Public Charge
Zabryna shines as Julissa, the main character in Public Charge. Julissa goes into public service because she wants to serve the people that laws effect, as her director says, we serve the flag not the president. The whole ensemble really does a great job of really embodying the characters they portray, you can tell that telling this story really matters to them all them just to play a part in a production. Watching Julissa struggle with putting her beliefs and values aside to follow the rules of her posting felt like a storyline that anyone across any industry could identify with. This felt like a well fleshed out script and storyline because it was written by a former diplomat. I constantly found myself wondering what parts of the story were 100% true and had happened vs what was just a story to tell for the stage. I think the ending of the play was so well done. Julissa reminds us that we can still hope. It’s still there.
Cool semi-modern history story with actors playing more than one role. Well designed stage, intimate theater, and a breezy hour and 45 min.
I feared this show might be a boring political lesson, but it actually sparked my interest in diplomacy and international affairs. The rhythm of the action catches your attention. The entire cast is great, and the direction seamlessly handles shifts in time and place. The stage design and audiovisuals serve the flow of the production—a play that mirrors how chaotic politics can be.
I was astounded at this play’s ability to communicate the complexity and tension of foreign affairs to a commoner like me. On that, it reminded me that I love the ability theatre has to illuminate human interaction in all its messiness. That crux of theatre shines in a piece like this which really reminds you that instances of large global discussions/negotiations are just humans stuck in complex webs from the past trying to decide what’s best for each other in the present. And after all of the governmental headache and progress you experience over the course of the piece, this play truly reverberates and almost stings in a shocking way at its end. The show claims there is so much hope in tomorrow (our today, as this show completes its timeline in roughly 2014) while a minor melody plays in the final underscored moments supporting the actors smile. I left with sort of pit in my stomach as I believe the goal of the show is to provide the knowledge that positive humanitarian change is possible, but it sadly feels a bit overshadowed by the failures of the current government. There were also slight moments that took me out of the piece or confused me (the nightmare) but, for me, it still doesn’t take away from the absolutely incredible marathon performances from its leading lady (who remains on stage the entire time) and the supporting cast who are constantly shifting into wildly varying, clearly distinct, and well executed characters every other scene. (Edited)
“Public Charge” by Julissa Reynoso and Michael J. Chepiga plays at the Public Theater until April 12th. The show follows an immigrant as she becomes an American diplomat who specializes in foreign policy—specifically regarding immigration. The show was incredibly informative as one of the playwrights was involved in American Affairs for Hillary Clinton when she was the Secretary of State. To keep the audience onboard with the timeline, projections are used to indicate the year and location of the scene. Although the content was interesting, I was never able to get truly immersed into the story as the staging was repetitive and had uninteresting stage pictures. It was difficult to separate comparison of “Public Charge” to Lincoln Center’s “Kyoto” from the fall, which was similar in topic and immersive staged. Overall, the show has passion for its topic that the ensemble seems to resonate with. I would recommend “Public Charge” to those interested in the inner-workings of American diplomacy and immigration.
Basically a staged lecture with simple stilted obvious dialogue. Lots of exposition. Probably best geared for a high school class learning about politics. At least it doesn’t fall to deeply into its own POV. Except for the coda which is a lost opportunity to show futility, but hints at an audience pleasing smirk.
‘Public Charge’ is Julissa Reynoso’s story as a former US Ambassador, chronicling her time under the Obama administration. The play centers around her work on the United States relationship with Cuba. With historical dramas, there needs to be a strong personally point of view and motivation that I did not find enough of in this piece. At its best, it’s a close portrait of the push-pull of trying to affect change in a rigid system. But Reynoso’s POV feels too buried for the sake of streamlining historical events, and it risks oversimplification. I think it could be an introduction to foreign affairs, a jumping off point for younger students interested in Cuba-American relations.
