Mindplay
Vinny DePonto’s Mindplay is a captivating show any way you look at it. I’ll admit, anytime I saw mentalists on talent competitions, etc., I was one of the skeptics convinced that any audience members were plants primed on what to say beforehand. Having been pulled up as a volunteer on stage with Vinny though, I was truly awestruck. However, what I liked most about Mindplay went beyond these incredible feats, which are likely what audience members expect coming into the show. In addition to Vinny spending time contextualizing his act, a narrative arc winds through the show, adding an element of theatricality and a scripted experience to it that gets the audience emotionally invested. This was not only wonderfully funny but surprisingly heartfelt and touching (due partly to the stories shared by audience volunteers at my performance). Vinny is undeniably charming and welcoming, brimming with warmth and making all the audience members (speaking from personal experience) feel comfortable in a vulnerable position of having their minds read onstage. If your only experience with mentalism is at a distance and as a skeptic (or especially if you’re a fan), this combines the best of that and theatre into one riveting hour and a half!
To say that this show blew my mind would be a complete understatement! 🤯 Vinny DePonto is THE REAL DEAL. He’s not just a mentalist, but an entertainer and empathetic storyteller. ‘Mindplay’ was heartfelt, funny, and extremely moving. ❤️ Though a bit slow at the start (because the audience I was a part of wasn’t the most enthusiastically participative), Vinny was still able to shock and dazzle and make every little thing he set up pay off by the end. It was very clear that volunteers were delighted and charmed—never intimidated, shamed, or made fun of. The set design was also not what I expected, and was a clever surprise thar caught me off guard in the best way.
Wow wow wow. What a show to start the year with! Mindplay is a one-man show where Vinny DePonto dives into the human mind. The ways it can fail, flourish, achieve unbelievable things, and the way it can connect us all. Vinny opens his mind to us, sharing what weighs on it, and invites the audience to do the same. The performance heavily uses randomly selected audience involvement and it was so fun to see how each person brought something unique. This show is both moving and hilarious. I don’t laugh out loud too often at shows, but I was constantly laughing during this. The size of the space also makes the show feel much more intimate, making you feel closer to every audience member, especially those Vinny highlights. I was one of the audience members selected and all I can say without spoiling is that it was freaky in the best way. Last night was surely one of my favorite theatre experiences ever. There were room-wide gasps during the portion of the show I was involved in. I cannot explain what happened haha. It was mind-boggling. I could not have asked for a better show to start the year and I will certainly be telling everyone I know to go see this. I might even go back myself. In the meantime I’ll be trying to unlock my own mind powers. Run! Do not miss this show!
Vinny DePonto’s Mindplay is a captivating blend of magic, storytelling, and heartfelt emotion that left me reflecting long after the show ended. I attended with my mom, neither of us knowing what to expect, and we were both struck by how deeply its themes of memory and loss resonated—specifcially Vinny’s relationship with his grandparents. At its core, Mindplay feels like a love letter to DePonto’s grandparents, skillfully woven into a performance about connection, the fragility of memory, and the effort to preserve it all through the concept of the “mind palace.” DePonto’s use of audience participation is both fascinating and essential, showcasing the trust and intimacy that are required to succeed as a mentalist. As someone who rarely volunteers, I was surprised by how safe and inviting the space felt under Vinny’s care. Coupled with outstanding sound and lighting, the production creates a dreamlike, surprisingly relaxing atmosphere—I nearly forgot I was in a theater and not a therapist’s office. The show is also unexpectedly funny, thanks to Vinny’s quick wit and sharp timing, yet balanced with touching anecdotes from both him and the audience volunteers. Ultimately, Mindplay is a heartfelt tribute and a unique theatrical experience that’s equal parts entertaining and moving. (Edited)
This was a fairly mind-blowing night! Without giving anything away, there’s some seriously hard-to-explain mentalism going on, and it’s delivered in such a way that you never see the strings, as it were. My friend was called up onstage, and she’s still shaking a little— it’s spooky stuff! On reflection, I think I have a fairly good idea of how the show is accomplished. But even with that knowledge, the “memory palace” that Vinny operates is pretty impressive.
As someone who reads up on psychology in their spare time, I never know how I’m going to respond to mind reading acts. In Mindplay, there were moments that I was able to figure out how he was able to predict/read the audience’s thoughts; but beyond his mind reading skill set, I was more impressed by his effect on the audience. The more he revealed his own fears, joys, and innermost thoughts, the more he won over the audience’s trust and attention. I witnessed individuals overcome with emotion as DePonto helped excavate their lost memories—with their consent— in-front of a mass of watching strangers. In 80 short minutes, DePonto cultivated a strange, quiet seance-esq community with the goal of inner-exploration to foster outer-connection and empathy. The technical designs were beyond gorgeous and impressive. Although I won’t reveal anything, I would recommend the show purely because of its ability to engulf the viewer into the atmosphere instantaneously. Plus, the use of cassettes are always a welcome bonus in my book.
