Schmigadoon!
Absolutely hilarious and funny
Everything about this was incredible
with performances from a hilarious ensemble and musical theatre references and easter eggs galore, Schmigadoon is incontrovertible musical comedy escapism that is impossible not to have a good time!!!
worth the hype and then some.
As someone who loved the tv show this was a wonderful adaptation and absolutely hilarious
The best thing I’ve seen this season. Absolutely loved it. Theatrical perfection.
So good!
Fun!
One of the best shows this year! Very funny, well produced and incredible acting!!! Must to see if you are around!!!
Loved it!
Do not miss this show. Fantastic!
So good!
PHENOMENAL! A must see!!!!
mckenzie kurtz carried
When you’re in Schmigadoon, you’re never just a tourist—you’re part of the magic 🧺 In a cascade of bold colors and dazzling big numbers, Schmigadoon! reminds us why Broadway is a place of pure spectacle. A glittering homage to the golden era, filled with charm and exuberance. Yet, there’s a party spirit that belongs to a different time, one that doesn’t always translate to today’s stage. As a fan of the series, I still feel the TV version captured that shock best. Those characters stepping from parody into a real-world stage was a jolt. A huge shoutout to my ex-roomie, @technicolorstella , who I used to watch every episode with as it aired. This was a perfect birthday week celebration with her, bringing that magic full circle! (Edited)
Saw this with Ian-Michael. Overall this show was very fun, but I also felt bored at times. Direction from Christopher Gattelli, was really creativelly well done. I know this adapted from the show, which I've never seen, and thus they had to regigger the the story a little, but the pacing just felt off at points like I was just bored and not interested in the story, maybe the steaks didn't feel high enough, I'm not sure but everyone else is enjoying it's entirety so maybe I'm in the minority. Music and Lyrics by Cinco Paul, again since I've never seen the show, I'm not sure which were added for the stage production but the songs were cute and fun, nothing super memorable in my opinion except bread pudding song. Coreography by the director is crazy but honestly was some great dancing, there were moments when it was individuals dancing that it felt a little awkard but the big group numbers were so intricate and fun. Sound Design by Walter Trarbach, it worked well, nothing good or bad to call out. Lighting Design by Donald Holder, in tbe beginning were some cool moments when transitioning from their every day lives and Schmigadoon but other than that it was pretty flat throughout. Costume Design by Linda Cho, they were actually so cute and fun, and I imagine relatively close to the TV series, but worked really well on stage and weren't boring. Scenic Design by Scott Pask, wow, the beginning was so fun with the vending machine and the bed, then Schmigadoon, the houses were so cute and bright and well constructed, really fit the vibe of the show. The cast: overall everyone did a great job. Alex Brightman (Josh Skinner), is a great actor but I WANTED SINGING! Not sure what the show holds but I just wanted the character to be singing more. Sara Chase (Melissa Gimble), I think she is a lovely actress and can really belt but overall she felt flat to me throughout, just one note. Ana Gasteyer (Mildred Layton) she was exactly who she was supposed to be, had the singing and the acting chops. Isabelle McCalla (Emma Tate) some of the best singing and acting in the show , honestly wanted more of her. McKenzie Kurtz (Betsy), HILARIOUS, she was perfect for this role, super kooky crazy.
I really wanted to love Schmigadoon!. I grew up on the classic musiclas of Oklahoma, Brigadoon, South Pacific, The Sound of Music and twirling an imaginary skirt in front of the TV while the VHS played. I loved the TV show, hunted down every Easter egg, and walked into this fully ready to for all the musical theater nerd glorty. And to be fair, there’s a lot here to love. The full-ensemble choreography (yes, the skirts swish gloriously). The musical jokes land with ease (yes, the baroness is a Nazi). And Ana Gasteyer is absolute perfection in comedic timing, vocals, villain energy. Her performance is Tony-worthy without question. Where I got stuck: I really missed the quirky, slightly exasperated charm Keegan-Michael Key brought to the tv show. I get that Alex Brightman isn’t there to do an impression, but his Josh leans so hard into anger that the love story never quite takes hold. I wanted to root for him; instead, I kept searching for anything endearing. That disconnect is especially noticeable opposite Sara Chase, who carries the show with her quirks, vocals, and charm, but can’t quite manufacture chemistry on her own.
Expected to like this more than I did. Fun dive into musical history and lots of laughs but many jokes could’ve landed better, and too much sameness and repetition in the sets. Anna Gasteyer’s pipes were superb, as were cheeky costumes and choreography. Tons of talent on display but saddled with a meh book. Still appreciated the chance to see this last minute via Theatr app!
This was my second watch. I enjoyed it the first time — this time, slightly less so, but mainly because I didn’t necessarily need to see it again. Surprisingly, while I loved the first act the first time around, this time I found it kind of relentless and annoying (but it’s kind of supposed to be!). I didn’t love the second act upon first viewing, but really enjoyed it this time and actually got choked up at the end. This is a really nice musical to have on Broadway, but it’s nothing I needed to see twice.
201–220 of 340 comments
Malick pancholcy!!!