Oh, Mary!
Turns out I don’t love slapstick comedy but for those who do, go see it! I still laughed, just didn’t enjoy it as much I thought I would based on the reviews here. Went so I could see Maya Rudolph’s Broadway debut, so no regrets there.
Honestly better the second time around. Still silly. Still dumb. Still not really my thing bit definitely a good time. Betty is great. 🍦🎭 (Those prices for a 75 min show though!! Don’t spend full price…)
Not sure how this is listed as the funniest show in years. I did not laugh once. The show is stupid, just that, it’s not funny. If you find stupid funny guess you’ll appreciate it. Cole does not take the role they play to the extent they could. I feel Cole really could have taken the role so much further if they close to.
Highlight for me was Bianca Leigh back as Mary’s Chaperone. I know this probably isn’t aligned with production’s financial strategy, but I’d like to see more performers who came up in theater (as opposed to film/TV) in the Mary role. (Edited)
It was a hoot and a holler but the more I look back at it the more I realize the plot made no sense. Very campy and Cole has excellent timing
It was funny! Though, some moments that felt a tiny bit rushed to me. Like a tiny pause would have make the some of the jokes/ silliness hit better. Seat was pretty good! Left side was a bit blocked but mostly because of someone in front of me.
841–860 of 1,055 comments
Oh, Mary! is very good overall, with strong performances and a clear point of view, but it wasn’t entirely my taste. It’s not a musical, which is worth noting going in, and it leans heavily into camp. While the exaggerated style and humor clearly worked for much of the audience, it felt a little too campy for me at times, occasionally pulling me out of the show rather than drawing me in. That said, it’s well done and undeniably effective in what it’s trying to be. If you enjoy bold, over-the-top comedy, this will likely be right up your alley—even if it didn’t fully click for me. (Edited)