Mindplay genuinely blew my mind. I don’t know if I believe in mind reading, but I believe in what happened in this theatre. I was on the edge of my seat, simultaneously hoping to be called on and so nervous that it might actually happen. Vinny is a wonderfully charming performer and storyteller. I was not expecting how heartfelt the show would be. The use of the space, the set, the props, sound, and lighting, all blended together to create the perfect atmosphere for this show. This show may not be for everyone (those who may be on the more skeptical side, those looking for a play or musical, etc.) but I definitely recommend it.
Mindplay was a thrilling, interactive and immersive show, that takes the audience on a journey and connects us all. There was a big community aspect that was built amongst the audience at the top to take this mentalist/magical journey together, which made it easier for more anxious minds (like myself) to buy in. I was definitely on the edge of my seat the entire time, but not in a fearful way! Vinny DePonto is down to earth, funny and exciting to watch, and super skilled in his craft. There are moments that feel absolutely impossible to the naked eye, yet there we were, shocked moment after moment. He really does see us all, so go in ready to be perceived in this intimate venue. If you're not into the whole mind-reading thing, maybe this isn't for you, but nothing too scary or intense happens outside of a few lighting moments. I’d say go in with an open mind; I'd actually love to go back to see how the show shifts with a different audience!
𝐌𝐈𝐍𝐃-𝐁𝐋𝐎𝐖𝐈𝐍𝐆-𝐏𝐋𝐀𝐘! Mindplay is a unique, participatory theatrical experience that keeps audiences on the edge of their seats. With every successful trick, it leaves everyone in awe. This was my first time attending a magic or mentalism show, and while I was a bit nervous, I also hoped to participate just to see for myself if the tricks were truly real. Unfortunately, I did not get the chance to do that. At first, I was skeptical. Some moments did not amaze me because I suspected that certain audience members might have been part of the production—their reactions felt a bit staged. However, despite my doubts, there were tricks that genuinely left me wondering how they were pulled off, making the experience all the more fascinating. Vinny DePonto is an excellent storyteller, captivating the audience with his charisma and wit. I am not sure if the failed tricks were intentional, but I was impressed by how he smoothly turned them into punchlines and distractions, keeping the energy of the show intact. The play was not just a showcase of tricks—it took the audience on a personal journey. I will probably watch it again, and next time, I hope to participate in any way I can. (I just hope my speculations are wrong because if they are true, I will be kind ofdisappointed! But for now, I love the show!) Overall, if you want to witness a show that blends illusion, storytelling, and audience participation in a truly engaging way, MINDPLAY IS A MUST-SEE!
How does the mind weave our memories into the very fabric of our being? Vinny DePonto is a charming, funny, and skilled mentalist who explores this idea through mind control techniques and his own experiences, creating an immersive play/magic show performance. The audience participation activity before the show tuned me in to this concept, and had me looking forward to audience participation instead of fearing it. The set and effects were visually stunning, and we were always kept on our toes throughout the show. Our seats were at the very end of the row on the right side, but the view was still great for majority of the show! Without spoiling the tricks, MindPlay is an impressive combination of exciting and heartstring-pulling moments that led to an entertaining night. Though it could feel somewhat artificial and disjointed at times, the flow was great throughout and always came back around to Vinny’s creative mind, comedic prowess, and heartfelt story. Definitely recommend to those interested in psychology, but also for anyone looking for a little mystery and wonder in their night out!
A fascinating play that is both part magic show (mentalism, specifically) and memoir exploring our magician’s (Vinny DePonto) personal memories, fears and life. While the magic is not always seamlessly integrated into the narrative, it is undeniably impressive. And the real heart of the show is the audience interactions, when he is able to bring an audience member up on stage (seemingly at random) and effortlessly read what is on their mind and offer them some kind of solace in whatever is troubling them. While these are “tricks” (he admits that himself during the show) they are undeniably human, real and raw. It’s genuinely cathartic getting to see some of these sequences play out, and definitely worth the price of admission alone.
At the beginning of Mindplay, it become really apparent to me that the show wants the audience to remember a time when performance was as simple as human amazement - when a human with a brain impressive enough could BE the show, and how much the digital age has taken that from us. This amazement was the key thing I left the show with. From the loosely vaudevillian set, the olde time flip projector, telephones, and even jokes at nostalgia, I deeply appreciated the framing that was provided as support to Vinny’s impressive magic. I’ll agree with some of the comments about the narrative ties and their weaknesses, but those were means to an end, the end being a wonderful and charming performance with some head-scratching and surprisingly intimate magic. (Edited)
had so much fun with this. so many wtf moments i couldn’t help but ask strangers in the bathroom line how he did certain tricks after the show. part-play, part immersive mentalist experience, it’d be wrong to chalk MINDPLAY up to a “magic show.” the piece dissects our idea of memory (or lack thereof) and how it can subconsciously affect our everyday lives, while boasting an array of mind tricks that directly involve the audience — often in deeply personal and heartfelt ways. would love to see this again; it’s sure to be a different and exciting show every night.
