Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Absolutely STELLAR!!! So much fun, a really beautiful story told but phenomenal performers. 10/10 would se again.
hilarious and cute
“Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is a masterclass in heart. Sam Tutty delivers a performance that is effortlessly charming, deeply vulnerable, and quietly devastating in the best way—every moment feels honest and earned. Opposite him, Christiani Pitts is magnetic: warm, sharp, emotionally grounded, and impossible to look away from. Together, their chemistry turns a simple premise into something profoundly human. This show doesn’t just entertain—it stays with you.”
Fun hilarious great story and fantastic music
this musical was so well done. so so good
Great show - funny and touching, hummable music. Highly recommend!
A love letter to NY!
OBC I LOVE THEM
An absolute delight!
Such a cute show!
Loved it!
obsessed
Fun, Funny, and a great time!
Very fun.
a great take on surprise connections...
Loved it from beginning to end! Run and see this utterly charming show before it closes on 11/29.
very entertaining evening
Delightful! This was so charming, witty, and very heartfelt. I recommend it to everyone
Absolutely charming. Original, fun, wonderful performances.
321–340 of 659 comments
Best show on Broadway not only is it hilarious but the message is amazing