John Proctor is the Villain
My jaw was on the floor with the twist that came in the middle. The high school girls all did a great job and are not getting enough credit for their performances! (Edited)
So I went back and cried MORE at the performance scene. Chills.
This play was so good, that I didn’t dare look at my watch to have an idea when we were getting close to 100 minutes. I wanted it to keep going. I could have watched these characters forever.
Enjoyed it but had trouble hearing the words from the Mezzanine. The girls talked very fast and high pitched voices. Well written and performed
INCREDIBLE. I was in tears the whole time. It captures girlhood, the me too movement, and so much more. I laughed, but was also deeply moved. Highly recommend!
As someone who has had Green Light on her Spotify wrapped every year since it came out, this show was a blessing, a triumph and left me in the best ecstasy of female rage. Didn’t know I needed a whole play centering my favorite song. (Edited)
my god. people keep talking about how stacked the musical category is this season, but the plays have been changing my life. sadie sink. girl. how do you do this 8 times a week. i was /sobbing/ for the last 30 minutes, put green light on repeat for my ride home, and cried the entire time. my god, what a force. please come back and do theatre more often molly and maggie and morgan and fina and amalia. wow. incredible breathtaking stunning beautiful phenomenal i wanted to sleep on this so i could be more articulate in why this play resonated with me, but honestly i still don’t have the words. i don’t think ive ever been so immersed into a story, or seen a more truthful showcase of girlhood. catch me screaming in the woods and creating interpretive dances all summer.
Holy shit, uncontrollable crying during the final scene. In awe of this script and character development. So so so powerful. I love those girls!!!
Extraordinary. Original cast. Obviously Sadie Sink was such a standout but the rest of the cast was equally as incredible. Fina Strazza. Standout performance. Unforgettable. Her timing was everything, her body acting was unbelievable - not enough good words to say. The meaning of this play. Wow. The way each of the girls represented different perspectives on the issue at hand (men in power, using that power and charm, to do what they please and then make everyone believe them and not the woman). I could see a piece of myself in every character. Truly incredible writing. Not only was it deeply impactful and emotional but it was ridiculously hilarious. Every joke landed. The MUSIC. INCREDIBLE. Every detail from the classroom number written in sharpie on the stool to the chipped paint on the molding was to perfection. Bawled our eyes out, laughed so hard we snorted and felt every emotion under the sun. LONG LIVE LIVE THEATER!!!!
i cried. sadie blew us away, her last show.
Audience members: It's 2025, you're watching a play set in 2018 about high school students studying a play written in the 1950s inspired by the Salem witch trials in the 1600s.... And y'all. John Proctor IS the villain. You don't need to know The Crucible to enjoy the layers of brilliance in this show but if you (like me) read or performed in The Crucible as a young high school student... this play is giving SO MUCH. Small theater, I think any seat would be fine. I was rear right orchestra and had a great view of all the action. (Edited)
This show was exactly what I needed, complete with angry feminist rage dancing. Where Teeth was maybe a little over-the-top and Liberation was basic, John Proctor is the Villain is the perfect in between - great storytelling, belly laughs, infuriating realities, and an audience that gasps at all the right moments. The title tells you exactly what is going to happen but the characters bring relatable experiences for many of us (unfortunately). You root them on as you're watching and you feel their pain. At the end, hopefully, you'll dance with them, too. Oh, and I'm definitely re-reading the Crucible.
Absolutely brilliant - felt every single feeling, and felt every word deep within my bones. Left the theatre in a cathartic crying spell and feeling incredibly empowered. I will think about this play for the rest of my life. Thank you Kimberly Bellflower. (Edited)
I could not recommend this play enough!! It complex and emotional. I started out laughing and left the theater in tears. It does in fact contain fricken multitudes!!!!
it perfectly showed how teenagers talk and interact with each other, while still getting a very important message across. i laughed, cried, gasped, literally everything that you could ever think of during this show.
Served me some Eureka Day vibes - excellent cast, the passage of time, the school setting… I also tend to love anything that references a well-known classic work from a new angle. It was a bonus to see all the tween Sadie Sink fans in their Stranger Things T-shirts, accompanied by parents, who probably didn’t know what an excellent, adult show they were about to see.
Such a powerful show, with a fantastic finale. Many of the people around me had tears in their eyes, myself included!
sobbed my way through this one, absolute MASTERPIECE of a show
21–40 of 486 comments
Such a fresh and all out fun night on Broadway! An excellent ensemble piece with Sadie Sink as the cherry on top. There were many times where I cringed while vividly connecting some of the things the characters said to people from my high school 😵💫