John Proctor is the Villain
Third time really is a charm! This was the most insane performance from each member of the cast. I memorized each and every detail that I could. The final scene had me sobbing AGAIN. It was even a poster-drop day. I will remember that specific performance for the rest of my life. I never want to forget it.
Absolutely amazing play! The performances were amazing and I was a senior in high school in 2018 when this takes place and it really took me back! The final scene was a standout to me I didn’t even realize I was crying until I was, just with what the scene meant and what it does.. hope to see it again one day!
Saw this a second time and caught lots of things I missed the first time. I cried during the last scene. So cathartic. I am Gen X. Don’t let them tell you this one is just for the kids. The writing is so good here. Left full of female rage. (Edited)
love love love love loved it. went in blind (r we surprised at this point) and genuinely ended it with tears streaming down my neck Seating Tip: it can be a little difficult to see if you are a #short queen like me but ultimately not a horrible seat
Show 5 of 5 of my July 2025 solo trip. This was so cathartic - I went in totally blind and was so glad I did. I laughed and cried the whole time with the whole cast and audience. It was beautiful! So glad to see Sadie in her last week. Left the theatre still teary eyed and hugging the woman next to me. (Edited)
This play took me right back to the conversations my friends and I had at our lunch table in middle school, in high school. The conversations about Taylor Swift and celebrity crushes. About our male teachers (I admit), about the drama in our grade. But also the conversations every girl needs to have, and oftentimes at far too young an age. The conversations where one of my friends said “it’s one in five, so which one of us is it going to be?” The conversations that we’re forced to have, that are always on our minds. Using Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” and other works of literature, “John Proctor is the Villain” examines the historical and present day blaming of women — the painting of women as the villains — during the Salem witch trials and the MeToo movement. The fear in every woman’s mind of not just the worst happening but also the all too real feeling that people won’t even believe you if it does. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a play that encapsulates girlhood so well. The times when you’re singing Taylor Swift, the times when you’re dancing with your friends, and the times when all you can do is scream. The times when you’re hugging your friends, when you’re standing up for your friends, when you’re standing up to your friends, and when you’re laughing with your friends. This play made me laugh, it made me cry, and it made me want to scream. I seriously can’t recommend it enough.
One time was not enough - found myself back again just one day later. I have been forever changed and will never be able to listen to Green Light the same way again. (Edited)
Holy moly this is a SHOW. The last 10 minutes are incredible. I was so emotional at the end I shot straight to my feet and couldn’t speak for 5 min.
This show culminated into a heaving sob from my seat. Perfect play!
Literally life-changing. As someone that grew up in a small, conservative town and dealt with SA in high school, this play hit home. It’s bold, it’s raw, but it’s empowering. It is very intense but somehow you will be laughing (as well as crying) all the way through.
cried throughout and then completely sobbed at the end, just so beautiful! plus this was sadie’s last show so it was extra special!
Second Time seeing the show and I loved it even more, I cried and laughed it was a very enjoyable show to watch! Loved this and would love to see it get a extended run!
This is actually such a powerful show. Very real high school experience and challenges. Focusing on the “Me Too” movement, speaking out and young girls struggling in that time that we assaulted. Dark comedy notes but overall very moving. Laughing one minute and crying the next. The entire cast was fantastic. Also, I’ve never seen a cast come out so fast to sign play bills, I was pleasantly surprised.
Loved! Great for all teenagers to see and I thought it was really smart. I can’t explain why because it wasn’t sad but for sure I was crying at the end.
This is my favorite show. In 2021 I chose this play for my directing final, my senior year of college. I know the script and envisioned this production extensively so I feared that it wouldn’t live up to the show I created. It was what I wanted in more. I SOBBED in the final moments. Not because it sad or tragic, no one dies, it’s just so powerful. This show means so much to me. The writing, the set, the direction, the lighting, the performances, the story, were all phenomenal.
Cannot express enough how absolutely incredible and moving this play is. It PERFECTLY captures female rage and teenagehood, and tells this specific story with such care and truth. The way they interweave the crucible and the class discussions with what’s “actually” happening in the play is so masterfully done, and the grand reveal had my jaw on the floor. The final performance was chilling, cathartic, and so emotional. Fully had me in tears, ESPECIALLY the “it wasn’t your fault” and dance parts. Please go see this show.
OH MY GOD?? Please go watch this play. It gave me the same feelings as watching the Barbie movie. It celebrates female solidarity and standing up to your oppressors, but is still funny and entertaining! This production had me gripped from beginning to end. Plus the theater itself has a great view. My friend and I had seats in the back row in the lower level and we still had a good view of the whole production. The staff who works there are also friendly and accommodating. I love everything about this experience if you couldn’t already tell lol Will be seeing again!
Wow. What a lovely and amazing play where everyone in the audience was feeling the same things at the same time. I hugged the man next to me after because we both cried at the same times. Everyone was either crying or saying “we made a great choice with this play” afterward. Everyone clapped and cheered at the same times. This play is powerful for ppl like me who have been survivors of sexual assault or have been preyed on. This play was phenomenal and it examined the themes within the crucible (the book). I’ve never read the crucible (don’t judge me), and now I must ! The writer and director are just beautiful ppl. They have to be. This was so healing and so needed. The time is NOW!!!!! The play is also fun and relatable at many points. The characters and the town setting (how it’s described or implied) are so great. I just feel so grateful to have had the opportunity to be in that room. Please watch it, for your spirit— and for the collective ✊🏿 (Also great for teens and young adults ) the message of standing up and speaking up for what’s right and believing victims and supporting friends in need. It just was so powerful. (Edited)
Sobbed.
1–20 of 486 comments
this play sneaks up on you, little by little. going in, i think i basically expected feminist commentary on girlhood and patriarchal hegemony in education–valuable commentary, commentary i agree with–and for that reason, i thought i'd feel a level of intellectual remove. i didn't expect this play to have so much heart, and to be in tears by the end. i thought i'd find the pop culture references cheap or obtrusive, but each reference held extreme narrative and thematic weight. they weren't just there to setting dress or pander to the audience. dear john and greenlight MWAH. the classroom scenes were visceral for me. i really was transported to high school, feeling so angry at what boys were saying in class that i just wanted to scream. the chemistry between the cast was completely there. and the performances were wonderful--fina strazza's physical acting was great, but i was surprised by how much amalia yoo compelled me, and how well she and sadie managed to capture the unique intimacy that is created in every teenage best friendship. enough can't be said about sadie sink, who more than deserves her tony nod, and who i think is a real contender for the trophy. *SPOILERS AHEAD* the catharsis i experienced at the end of this play as an audience member was immense. the way the greenlight sequence was first played for laughs to lull the audience into a false sense of security. and then just lingering on it, having shelby and raelynn give it their all, literally feeling how embodied shelby is in that moment, and how crucial raelynn's support is. i don't know, i just couldn't stop crying. AND THEN WHEN MRS. GALLAGHER STOOD UP TO BLOCK MR. SMITH. it's just so interesting watching this play as a 24 year old woman–i'm close enough to my teen years to remember those exact high school environments, to remember navigating those exact issues (specifically, sexual assault of close female friends who i loved)–but i'm also at a stage in my life now where reliving how suffocating that time period was is nearly unbearable. i really left the play with a true need to do more to protect young girls.