John Proctor is the Villain
So good!!!! Partial view, but didn’t miss a thing!
Had to see it one more time before Sadie Sink leaves. Amazing every time!
Setting aside that it’s a tad predictable, this is a really good play in an incredibly strong production. All around incredible — the 100 minutes flew by. And this play cements Danya Taymor as one of the great directors working on Broadway right now.
Sobbed
Absolutely AMAZING show! I expected a lot, yet it far exceeded my expectations. Powerful, emotional, moving, meaningful, funny, surprising and smart. Acting was phenomenal!
so so so so good!!!!!!! i cannot stop thinking about it
Absolutely loved it. Girlhood is such a beautiful thing… let’s fight for it
As someone who never enjoyed reading "The Crucible" in middle school, I approached "John Proctor Was A Villain" with considerable skepticism. Add to that my complete unfamiliarity with Sadie Sink (apparently a star to many), and my expectations were admittedly low walking into the theater. I was pleasantly surprised. This compact powerhouse of a show, running a brisk 1 hour and 45 minutes without intermission, doesn't waste a single moment. The production tackles heavy themes with surprising deftness, creating an experience that feels both timely and honest. What particularly impressed me was the show's handling of its Gen Z characters. Despite focusing on contemporary teenagers, the production refreshingly avoids the reality of individuals constantly staring at their phones. References to digital culture are woven naturally into the dialogue without physical devices dominating the stage—a subtle choice that allows the emotional connections between characters to take center stage. That said, this isn't a show for everyone. The production is richly layered with pop culture references that will particularly resonate with younger audiences. Its unflinching exploration of complex social dynamics creates a narrative that especially connects with young female viewers, offering perspectives rarely centered in mainstream theater. Among the standout performances, Fina Strazza deserves special recognition. Barely offstage for a moment throughout the show, Strazza passionately explores her character's relationships, individuality, and interests with remarkable vulnerability. The real magic of "John Proctor Was A Villain," however, comes in its final scenes. Without spoiling anything, the production builds to a moment of such genuine, palpable joy that it's nearly impossible not to be swept up in the collective emotion radiating from the talented cast. Their chemistry and commitment to these complicated characters create an ending that feels both earned and unexpectedly moving. Happy Face+ (Edited)
Not a dry eye in the house
Great show. Leaves you guessing a bit at the end on what happened and is going to happen in the future.
super thought provoking -jacque great performances -jacque amazing set/light/sound design, and awesome interpretive dance for real
Probably one of my favorite things I’ve seen on Broadway. Cannot recommend it enough. I saw it on Sadie Sink’s final performance (she was phenomenal) but nonetheless it is still a must see even without her performing!
I didn’t want it to end!
I loved the show, Sadie Sink was really good, I thought it was funny and cutesy! I would def see it again, this show made me feel young again! (Edited)
literally a zillenial dream sadie sink killed it i could not recommend it more
Incredible show. Perfectly staged, written and acted. The ending is amazing. It helps a bit if you know The Crucible, but that isn't necessary. Just go see it.
Great cast! Heavy subject but very good show
Highly enjoyed this play, the cast, the lighting, the pop culture references. Everyone needs to see this. And maybe a quick spark notes of the crucible before hand!
An electric theatre experience. Loved the ensemble. Sadie Sink was excellent. Writing was smart. (Edited)
141–160 of 486 comments
Had to see it one last time before it ends its run. This play is everything.