The Last Five Years
I love the show, it was my first time seeing it as a live production. I didn’t feel vocally it lived up to the original cast (Scott and Butz) nor the movie (which I know is studio). It was a seamless show and always brilliant to see a 2 person performance that never feels long. I was hoping the emotion was conveyed and sadly, it didn’t move me.
lottery win! adrienne warren was really good! i had a little trouble understanding nick jonas at some part but he wasnt bad! i didnt watch the movie but i was able to follow along. i liked how the orchestra was on stage with them. just felt like it was missing something that wouldve made it great.
I really wanted to like this production but there were a few too many misses to give this my ‘thumbs up’. While Adrienne Warren and Nick Jonas are phenomenal singers (Adrienne is OMG level of insane talent, I look forward to seeing her work in a different production in the future!!) I don’t think this score suited either of their vocal styles. The few times they were performing together on stage they were pretty magical and I loved how they showcased the orchestra through the staging and set design. It’s a tough competition out there, lots of strong productions taking Broadway by storm, and unfortunately, this one just didn't do it for me.
I felt like this production was really crutching hard on the stunt casting, and as a result was severely lacking in almost every other category, most notably the set, adaptation to stage, and lack of extras / ensemble. I was first exposed to the Last Five Years through the movie and I think this show would’ve been hard to follow if you don’t know the storyline, making me think it is not as accessible for people to go in blind (which is something I think all top tier Broadway productions should be able to do). Since I was already familiar with the story, I enjoyed it and the phenomenal actors, but was disappointed about the rest.
I have to say I was surprised by this production, while Adrienne is superb as always, Nick was better than I had expected. The one thing I think this lacked heavily was stage production, they did almost nothing to it. No furniture, special backings or decorations, there’s only at times a desk, a bed and a giant screen with a backing of clouds. (Edited)
Blown away by Stacey Derosier’s lighting design on this one! Everyone and everything looked SO GOOD all of the time, and the visual vocabulary for the parallel journeys onstage is so clear and thoughtful. Some mix of Nick Jonas’ performance as Jamie and the way the character is written made it hard for me to invest in him as romantically viable, even at the beginning- fuckboy in a nice shirt vibes; while the ending still hurt, I felt the heartbreak mainly just for Cathy, rather than for Jamie or the relationship. Adrienne Warren’s performance was incredible, but the main thing I was thinking throughout was “girl, get up!”.
Adrienne Warren is wonderful! Nick Jonas is good, but pales in comparison. The audio was weak in the beginning and I couldn’t make out some of the songs, but it got better. The story was unique with the differing timelines but it got confusing when the characters were involved in the others timeline.
Adrienne is truly a star and it was a treat getting the chance to see her perform live! Nick was great to see based off the fact of nostalgia and him being a childhood crush, but his performance wasn’t that strong. During some of his songs he sounded great and during others his voice gave out! It’s a treat either way!!
Adrienne Warren was good, Nick Jonas was a bit better than expected, but expectations were low. Sets were cheap and somewhat strange at times. Characters interacted more than they should have.
Sorry - this wasn’t it. I love Nick Jonas, I love this musical, and I love Broadway, but I don’t like all of those things together. I don’t think this would have made sense I didn’t already know the show. Still, lovely to see a favorite of mine live.
Adrienne Warren!!!!! Came to see her and she was amazing in this role!!!!! Nick Jonas was meh. Not impressed with the story line as it was very difficult to follow and understand. But holy shit can she sing!!!!
this show was interesting i just wish there was more dialogue. HOWEVER from the tippy top of the hudson theatre we had a great view
Adrienne was spectacular!! Nick was alright, definitely felt like he was either holding himself back or like he was given a note to sing it more in his current country-style than the belty tones of his youth, to a detriment.
i want to start with: the production itself is honestly a miss for me. there was a PERFECT production of this show over covid, then entire thing was streamed live in a new york apartment and it was literal perfection, i still think about it to this day. (understudy nasia thomas was also cathy in this production and i would go back solely to see her whenever she makes her debut) it needed more of a set, the bare bones felt so sterile and disconnected. i can see how it would be difficult to follow if you went in blind (even with the playbill timeline insert) the orchestrations were good, and i adore the songs. book could’ve been fleshed out just a tiny bit more, but i think they were avoiding having jamie and cathy interact to not confuse the audience. the lighting was solid, and attempted to help you depict who was where in the timeline, but again, give me MORE. onto the cast. adrienne is a powerhouse. it makes nick look worse than he is. he’s fine. (everyone let’s remember cameron dallas in mean girls - he’s not as bad as that!!! he can hold a tune!) however. he’s just singing like he always does. his timing was off for what emotions to punch and when. his acting wasn’t bad, but is it hard for a straight man to act like an ass? idk. i think if he had just done a month of musical theatre vocal lessons, he would’ve been great. but as it stands, he doesn’t have the breath control or the stamina to sing these songs. nor is he able to harmonize with his costar. i’m not as mad as i feared i would be. i am eagerly awaiting for noah and nasia to announce a date they are both on so i can revisit.
I luckily saw the understudy performance as I would never spend money to see Nick Jonas do anything… this show was very good with the understudies - the production worked at points but why are we making theatre actors climb set pieces like that? Poor design
I’ve been a huge fan of Jason Robert Brown musicals since high school…Adrienne Warren as Cathy didn’t disappoint…there were a few parts that, as a theater kid, I was missing from Nick Jonas’s performance, but overall he was a great Jamie!
After waiting more than two decades to hear this glorious score on Broadway, it is such a shame audiences won’t get to experience it performed to its highest potential. This production is such a clear example of how important casting truly is to the success of a show. At least Adrienne gets to shine.
Though Jonas’ performance has been much maligned, he delivers a solid performance here as Jamie. Adrienne Warren soared vocally and brought relay nuances to Cathy - who is often portrayed as neurotic and overbearing. Warren brings a groundedness to the role that is refreshing and worth the price of (my TDF) admission. Where the production goes a bit sideways is in the direction - the choices didn’t serve the overall story. I would have preferred they share less time on stage together so that the next 10 minutes really packed a punch! The set was disjointed - in some ways conceptual and in others leaning into realism - which was just confusing. Overall, would recommend to fans of the musical / JRB and folks dying to see these stars. But to casual viewers, it’s a pass.
81–100 of 187 comments
It was fine — nothing surreal, nothing extraordinary. I would say go see for the experience, the actors have great voices, and the music is good. Honestly, I was expecting something more visceral — to connect with the story and the characters, but it was not clicking it for me. I was also missing some dialogue between songs to at least give me a guidance in their timeline, especially in the middle of the show when their story in years combine. Overall, is a ok show, don’t expect much (the hype is not worth it). (Edited)