The Last Five Years
Great play with very talented actors! Bravo!
SO GOOD
Loved it!
The cast is just so talented!
Enjoyed
𝐈'𝐦 𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐥𝐥 𝐡𝐮𝐫𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐟𝐫𝐨𝐦 𝐡𝐨𝐰 𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐰𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐦𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐯𝐚𝐥 𝐰𝐚𝐬... For those unfamiliar (no spoilers here), The Last Five Years features a unique storytelling structure: the man’s story is told chronologically, while the woman’s is told in reverse. But if you go into this revival blind, the production doesn’t do a great job of making that concept clear—and that, to me, was its BIGGEST flaw. I didn’t quite understand the creative direction, and some set and production elements felt flat. I was hoping for a more inventive or stylized approach to elevate the storytelling but this production just lacks them. I had seen the film adaptation before and wasn’t a huge fan, although a few songs really stuck with me. So going into this show, I kept my expectations low and just hoped the two leads would deliver vocally—and they absolutely did. Nick Jonas proved to be a phenomenal singer, and Adrienne Warren was equally amazing. I have zero complaints about their vocals. But when it came to chemistry, there was almost none. Despite the emotional weight of the story, I never truly felt a strong connection between their characters. It felt more like two separate solo concerts than a cohesive love story, which made it hard for me to become emotionally invested in their journey. The Last Five Years doesn’t have the most groundbreaking plot, so this revival really needed to bring something fresh—whether through dynamic staging or electric onstage chemistry. Unfortunately, it delivered neither. Even with their incredible voices, I still couldn’t bring myself to like the production.
Standby night was epic!!! So much love in the theatre for Nasia and Noah🥹 I want to give it a 5/5 because I’m such a fan of the score, but will have to give it a 3/5 because the direction was a little wonky :/ The two actors aren’t supposed to be on stage together all the time and are only supposed to meet in the middle of the show, but they were constantly on stage with each other throughout the piece. If I didn’t know the show already, I’d be much more confused because the couple is telling their respective stories in different timelines. So to have them be on stage together at the same time makes you wonder what timeline are we in during each song. Otherwise, I had a blast, and I finally saw one of my favorite shows live🥹 the audience was so palpable and electric, and I felt so lucky to be there🫶🏻🫶🏻
The word I’ve settled on for this production is noncommittal. Which, considering the story may make sense but unfortunately leaves you very unsatisfied. The production has absolutely no idea what it is. Is the set maximalist with full sets? Or minimalist with models and suggestions of sets? Is the lighting maximalist and utilize the giant wall of lights upstage? Or minimalist and just rely on specific spots? Should the actors be present in each other’s scenes? Or not? And if they are why are they wearing the costume for their next scene not the one they are in? There really seems to be little to no real direction. And it is a shame, cause not even Adrienne Warren can save it. Because is Cathy supposed to be a mid performer? If so they cast the wrong person. But it’s obvious that so much more work was put into making Nick Jonas comfortable than working with Adrienne, especially with the sound levels. Speaking of Nick, I was afraid he would be in his pop falsetto the entire time, but that wasn’t the case. Sadly, they keep him in a very boring small range of notes, keeping him out of his falsetto, but also trying to adjust to the fact that he doesn’t have much of a lower register which is how most of the lines end. The biggest takeaway for me was that not a single person left crying that I saw, which for this show is insane.
Adrienne is SPECTACULAR!! Every moment she is on stage my eyes, mind, heart and soul were completely in the show. Nick is good, a competent performer for the most part (I saw it in previews had he had to stop twice.) Though honestly I had a hard time not having mixed feelings about a Christian and right-wing leaning/Tr*mp supporting man singing about why he doesn’t want Jewish women. Given the historical moment we are in it was hard to ignore the implications of him in the role, playing a Jewish man, and intellectually it took me out of what should’ve been a very emotional show.
Adrienne, Adrienne, ADRIENNE was all I was talking about when I came out the show. She does a lot of heavy lifting here I feel. Nick Jonas has potential (I thought the vocals in “Nobody Needs to Know” were very promising), but I ultimately feel like he’s just not right for this role (I made a joke with my partner saying he must’ve been the last leading man available on the “Broadway stunt cast list”). But I honestly feel like a LOT of what’s lacking with this production comes from direction (or rather lack of). Jamie comes off as manipulative, shitty, and an incel which is a very one note take on the character (perhaps a choice made based on what Jonas was capable of). I think the amount of interaction they had made the story hard to follow- and I LOVE this show so if I got confused then I know others who do not know the show definitely were lost.
i’d say 6/10, i did enjoy it, i had fun, 90min w no intermission. main girly slayed the house down!!!! nick was fine, needs to enunciate a bit more and i wish he’d hit high notes instead of falsetto’ing. also wish there was more nuance to the plot other than that men suck, but. we can’t all be merrily! oh but the lighting production was 10/10 btw never noticed lighting before but amazing (Edited)
First off, Jason Robert Brown has put so many sincere and painful sentiments within his incredible music and seeing this show continues to remind me of how truly incredible the writing of this piece is (including the new orchestrations!) However, I felt the distance of a Broadway theater in a show that is so intimate and I lacked the ability to connect with either of the characters throughout the piece even though I’ve had no trouble when seeing the show in the past. I will say that Cathy being played by a woman of color really enlightened me on so many different intricacies within the piece and I’d love to keep seeing it done that way! But I personally just left the theater feeling roughly the same as to when I went in and that’s never my goal when attending a show.
I love the Hudson Theatre personally so I never have any complaints on where I sit… but this production was fine. I still am trying to wrap my head around Nick Jonas in this production. The first half of the show I literally could not understand him. It was a mumbling experience especially when you’re up against MOTHER. Oh my gosh she was a breath of a fresh air to this production. She is the reason I enjoyed it. Adrienne Warren is truly perfection.
I don’t know what people are saying about Nick. He was great. I wasn’t a fan before as I never liked his pop hits solo and with his brothers but this was his standout performance to me. Adrienne was very good as well as I’ve seen her a few times in the Tina Turner musical. There are some boring parts of the show but it was the songwriters fault on those but many songs were good.
Honestly I did enjoy this way more than expected!! I’d heard meh things and I do think that Nick Jonas was overshadowed by his female co-star, but wow she was incredible. The staging/general plot was confusing since I had no background knowledge, so took me 10-15 to even figure out what was going on, and I could’ve used more dialogue or together moments to really feel emotionally connected to the story. Honestly this could’ve been 30 mins longer and wrapped up a bit different imo! (Edited)
Adrienne Warren was a star, but Nick's voice seemed to struggle at times. Both had great acting performances though! Glad to have watched a production of one of my favorite musicals, but thought some of the staging choices were confusing, especially if someone was coming new to the show.
61–80 of 187 comments
The show was amazing!!! Performances were off the charts!