About
Following critically acclaimed, sold-out engagements at the Geffen Playhouse in Los Angeles and Arena Stage in Washington, DC, the smash-hit Mindplay will enthrall audiences in New York City this December. Created and performed by Drama Desk Award-nominated mentalist Vinny DePonto (Charlatan), written by Vinny DePonto and Josh Koenigsberg, and directed by Andrew Neisler, Mindplay invites audiences to an unforgettable, gasp-inducing experience in which your thoughts and memories play a leading role. Infused with intrigue and mystery, DePonto guides participants on a jaw-dropping, interactive journey as he reads minds while also revealing his own.
The show was hailed by Broadway World LA as an “inviting, nostalgia-ridden… gem of a performance. Vinny DePonto is a masterful actor, storyteller, mentalist, and illusionist, and Mindplay puts all his talents on display in a unique production that is not to be missed.” The Washington Post raves that DePonto “brings ‘how did he do that?’ wonder to delight all…” and demonstrates “enthralling feats of mind-probing prowess…” and “mesmerizing stage magic — including one particularly head-spinning stunt.” Masterfully blurring the line between illusion and reality, while investigating the wildly unreliable nature of memory, Mindplay will send audiences reeling into the night.
Cast & Creatives
Created and Performed by Vinny DePonto Written by Vinny DePonto and Josh Koenigsberg Directed by Andrew Neisler Produced by Eva Price, Thomas Kail, Arielle Tepper, Maidson Wells Live, and Hugo Six
Seat Views
View all 7 seat viewsCommunity Discussion
Vinny DePonto’s Mindplay is a captivating show any way you look at it. I’ll admit, anytime I saw mentalists on talent competitions, etc., I was one of the skeptics convinced that any audience members were plants primed on what to say beforehand. Having been pulled up as a volunteer on stage with Vinny though, I was truly awestruck. However, what I liked most about Mindplay went beyond these incredible feats, which are likely what audience members expect coming into the show. In addition to Vinny spending time contextualizing his act, a narrative arc winds through the show, adding an element of theatricality and a scripted experience to it that gets the audience emotionally invested. This was not only wonderfully funny but surprisingly heartfelt and touching (due partly to the stories shared by audience volunteers at my performance). Vinny is undeniably charming and welcoming, brimming with warmth and making all the audience members (speaking from personal experience) feel comfortable in a vulnerable position of having their minds read onstage. If your only experience with mentalism is at a distance and as a skeptic (or especially if you’re a fan), this combines the best of that and theatre into one riveting hour and a half!
To say that this show blew my mind would be a complete understatement! 🤯 Vinny DePonto is THE REAL DEAL. He’s not just a mentalist, but an entertainer and empathetic storyteller. ‘Mindplay’ was heartfelt, funny, and extremely moving. ❤️ Though a bit slow at the start (because the audience I was a part of wasn’t the most enthusiastically participative), Vinny was still able to shock and dazzle and make every little thing he set up pay off by the end. It was very clear that volunteers were delighted and charmed—never intimidated, shamed, or made fun of. The set design was also not what I expected, and was a clever surprise thar caught me off guard in the best way.
Wow wow wow. What a show to start the year with! Mindplay is a one-man show where Vinny DePonto dives into the human mind. The ways it can fail, flourish, achieve unbelievable things, and the way it can connect us all. Vinny opens his mind to us, sharing what weighs on it, and invites the audience to do the same. The performance heavily uses randomly selected audience involvement and it was so fun to see how each person brought something unique. This show is both moving and hilarious. I don’t laugh out loud too often at shows, but I was constantly laughing during this. The size of the space also makes the show feel much more intimate, making you feel closer to every audience member, especially those Vinny highlights. I was one of the audience members selected and all I can say without spoiling is that it was freaky in the best way. Last night was surely one of my favorite theatre experiences ever. There were room-wide gasps during the portion of the show I was involved in. I cannot explain what happened haha. It was mind-boggling. I could not have asked for a better show to start the year and I will certainly be telling everyone I know to go see this. I might even go back myself. In the meantime I’ll be trying to unlock my own mind powers. Run! Do not miss this show!
Vinny DePonto’s Mindplay is a captivating blend of magic, storytelling, and heartfelt emotion that left me reflecting long after the show ended. I attended with my mom, neither of us knowing what to expect, and we were both struck by how deeply its themes of memory and loss resonated—specifcially Vinny’s relationship with his grandparents. At its core, Mindplay feels like a love letter to DePonto’s grandparents, skillfully woven into a performance about connection, the fragility of memory, and the effort to preserve it all through the concept of the “mind palace.” DePonto’s use of audience participation is both fascinating and essential, showcasing the trust and intimacy that are required to succeed as a mentalist. As someone who rarely volunteers, I was surprised by how safe and inviting the space felt under Vinny’s care. Coupled with outstanding sound and lighting, the production creates a dreamlike, surprisingly relaxing atmosphere—I nearly forgot I was in a theater and not a therapist’s office. The show is also unexpectedly funny, thanks to Vinny’s quick wit and sharp timing, yet balanced with touching anecdotes from both him and the audience volunteers. Ultimately, Mindplay is a heartfelt tribute and a unique theatrical experience that’s equal parts entertaining and moving. (Edited)




If you’ve ever wondered what it would be like to sit in on an 1800s’ seance, this might be it. Although you won’t be conjuring spirits, you’ll tap into thoughts. BrainPlay is that little bit of something different perfect for the winter season. Hey ready for Memory Lane. Vinny DePonto, our showman for the evening, created such a welcoming environment. Every aspect of the set, sound, and found lighting cast me into nostalgia. Before we entered, we were asked to answer writing prompts in the lobby, seal them off, and drop them into buckets at the foot of the stage. Our thoughts became the heart of the show. I secretly wished my note would be chosen, but also held my breath knowing that could be a possibility throughout the night. Each time someone’s story was reviled, I felt a little more connected to them through relatability. But across all the anxieties, the fears, the love, I remained mystified. As I left the theater, there was only one word on my mind: HOW. It won’t move mountains, or change the world—but it might make you stop and wonder what someone else is dealing with. And maybe that little bit of Mindplay’s ✨ magic ✨ is just the remedy for this holiday season. I would love to return to the Greenwhich Houss Theater and see how a new audience changes the show. Until then…I’ll keep thinking about it.