Operation Mincemeat
It was highly original musical, and it was certainly unique in many respects, but although I only saw it a few days ago and it wasn’t particularly memorable. I was already familiar with the story and it translated well into a high paced drama. It was also very slapstick and “British” and in this regard, it was very well done. It certainly held my interest throughout and the performance were all superb. I just didn’t fall in love with it like some people do, but it was altogether worth seeing.
A lot of heart but sometimes extraneous antics. The physical comedy was not quick enough and the quips not witty enough. Amazing that it grew from an acorn at Edinburgh, but it needed a much more deft spanner to tighten it up for Broadway. Endearing performances amd some lovely songs, though there seemed to be some mic issues the night I saw it.
Incredibly inventive — the collaborators make fine cast members, with a truly stand out performance from Jake (?) Malone (not one of the writers), who is sort of like John Cleese among the rest of the Monty Python cast. The gender switching works absolutely seamlessly, and the production is superb, with an ingenious set design, and a director who has paced the show for perfect comic timing. However, the score is mostly pretty weak, and the orchestrations are dismally awful. Two crappy-sounding synthesizers and a bass player and a drummer who never even begin to gel. How can that happen on Broadway? Somebody suggested that there should be a Tony award for best song; and while most of the lyrics and music fall flat, Jake Malone‘s ballad about a World War I letter to a soldier could win that award if it existed.
The show brings a ton of energy, wit, and is a fascinating story. It could be 20 to 30 minutes shorter by cutting parts of the first act. Additionally, the lyrics were difficult to understand for much of the performance. The sound quality issue might have been due to my seat location in the rear mezzanine, but I had to listen very carefully to catch the lyrics. Would potentially play better in a smaller off-broadway theater. But the creators of the show are in the cast which is a joy to see! Props to them for crafting and performing a new unique show! (Edited)
Dear Bill is a tear jerker and the comedy is very Dumb and Dumber like. Some of the jokes didn't land because they're really niche jokes about England. I also didn't leave singing any of the songs in my head. But I will say Jak Malone needs to be in the running for best supporting actor and the cast overall is fantastic!
Don't seat in back of balcony. Hard to understand some of the words due to their English accents
Loved it! Very funny and the music was great. My only complaint is that it was hard to understand some of the lyrics, so was a bit lost at a few points during the show.
Act Two is incredible! Act One I definitely felt like I was missing things due to sound or accents, but then I will recommend because Act Two is so fantastic that it all pays off
David Cumming is the star of the show and Jak Malone brings it home, especially with their musical number, “Dear Bill” When the comedy is forced, it could be very cringey. The funniest moments were when it was a lot more subtle.
Very broad comedy, hard to sustain, but becomes more grounded in Act 2 and is finally moving.
Great show- fun choreography, and the range some actors show is spectacular. The voice of a few actors was a bit muffled/difficult to hear even in the orchestra and the show is a bit too long, but overall worth the watch!
581–600 of 708 comments