Schmigadoon!
The concept of Schmigadoon! really excited me. It’s not every day there is a new Broadway musical with so many triple threats and brilliant comedians in the cast. It’s even rarer to find a new musical that aims to pay homage to the shows that came before it. All of that should have been an easy recipe for success. Sadly, none of it was not enough to save a musical that is ultimately dull and forgettable. Most of the comedy in Schmigadoon! revolves around the fact that golden age musicals are all wildly sexist and homophobic. Though the book by Cinco Paul is clever enough, the repetitive punch lines get old quickly. Similarly, the music and lyrics also by Paul feel tired. I enjoyed the satire, but once you know what song they are parodying, it’s easy to zone out as the music adds little to the story. The melodies and lyrics are overly simplistic for the sake of laughs, but it is not enough to sustain a two and half hour musical. Instead, Schmigadoon! feels like an underdeveloped SNL sketch that is far too long. The cast is spectacular across the board with McKenzie Kurtz, Ana Gasteyer and Isabelle McCalla as standouts. However, not even the brightest of Broadway stars can salvage such a big musical with so little to say. Most of the stellar principal cast members are underutilized, leaving audiences feeling unfulfilled, no matter how truly great the performers are. With that said, I wanted to give special shoutout the fantastic Townspeople of Schmigadoon! The ensemble brings a much needed enthusiasm to an otherwise lackluster series of scenes and songs. Their energy and talent make a strong case for why we need more big cast musicals on Broadway. Though Schmigadoon! has its faults, there is still a lot to enjoy. In addition to the incredible cast, both the scenic design by Scott Pask and costume design by Linda Cho are gorgeous. The choreography by director/choreographer Christopher Gattelli, is lively, delivering the nostalgia one would expect. I appreciate all the musical theatre history that is incorporated into this production. There is something to be said about paying tribute to the musicals of the past. I simply wish the biggest takeaway was more than just a reminder of how slow and problematic golden age musicals used to be (and often still are.) (Edited)
Excellent cast and sets, but I just don’t know if the plot really left me with anything. I like when a show has a strong message that is going to linger with me for a while. This was a lovely throwback to many older musicals, like Oklahoma and the music man and the sound of music.
Show is fine but doesn’t really add much over the Apple series, which was really well executed. The ensemble is better used here than in most shows I see, and I enjoyed that. Dancing was great. So were the costumes. Both Chase and Brightman were out when I went. The understudies did a good job and those roles are generic enough, I’m not sure how much we missed out. Ana Gasteyer was fantastic in this and I think she was robbed of a Tony.
Saw it at the Kennedy center -- cast was amazing but it was clearly a bit hard to take an entire season of a show and fit it into a few hours.
221–240 of 340 comments
Watched this after the Tony’s and Im glad I watched it but it wasnt for me. It was long and yet the story line was hurried as they tried to get seasons of a show into 2 acts…. Performances were great but overall I didnt get it.