The Great Gatsby
It’s basically the exact same story with the 2013 movie by Leonardo DiCaprio - they didn’t really change anything. If at some point DiCaprio can come to Broadway (no offense to Jeremy Jordan), I wanna watch it again! The stage looks so beautiful, but the seats are very tight and uncomfortable. If you are big or have back issues, please make sure to get an aisle seat! (Edited)
It wasn’t very good, Reeve didn’t sound good. The 2nd act was great but felt rushed. The set design was beautiful, but overall just kinda’ve boring which sucks because I’ve seen so many shows. And I really love broadway so I really wanted to love this show. It just didn’t end up that way.
I wanted to like it, but it seemed like a lot of sparkle with little substance. Songs were unremarkable; I doubt I’ll remember them next week. I thought Gatsby was supposed to be charismatic, smooth - the actor played him as largely awkward and goofy. I wasn’t invested in any of the characters or their relationships. Lovely to see Terrence Mann on Broadway again, wish he had more to do. My overall feeling was, “Meh.”
3rd time, including Paper Mill, to see Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada before they depart… unfortunately the book, lyrics, and storytelling are still some of the worst material I’ve seen on Broadway. Then principal voices are fantastic, there are some standout dancers (Raymond Barnard), but there’s very little to compliment besides that. (Edited)
I cannot express how big a fan I am of Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada, among other great performers in this show, but…. this show is bad. Even the moments most of the audience came for - the big emotional ballads and duets and belting of the two leads - seemed a strange fit musically and emotionally in this show. Most the other music and lyrics were unexciting and the book/story pacing didn’t work for me. I’m rooting for it to revise and improve and survive but am not optimistic unfortunately.
I’m sorry but this was so corny. I love the book and this seemed to poke fun at some of the symbolism from the book in trying to spell it out for people who don’t know the story.
I really felt like there were too many long ballads in this show. It felt a little too much like the production hired Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada and decided they needed at least 3 ballads each just because. (Edited)
Horrible songs - lyrics and melody so off. Not sure how it is possible but nothing made sense. Set is pretty and their voices are good but really bad songs.
Eva, reeve, and Corbin were wonderful, but not a strong production (Edited)
Jeremy Jordan was great, costumes were great- but I feel like this budget should've focused on making the story more developed. Felt like more of a tourist trap than The Great Gatsby.
As a big fan of the book, this version is way too light and bright. So much so that the deaths felt shocking and jarring because the tone is too light for the darkness of this show. The actual message is washed out, and some of the plot changes seem incredibly unnecessary.
This musical felt like what you would get if AI were to write a musical after being fed The Great Gatsby. It seemed to miss the entire point of the book, which is a scathing indictment of materialism and the emptiness of consumerism that haunts everyone, but mostly harms the “have-nots”. There was no commentary on the ever-present queerness in the novel, and the love story was not a good enough excuse for me to watch it. It was at times entertaining, but ultimately empty, which is exactly the type of mindless entertainment Fitzgerald was criticizing. (Edited)
I think they missed the point. Writing and choreography didn’t seem to know what story they were telling. Singing is great. Storytelling and them kicked in towards the end but too little too late.
It was pretty to look at but the direction, score, and book were a huge disappointment
Went for Eva and she ate as usual, but the writing didn’t hook me, not my thing (Edited)
Felt like the cast was trying too hard. Singing was so off key. However, the props and costume design was impressive.
801–820 of 856 comments
I struggled to stay awake. Many of the lead actors were incredible, I loved Eva and the actors who played Jordan and Nick. Jeremy Jordan honestly bored me. I felt like he was relying too much on pretty singing and not enough on acting. Didn’t like the book (and by book I mean the musical’s book) either.