Oh, Mary!
C**t. See it.
good
Absolutely spectacular
𝐈𝐓 𝐂𝐎𝐔𝐋𝐃 𝐇𝐀𝐕𝐄 𝐁𝐄𝐄𝐍 𝐁𝐄𝐓𝐓𝐘-𝐄𝐑 😓 I finally got to watch Betty Gilpin as Mary, and this time, I had the amazing opportunity to see it from the second row, orchestra center. Seeing the show up close allowed me to fully take in her performance and compare it to the original cast. The original cast set a high standard for me since I had seen the show twice with them, and I loved it both times. Watching it for the third time with the new cast, I did not feel the same energy and excitement I had before. This was mainly because of the delivery of the jokes. What made this play work for me was not just the jokes themselves but also the facial expressions and mannerisms that elevated the comedy. Betty’s performance was not bad. If you are watching for the first time, I think you will enjoy her. However, for me, her performance did not live up to Cole’s ridiculously funny portrayal of Mary. HOWEVER, when it comes to singing, BETTY WAS BETTER. I had no idea she could sing, and it was such a fun surprise to hear her up close. Chris and Philip were okay and had some funny moments, but they did not have the same charm and presence as Conrad and James. Each of the new cast members brought their own style to the jokes, but in comparison to the original, I found myself a bit disappointed. Nonetheless, I still love the show and highly recommend it. I am also so excited to see Titus play this role because I know he is funny and can sing as well! I will then make the ultimate comparison and pick once I see titus!
𝐎𝐇 𝐓𝐈𝐓𝐔𝐒, 𝐘𝐎𝐔'𝐑𝐄 𝐌𝐀𝐑𝐕𝐄𝐋𝐎𝐔𝐒! This is my fourth time watching this show, and I'm so glad I had the chance to see it again on Titus' debut as Mary Todd Lincoln. I'm a fan of him in Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt and Schmigadoon, shows that highlight his talent as both a comedian and a singer. When it was announced that he'd be playing the role, I was so thrilled that I had to find a way to watch him, as I knew he would be perfect for it. And he did not disappoint. He was hilarious. He was unhinged. He was everything I expected him to be. The wig looked so funny on him, and his facial expressions brought a whole new energy to the role. Having seen it four times, I noticed many changes he made in the delivery of the punchlines, most of which were brilliant decisions. He brought a very original approach to the role, which was refreshing to see. I honestly think he changed some of the lines, as I couldn’t remember some of his punchlines. My most anticipated part of the show was the final performance, and boy he knocked it out of the park. Even though he was undeniably hilarious, I think his performance today wasn’t his best yet. He kept touching his wig, and some of the jokes were rushed and lacked clarity in delivery. I know he’ll adjust along the way, but despite these issues, he was still A STAR!!
Went again to see how Jinkx would take on the role. I was a bit disappointed. Jinkx screamed. She screamed a lot. It was funny the first time or two, but it seemed to become a crutch which left the performance feeling rather surface and one-note. The play is still brilliant, but this rewatch made me really appreciate the nuance that Jane Krakowski brought to the role. Some fans may revel in the brute audacity of this Jinkx rendition, but I felt Jane’s nuance grounded the piece which allowed for the absurdity to shine. Unfortunately, this was my friend’s first experience with Oh, Mary and so many of the lines were just lost to being shouted at us. It’s a shame he missed some great dialogue. No wonder Jinkx was on vocal rest at the stage door 🤭😅 (Edited)
Is the play you go to laugh your pants off! Physical comedy is high and the script is on point! Honestly, there’s nothing like this on Broadway. I was able to get the return of the original cast and it was amazing! Cole Escola nailed on this production! However, heard some people say it was an SNL sketch that went too long and I don’t totally disagree on that. (Edited)
Second time seeing the show, this time on Broadway with Jane Krakowski. It was…fine. The Broadway prices are totally out of control for what this is, which is 90 minutes of light stupid fun - I went again because I had friends in town who really wanted to see itk. And having seen Cole Escola in this, I thought Jane Krakowski played it kind of safe. She was very good, but she didn’t lean into the absurdity of it all enough in my view. I felt like I was watching her Jenna Maroney character from 30 rock perform, which was fun but again, not for these prices.
Hmmm. Not sure I really understood what was going on. Should have read about it before so I knew what the story was about and what the style was going to be. Performance was impressive. Not sure how they keep the energy going night after night. Funny moments, but felt like there were lots of in jokes that went over my head. We were right at the top and back, so view was slightly obscured by the railings. Think it was a good performance, but think I’d enjoy it more going to see it a second time, now I know what to expect.
OH WOW!! Oh, Mary! had a lot to live up to with all the hype surrounding it, and I’m happy to say it totally LIVED UP TO THE HYPE! From start to finish, I couldn’t stop laughing. It was everything I wanted in a comedy. Not only was it incredibly funny, but the story also had plenty of surprises that kept me entertained the whole way through. The writing was brilliant, with every scene ending on a punchline that left the audience bursting with laughter. Even though I’m not a big fan of American history, this play presented its (admittedly not-so-accurate) story in such an entertaining way that it held my attention from start to finish. Cole Escola and Conrad Ricamora were ABSOLUTE SHOWSTOPPERS as the Lincoln couple. Their comedic timing and performances were flawless, with Escola’s facial expressions alone leaving me laughing non-stop. They carried the show with so much energy and charm that they made every moment unforgettable, especially the final performance. The only reason I’m not giving it a perfect score is that I wanted more from the story. It felt too short, and there wasn’t much of a resolution, which left me a little disappointed. A stronger ending could have made it even better. Still, Oh, Mary! is hands down the FUNNIEST SHOW I’ve seen all year. It’s clever, hilarious, and such a good time. I’d definitely watch it again just to laugh as much as I did the first time! WHAT A SHOW!
The acting was hilarious, and I loved Simu in it as Boothe. I did expect it to be longer and more clever/less slapstick. It is the over-the-top expressions of the actors that sell it (so was glad to have a good Orchestra seat)! John Cameron Mitchell did a great job, but I’m sad I missed Jane Krakowski as Mary, and now I hear Maya Rudolph will be playing Mary down the road!
Maybe my expectations were set a little too high. Yes, I laughed out loud, and as a history nerd who had recently visited Mary Todd Lincoln's home in Kentucky, I was excited for the full on comedy of their lives. This show is over the top, which meant for me, some of the jokes felt predictable or forced. Sure, I love a gay president, but I wish the characters were a little more complex rather than just antics for laughs. This show a cross between Family Guy and a Ru Paul's Drag Race skit. Both of those things are great, but for 90 minutes I think something else needs to be introduced. It's refreshing to laugh at the theater, especially at Shakespearen-esque mix-ups and presidential blow jobs. If physical comedy and absurd historical silliness is what you're looking for, or if you loved every moment of Potus, this show is certainly for you.
The house manager was so excellent and nice. JCM was fantastic. Honestly it started a little slow for me and didn’t find the beginning funny but it picked up and ended really well. I can see why you’d come back and see different people in the role of Mary.
Hilarious, definitely more farcical than anticipated but still a good time. The worst bit was dealing with the American audience who clapped at everything for some reason which really ruined the momentum of the show.
genius. wish I didn’t take my grandma
821–840 of 1,055 comments
Hilarious