Going into this play, I didn’t know much about the real world events of this show and the complex relationship between the US and Cuba, but I walked out of it having learned much more than I anticipated! I think this would be a great educational piece for schools but personally, I like my theatre a little more wacky and whimsical. I’ll admit that is sometimes harder to achieve when the subject matter is rooted in reality, but not impossible by any means! More risks could have been taken. From my understanding, all the characters were real political figures and the playwright, Julissa Reynoso, was writing a bio-play starring herself and her experiences. I appreciated that this achieved diplomat wanted to share her story and commend her on doing so in play format; however at times the play felt a little clunky. I wonder if her newness to the playwriting space was a factor as to why I felt this way. I would recommend this show to those eager to learn more about foreign policy and the state department in the 2010s. You will definitely come out of this show having learned something, although the ending is a (spoiler alert!!!) bit of a punch in the gut as the characters look towards a promising post-Obama future free of narcissistic dictator-types. A little on the nose … (Edited)
I feel like the show had so much potential it just felt chaotic and underdeveloped. I felt like it only focused on what she didn’t accomplish and was like what’s the point. Sad I was expecting a lot more!
The play touches on political themes and the relationship between the United States and Cuba, but despite the large effort on elaborating the conversation and events, it still looks fragile and thin-plotted to me. I found myself thinking a lot that the production could benefit from more music - as narrative does not feel substantial enough to stand on its own. Scene transitions also lack strength and twist, which makes the emotional continuity difficult to sustain. There are, however, occasional moments of unexpected humour. Some lines even vaguely allude to the current president, which adds a layer of ironic amusement and briefly energises the audience. Overall, the production presents good ideas but struggles to develop them into a cohesive and emotionally compelling theatrical experience.
This show was not needed and not good. The script is so boring and poorly written, it would be better to wait for some streamer to do a cheap documentary miniseries. The set makes no sense and seems designed to remove as much direct engagement between characters as possible. The direction makes me long for the artistic complexity of a fifth grade talent show.
“Public Charge” chronicles the life of Julissa Reynoso, a foreign affairs worker under the Obama administration, but feels better suited to a chapter in a textbook. With dialogue that feels like it is attempting to emulate Sorkin (but falling flat) and discordant time jumps in and out of chronology with no real purpose, the show zooms into diplomatic affairs around United Stares relations with Cuba. However, following only one side of diplomatic affairs leaves the audience too removed from any substantive conflict or narrative structure; all we see are bureaucratic discussions about more compelling events from a singular viewpoint. The audience detachment is aided by one of the show’s main drawbacks. “Public Charge” is unwilling to see any flaws of fault in its protagonist - in no small part due to its autobiographical nature. Every other character is painted as fallible and nuanced, the very things that make characters relatable and compelling to follow. This narrowed viewpoint also lends itself to a rose-tinted view of the United States government. This is clearest in the way that the show mythologizes Hillary Clinton; who is referred to reverently as “she” for most of the show. Invitations of nuance were avoided entirely, instead opting for less-than-subtle nods to a future Trump administration, which personally always resonate as the weakest form of political commentary/comedy. The show seemed to work better for an older and more centrist crowd, so there may be an audience for this work, it’s just not me. (Edited)
1–14 of 14 comments
This is a well-needed play for the current political climate, one that helps us understand how diplomacy works in real life, and gives us slight hope. As someone who immigrated to the US, I found myself intrigued by the storytelling around Cuba, South America, and their relationship with the United States during the years. Coming without the weight of too much familiarity, real events and real people felt fresh and urgent to me in a way. The play jumps between time and location, centering around Julissa Reynoso and a deceptively simple but powerful idea: when you put human beings at the center instead of rigid rules, countries can actually move past hatred and find somewhat common ground. Julissa is written with real depth she feels like a full person, not a symbol. The set is minimal while effective, and the staging places the audience on both sides, close to the actors, creating an intimacy that pulls you into the world of the play rather than keeping you at a distance. I would recommend this to people who wants to take a closer look at this part of history, or who is simply looking for a way forward , because sometimes drawing inspiration from the past is the way to move forward. At the very least, that's what it did for me. It gave me hope, resistance, and something close to a handbook on how to do the right thing and serve the people.