The Great Gatsby
2nd time watching and dare i say even better this time
such a spectacle! ryan was a cutie and noah ATE
Such powerful voices/songs and great all around dancing/numbers. Really enjoyed it!
Insanely glad to have seen it with Eva and Ryan!! Vocals top tier, energy top tier
eva noblezada x ryan mccartan. vocals were crazy good i enjoyed very much
A great cast overall, but Jeremy Jordan was beyond exceptional! Only wish we could’ve had Eva there, but just missing her return to Gatsby next month.
Now this was spectacular. I saw it with Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada and it was incredible. I love love love this show.
Love Jeremy Jordan from his Smash days and he did not fail me as Jay Gatsby
I loved all the colors and dancing sequences.
I may be biased since the Great Gatsby was my first show while working at Paper Mill Playhouse, but I have a soft spot for this show. First, Jeremy and Eva are absolute powerhouses. Hearing them sing “My Green Light” together is enough to go see this. In addition, the sets by Paul Tate DePoo III are really revolutionary in their mix of physical elements and screens. Go see this if you want a big, glitzy show!
Amazing! I had a wonderful experience and show 🙂 The talent! I know most people come for the bigger names of Jeremy and Eva, but I was blown away by Noah Ricketts and Samantha Paul from beginning to end 🤩🤩 and I believe the actress for Myrtle (through Sept) is Chilina Kennedy? Her performances were jaw-dropping!
It was very good! Set design and costumes were amazing! Jeremy, Eva and the whole cast of The Great Gatsby was amazing!!!
I loved the show! This was the second time I saw it and it was so fun
Sarah Hyland crushed it - had understudies for Gatsby and Nick but it was still an incredible time
so good!!! ryan mccartan’s vocals are top tier
One of Jeremy and Eva’s last performances and truly they are going to be SO missed
I met Jeremy Jordan!! Best day of my life!!!
AMAZING show!! jeremy jordan and eva noblezada absolutely killed it along with the other 2 leads. classic story beautifully adapted to the stage. the songs were fantastic, and oh my lord jeremy jordan
181–200 of 856 comments
Second time seeing it. Ryan McCartan and Sarah Hyland were incredible.