Operation Mincemeat
Liked it. Wouldn’t see it again. Orchestra felt like it got the jokes more than back mezz where I was (and couldn’t see clearly). Sound design and articulation is terrible, especially with fast paced British accents. But fun overall!
Understudy for Bevan had much clearer audio!! It was her voice, which was higher and more piercing. She was great, but I missed some of Zoe’s expressions.
start relistening to the soundtrack the second i sat down on the bus some of those quick changes highkey had me screaming, god they're brilliant also noah liked it which made me really happy :) just take out all the ladies and it would be perfect. maybe i'm biased bc im a SIX hater (Edited)
Great show based on true events. The cast of 5 was visually amazing. Show has a great stage and amazing choreographies! I think Id love to see the choreographed acts again. However, 2.35 hrs was too long, specially after 1st part, leaves you wondering if actors speak too fast or if something is wrong with acoustics in theater, because understanding actors and songs is difficult over orchestra. Story is easy to follow because its a great story but I think many punchlines and dialogue were missed because of the audio issues, perhaps it was my seat location. Who knows, not interested in finding out. (Edited)
An absolutely astounding technical feet, the show is worth seeing for the ensemble's masterful command of the story and fluid running of the stage alone. I found it rather difficult, however, to drop in right at the start of the show, and struggled to understand many of the songs (just for challenge to follow the lyrics to start). And maybe controversially, felt myself grow disconnected at the Act 2 opener (I just don't think it's appropriate to do the whole "Nazis were just silly little guys" without something that really grounds the terror of what they were doing alongside that.) All that being said, it really is a stunning production overall so I recommend viewing, though I suggest, if you can, seats a little closer to help yourself feel more connected.
Very funny but a little too long and the sound quality wasn’t great in the rear mezz (I couldn’t understand some of the lyrics in the faster songs/sections)
sooooo so so british, like panto british which if i’m being honest is not entirely to my taste. i just didn’t laugh all that much? a Hamilton descendant both musically and in its solicitation of big satisfied Liberal Clap Breaks, which i always find cringey. look where we are!! broadway theater, respectfully, will not save us! i did find myself charmed by the scrappy, 5 people in 30 roles, necessarily clever stagecraft because they had to make do with what they’ve got quality of this. the flip side is these off west end comedians don’t enunciate like broadway actors do, and it does affect the quality of the singing. ultimately i am forever a sucker for quiet WWII heroism and keeping calm and carrying on— everyone chipping in and doing their part… pip pip cheerio. i teared up a little, i’ll admit it! (Edited)
Overall very funny and cute and with some very moving moments, if you can understand what they’re saying. On the day I went, the lead character swings’ UK accents were not only hard-to-believe, their enunciation was… mushy. It broke the magic a bit.
Not sure I got the hype here. There were a few really wonderful funny or touching moments, but in between them I was a little bored. Maybe the English humor just wasn’t for me. Most people I know loved it. I had a pretty uncomfortable seating situation so maybe that didn’t help.
Funny and clever, but definitely best suited for those who already enjoy British humor. The set was simple and minimal, allowing the performances to really shine. With only five actors on stage, it was impressive how much energy and versatility they brought—each of them did an amazing job. The audience skewed heavily tourist, which was about what I expected. Unfortunately, the woman seated behind me hooted and hollered throughout the show, which was distracting at times. Still, if you appreciate British wit and understated staging, this is an entertaining evening of theatre.
I saw this without knowing anything about it other than Jak Malone had just won a Tony. I didn’t love the first act, but the second act was good. I liked that it was only five people and the effort that took. (Edited)
While I thoroughly enjoyed my time at Operation Mincemeat I feel like the show doesn’t quite find the right balance between the goofy and the heartfelt. While it goes for camp it doesn’t commit enough, and while there are sincere showstoppers they are few and far between. Would I recommend? Absolutely. Did it profoundly affect me in any way? Sorry but no.
Interesting, entertaining, and energetic! But if your mother tongue isn't English, you won't be able to fully enjoy the show. Especially with their British accent and jokes. I used Galapro to understand the show. But even with the help from Galapro, it was a bit difficult to follow the show. They sing really fast, and often times, Galapro subtitles didn't sync well with the performance.
I liked it but it took me until act two to get really involved in the show. The tech? The quick changes? Life changing. I understand how it was a best musical winner.
