Faye redemption story. But in failing to interrogate the story deeper, the real life harm of the Bakkers doesn’t feel fully addressed, casting shadow and doubt onto the book’s message of Tammy’s strong moral compass. Because the musical is so extremely sympathetic to Tammy Faye, I left the theater wondering if this was an intentional commentary about being careful of the perspectives you consume - that it’s actually a reminder to remain media literate and question the narratives behind all the sparkles and colors. But I think they were genuine in their adoration of Tammy Faye, which is fine, but not for me. That is the conundrum of the biopic, a genre I am usually wary of as it requires distilling a life into a compelling story arc that favors the protagonist. If they wanted to hone in on the message of pure “love” and acceptance in relationship to Christianity, it would be more compelling to craft an original story rather than attempt masking or revising real history. My review is obviously through the lens that I have serious qualms over biopics. “Empty Hands” is a great piece. Falwell’s (Cervais) satellite song was strangely a bit of a highlight - lyrically a tad off but removed the facade of religion from what was ultimately a power struggle. I found the staging fun, minus some of the use of projections, which project across uneven surfaces, leaving it look weird if you are too close. If it was campier and less sympathetic of Tammy Faye, it could potentially work as a warning about money, politics and religion. If I divorce it from real life, it’s a strangely fun, quirky, but musically forgettable production. (Edited)
I had a lot of fun at Tammy Faye. The energy of the cast and the individual performances of Michael Cerveris, Christian Borle, and Katie Brayben left me in admiration. Where the story might’ve failed, the trio certainly delivered. I also thought the songs were enjoyable and at times, found the lyrics to be even crafty. I can totally see why this wasn’t a knockout in the community but by all means, was still a fun night of musical theatre. (Edited)
Seen it in while it was in previews amazing show even better soundtrack😭💔
I really enjoyed it, in spite of the very mixed reviews. The lead was great and the whole cast was energetic I didn't think the music was Elton John's best work
It’s interesting and the leads were good, but the exposition needed is overlong. I wish more of the songs were memorable too. Sadly I don’t expect it to last. #lastpreview
Overall, this show needed more time in the oven. For all its buzz, it came onto the scene and announced its exit with very little notice. The most attention it received was its red carpet divorce from Andrew Rannells. The newly restored Palace Theatre is the highlight, though a visit can wait until the much-rumored Ragtime revival (fingers crossed). Cerveris makes an excellent villain character with a strong voice and looming stage presence. Christian Borle is an actor I often love on stage, but something doesn’t quite click for me here - I think mainly the lack of character development. The audience isn’t given enough time to meet *and like* the Bakkers before his (and her) actions take a turn. Their popularity is just not believable as presented. Katie Brayben has impressive vocals and a Reba/Wiig-ensian likability. I really wanted some songs to love from Sir Elton John, but that was not the outcome. Ultimately, it was better than I thought, based on word of mouth, but still lackluster. Unfortunate that it came to Broadway before it was ready. (Edited)
Rough first preview. Despite mocking the lord for 3 hours, they sure could’ve used his help!
Tried really hard to be something but fell short for a young person. Don’t get most of it. Good music & cast though (Edited)
Great music- hard to relate for younger folks
It needs work. It was exhausting. (Edited)
Tries to be too many things. Makes a complicated character one note and way too passive in her more egregious behavior. The music was great!
Bloated. Too much of everything—needs serious editing. Less is more.
Lead was fantastic but the show felt too long and uneven. Music wasn’t memorable.
The show was fun and the cast was beyond talented. Not my favorite thing I’ve seen but it was entertaining! Sad to see it close so soon.
Not as bad as people made it out to be
Not as bad as I expected.
there was not a single thing i liked about this show besides the fact that christian borle said excuse me to my mom to get to the stage door. it was the first preview so i understand not being perfect but wow. not ideal indeed. they did give tote bags which was nice and the wedding guy had a good number. we also had sunset blvd earlier that day so my life was changed. overall, it was one of my least favorite shows in a long long time. my 72nd show. 2/10. (Edited)
41–60 of 91 comments