Schmigadoon!
I havent seen the TV show, so as an avid musical fan, this was a blast. Standout performances from Isabella McCalla, Sara Chase, and OBVIOUSLY Ana Gasteyer. Was also impressed by the dance numbers and playful blocking. This particular seat (not pictured- center mezz) was very uncomfortable for leg room as Im 5’9”, and the person in front of me was tall with very spiky hair, frequently leaning forward and blocking center stage. Not their fault, just an unlucky person to sit behind. I was able to move to the front row of the second mezz level which was SO much better. May have been a fluke but getting into the theater was a mess- for a 2pm show there was a line so long it almost spanned the block at 1:48. Seemed they opened the house very late. Glad I saw it, definitely makes me want to watch the show!
What makes this production sing, literally and figuratively, is how completely it commits to the spectacle. The set design is intricate and gorgeous, with massive scenic elements gliding in and out from every direction with a speed and smoothness that is genuinely awe-inspiring. Transitions that could easily pull an audience out of the story instead become part of the show itself—seamless, precise, and clearly the result of serious design and engineering. Coming off Beaches the night prior, where two sand dunes and a projection screen were expected to do all the heavy lifting, this felt like a palate cleanser of the highest order. The casting matches the ambition of the production. Every single person on that stage is remarkably talented. I recognized a handful—Ana Gasteyer, who continues to be incapable of a wrong note and is absolutely hilarious as the town’s stern moral authority, and Ann Harada, a wonderful holdover from the original series—but familiarity is not a requirement. The harmonies, the synchronized choreography, the sheer precision of it all—and the pure joy radiating from that stage—does something rare: it makes you feel genuinely lucky to be in the room. Oh, and there was an entr’acte—two shows in one week with an entr’acte. Unlike Beaches, this one felt entirely earned.
front rowing with tay!!!! life is worth living!!! the best way to see this show is feeling the schmoschestra vibrations on feet!! doc nathan and reverend jess
i freaking love this show. my cheeks hurt from laughing (Edited)
this show is SOOOO broadway. like so insanely fun and actually hilarious. i didn’t know much about it beforehand and i was shocked at how funny it was. the set is beautiful and the actors are soooo talented as well as the ensemble. i will say i was a little eh with the music - there wasn’t any song that really stood out to me or anything that made me wanna go back and listen again. we got these for broadway 2 for 1 week and the seats were great! you saw the whole stage the entire time. 8/10 - possibly would see again but very happy i saw it (Edited)
Amazing seats and an even better show! This whole cast and crew is phenomenal! I see why it won the Tony for best musical! It was so funny especially McKenzie Kurtz as Betsy! I couldn’t stop laughing! All of the songs were amazing and I couldn’t stop singing and dancing in my seat! I DEFINITELY recommend it!
Such a fun show! The music was catchy, the sets were gorgeous, and the humor was refreshing. Performances from the entire cast were stellar. I sat front row and did t miss a thing, it was so nice to see facial expressions that close.
my belly hurts from laughing so hard everyone is sooooo freaking talented. damn i really want some corn puddin
I went into this blind, only knowing it was based on a TV show and was pleasantly surprised. The costumes and set design were fun and well executed. A very light, feel good show. Seats were great despite being towards the back. The sound was only slightly dimmed during one part of the show, for a split second. Overall the sound quality was crisp!
Lots of fun with a great dance ensemble. I never watched the TV show and had a delightful blast at this. I really don’t think I have laughed this hard in a while. Clayton, Gasteyer, Kurtz and McCalla were the standouts for me but everyone is really excellent and appear to be having a ball which is half the fun. This is such a great parody/satire which I need in large doses now so I will definitely be revisiting this one. (Edited)
loved it! i sat in the very back of the orchestra and still had a great view and a great time. i’m not sure if this was normal or not, but it was FREEZING inside, so bring a jacket or two. (Edited)
had the most amazing time at the nederlander tonight!! had the honor of meeting cinco during intermission 💙
Seat view center-center— right in there with the fun, energy, color, and EXCELLENT DANCE. A very silly yet loving and knowing spoof. Great time with the audience age 11 and up. (Edited)
I won the lottery and didn’t go in with high hopes because I thought I would not like that it was based on a tv show I haven’t seen. Well I was totally wrong . I loved the big numbers, I thought the school marm and the blonde temptress were breakout stars, and I laughed and was entertained. Would go back and see it again.
Schmigadoon is clever, silly, and completely joyful — a loving parody of classic mid-century musicals mixed with modern dialogue and humor. I’m a fan of the series already, but I went with friends who had never seen it, and we all had an equally great time. Mid mezz seating, very good for this show!
Got back row seats for a good deal. I was shocked at how great the sightline was! Mega talented cast.
my comfort tv show came to life! the musical was everything i dreamed of and more. shout out to kaleigh cronin who absolutely blew the roof off in one of the songs and mckenzie betsy❤️ (Edited)
1–20 of 340 comments
baby’s first front row at the nederlander!!! amazing fun night seeing my favorite cast. could feel the vibration of the stage when they tap danced. i get goosebumps just from thinking about it. ana gasteyer is to me what jesus is to christians.