I enjoyed Operation Mincemeat but found it difficult to keep up with even after watching the movie as homework. It’s quite dense and it was hard to understand all of it with the British accents. All the performers are outstanding but I was particularly won over by Natasha Hodgson and hope that she earns a Tony nomination. She is quite electric. I debated going with the cheap seats or splurging a bit and sitting in the orchestra and am glad I went with the orchestra given how difficult it was to keep up with the lyrics. Seat G9 was quite comfy with extra legroom and space between you and the left wall. Also, there is no seat in front of you so no heads are blocking your view. Good but not a favorite this season.
There were a lot of touching moments to this story and a lot of prop/costume/set changes that happened effortlessly and impressively. I don’t think I personally gravitated to the style of clowning and farce going on but glad I got to experience it!
Very smart, excellent direction. Sometimes hard to understand. Hester’s letter to Bill was incredible
Good cast. Topic was a bit hard for me to handle as a jewish person as it’s about war world 2. In the beginning didn’t understand a word as had British accents but in time got better. Overall good show but not sure I would rec it to everyone
541–560 of 708 comments
There’s been a lot of discussion over whether “Operation Mincemeat” is funny for an American audience or not. And while I do think it’s funny, it’s not necessarily for the reasons you might think. The overall feeling that I keep coming back to as I think about this show is the hilarity in the fact that this is a true story — they didn’t add anything and, in fact, that had to tone down some of the ridiculousness because the events that transpired are so unbelievable. The basic premise is a group of British officers trick Germany into thinking they’re going to invade Sardinia instead of Sicily by sending a dead body, made out to be a soldier, into the ocean with a briefcase full of documents of their fake plan. From there, craziness ensues and you truly can’t make this up. Because of the insanity in the historically accurate story, it does make sense that they would choose to tell this story in the over-the-top, in-your-face, almost panto style that they did. But while they are entirely set on making war funny, I can’t help but feel that they neglected the pathos or balance of emotions that is necessary to keep us engaged in this story. The show leans so far into this oversaturated obviousness that we aren’t really given a moment to breathe. All of the performances are entertaining, with the five actors playing many different roles, but in order to simplify a story and premise that could otherwise be quite complicated, many of the characters do fall into stereotypes which I didn’t find entirely funny, such as Charles’ nerdiness about newts. The one exception to this is Jak Malone as the secretary Hester. In his solo, “Dear Bill,” by far one of the most memorable songs in the show, he writes a letter pretending to be the fiancé of the fake soldier they’re inventing and he’s able to evoke the mixed sadness and hope that war brings about. Before singing, Hester remarks that this is not the first war she’s lived through, hinting at the fact that she had a fiancé who died in WWI. At the end, the show does attempt to offer a bit of sentimentalism about the man who became the body that they used, but it falls short in acknowledging that, even though Bill wasn’t a real soldier, many people were Bill. Many real soldiers left their fiancés and their families and gave their lives to the war. They may have invented Bill, but he is all too real. Among this little known and truly unbelievable story in history, there is the backdrop of seriousness. The show could have benefitted from grounding itself in the seriousness a bit more through further moments like “Dear Bill” and this juxtaposition could have highlighted the funny moments even more. It’s hard not to compare something like this to a show like “Come From Away,” another musical about a small part of history that does a remarkable job grounding itself in the true tragedy that surrounded it. And what “Come From Away” does really well that “Operation Mincemeat” could benefit from, in my opinion, is building a sense of intimacy with the audience. The “Operation Mincemeat” production is interesting, largely relying on lights, but it feels slightly too big for the small cast of actors. I wish the production had leaned into a more innovative, inventive style of staging that feels more focused around the actors and the characters. I also think the show could have been a one-act to make sure that the comedy isn’t overdone and that we remain invested throughout. Overall I thoroughly enjoyed this piece and it has stuck with me. There are some brilliant performances and it’s incredible what this small team of people have been able to achieve. But it seems to me as though everyone is asking the question “is war funny?” whereas I feel that this show is funny but the question should be “is it too funny?” Does it lean too far into the hilarity, to the point where it’s almost exhausting to watch because we really aren’t given a break, and forget to build in just a few more moments like “Dear Bill” that remind us of the context in which this is taking place? I certainly don’t mean that this piece should become a tear-jerking commentary on the realities of warfare, but a bit of a blend in the tone could have made the comedy shine even more.