The Great Gatsby
★★★½ Tainted with original sin because this is the reason Gatsby: An American Myth isn't on Broadway. Still pretty fun, though. (Edited)
Loved Jeremy and the rest of the cast. Just wasn’t my type of play. The music was great as well.
The show is good but I was expecting more of the musics! The actors were amazing and I love it all!
It was nice! Acting was overall okay - Gatsby’s acting while singing paid for the price of admission
Beautiful stage production and very talented cast! I just felt like the songs weren’t memorable
It was very pretty to watch. Nothing spectacular but I had a nice time.
Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada were phenomenal, but this show completely misses the point of the novel and misinterprets nearly all of its themes and symbols, particularly the green light. Thankfully, if you separate it from its source material and simply appreciate it for what it is, many (but not all) of the show’s issues are forgivable.
fun to see jeremy and eva. don’t remember it tho.
Amazing!! Loved it so so much! Saw the matinee, felt a little low energy at some points, but loved it nonetheless!
I think they missed the point. Writing and choreography didn’t seem to know what story they were telling. Singing is great. Storytelling and theme kicked in towards the end but too little too late.
Great sets and costumes. Some fun production numbers and dancing. Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada have fabulous voices and the other leads were strong. Score: meh. Book: very meh, especially the ending.
It was pretty but there was no new take on the story. It was as expected. No surprises, no changes however it was pretty and the acting was good
Very nice sets and good costumes! Not one of my favorites but still a fun show.
Not my favourite show ever but still everything you would expect from a big glitzy broadway show.
first time i saw this show it was incredible. this cast not so much but still a great show
Very fun musical but strays from the original source material. I believe everyone should see it but I was kinda disappointed. Very talented cast and crew, no doubt. I just was iffy about some of the songs and changes from the book
Great performances and very entertaining—not my favorite adaptation of this classic story.
Eva & Ryan McCartan Understudy - Nick (Alex Prakken) & Jordan (Dariana Mullen) (Eva was replaced with understudy in 2nd Act) (Edited)
Jeremy’s final performance
701–720 of 856 comments
In true broadway theater fashion, the singing,visuals, dancing was amazing. But unfortunately for me it was too slow of a story for my liking. It was good but definitely not amazing when it came to that aspect.