Mindplay combines the magical elements of mentalism with touching hints of memoir to create a really fun night out. The set design is quite simple (though not without some surprises,) and not every trick is executed 100% perfectly, but I was still charmed throughout. This is the unique sort of off-Broadway experience that makes you feel grateful for all of the little theaters in NYC putting on experimental pieces. The best part of the show is the connection that happens between the audience with each other and with Vinny Deponto. There are moments that will make you gasp, and other moments that will leave you touched at the vulnerable display of emotion. It’s not life-changing theater but it’s definitely worth seeing for the unique experience. Warning: anyone in the audience could be pulled in for some participation moments. None of them are scary or embarrassing, but if that doesn’t interest you, you might want to avoid.
Whether you believe in mind reading/the mystic or not, “MindPlay” provides a rare experience for any modern theatre audience: connection. Vinny DePonto uses the brief 90 mins to expertly guide the audience through an exploration of their own and each other’s memories; consequently challenging what we know of memories, how we think about memories, and what happens to a human when they have too many or too little! With a set consisting of (seemingly) nothing found in this century, and a series of inconspicuous curtains you are immediately immersed in a land where time feels funky. (In the best way) I can’t recall the last time (or any time) I’ve left an audience having cried tears specifically for another audience member. Even the post-show disbelief and shock provide a singular shared experience for a unique audience each night. DePonto balances his actor, mentalist and storyteller hats nicely throughout the show. I can’t sing higher praises for how well the narrative aspects of this piece are played out. A lot of times with content like this the audience is left wondering what the point of the show is besides impressing people and showing off abilities . The show has a strong reason to be in existence. Yet the narrative aspects are not overpowering of the humorous and Mystical.
"Mindplay," starring the charismatic mentalist Vinny DePonto, offers a fascinating blend of psychological illusion, audience interaction, and personal storytelling. DePonto's performances keep audiences guessing throughout the 90-minute runtime. Mindplay bears similarities to other popular mentalism acts like "Mind Mangler" and “Stalker”, but DePonto brings his own unique energy and style to the stage. His ability to predict audience behaviors and seemingly read minds creates moments of genuine astonishment that ripple through the theater. What elevates "Mindplay" beyond mere trickery is DePonto's personal narrative about his grandparents and his attempts to preserve and relive those precious memories. This emotional thread gives the show unexpected depth and resonance. His story of his grandfather particularly struck a chord with me, evoking memories of my own grandfather and adding a layer of unexpected poignancy to the experience. The show's opening suffers from excessive exposition that feels like unnecessary fluff, slowing the momentum before the real magic begins. However, once DePonto moves beyond the introductions, "Mindplay" hits its stride with a series of increasingly impressive mental feats. The production maintains its sense of surprise and wonder throughout, with clever twists that keep the audience engaged until the final moment. Rating: Happy Face (Edited)
I have not laughed that much in a show for a long time. This would be one of the show I would watch over and over.
I was astounded by the absolute wonder this man performs on stage balancing truth and honesty with theatricality. The genuine moments of wonder and intrigue between you and your fellow audience members really pulled me in throughout the entire time. That use of connection is such a powerful vehicle the show uses. I will say you must go into this production, like any interactive piece, prepared to participate. It increases the effectiveness of the whole event if you do so and I would recommend it because you will get to experience some magnificent things and learn about your mind all in the process.
I have seen some magic and mind-reading performances before, and every time I watch them, I am always impressed by the moments when you truly have no idea what’s going on or the principles behind the tricks. This show is very much audience engagement, amazing mind-reading bits with a stunning set design, and a well thought out storyline. By the end of it, as an audience member, I felt more connected to my own memories and emotions. Great storytelling, and some thought provoking quotes. If the transitions between segments were smoother, it would be absolutely perfect!
1–20 of 57 comments
If you’ve ever wondered what it would be like to sit in on an 1800s’ seance, this might be it. Although you won’t be conjuring spirits, you’ll tap into thoughts. BrainPlay is that little bit of something different perfect for the winter season. Hey ready for Memory Lane. Vinny DePonto, our showman for the evening, created such a welcoming environment. Every aspect of the set, sound, and found lighting cast me into nostalgia. Before we entered, we were asked to answer writing prompts in the lobby, seal them off, and drop them into buckets at the foot of the stage. Our thoughts became the heart of the show. I secretly wished my note would be chosen, but also held my breath knowing that could be a possibility throughout the night. Each time someone’s story was reviled, I felt a little more connected to them through relatability. But across all the anxieties, the fears, the love, I remained mystified. As I left the theater, there was only one word on my mind: HOW. It won’t move mountains, or change the world—but it might make you stop and wonder what someone else is dealing with. And maybe that little bit of Mindplay’s ✨ magic ✨ is just the remedy for this holiday season. I would love to return to the Greenwhich Houss Theater and see how a new audience changes the show. Until then…I’ll keep thinking about it.